RE: [Elecraft] Rob Sherwood's K3 test data -- quick summary

2008-02-11 Thread Darwin, Keith
Actually, Wayne, you have it upside down. The K3 topping Rod's chart simply validates his testing methods. :-) - Keith N1AS - - K2 5411.ssb.100 - - K3 Wave 3 - -Original Message- From: wayne burdick Rob Sherwood, NC0B, an independent and well-known receiver performance specialist, has

Re: [Elecraft] Rob Sherwood's K3 test data -- quick summary

2008-02-10 Thread David Cutter
It's not just vhf contesters who have a problem, we also have 59+60 to 66dB signals from broadcast stations on 40m (and don't forget those nasty sidebands) -10 to -5dBm is not unusual from a high dipole. David G3UNA snip from AD6XY: This is excellent news, especially that -138 dB phase noise

Re: [Elecraft] Rob Sherwood's K3 test data -- quick summary

2008-02-10 Thread AD6XY - Mike
Did Rob comment on pops and transients generated in the AGC and DSP? That was the subject of his presentation at Dayton 2007, where he gave many examples to show that "New IF DSP designs [can] seriously exaggerate transient noise on weak signals... Some DSP radios make QRN much worse." http

Re: [Elecraft] Rob Sherwood's K3 test data -- quick summary

2008-02-10 Thread Ken, KA0W
Yes, the Orion (II) is a "little" unpleasant to listen to unless one perhaps adjusts RF gain down. I enjoyed the excellent filtering on the Orion II when comparing the modified FT-1000D and Pro III, but the Orion II felt "unfinished" for the year and a half I had it. Yes, can maybe blame the ag

Re: [Elecraft] Rob Sherwood's K3 test data -- quick summary

2008-02-10 Thread Barry N1EU
FWIW, my initial listening isn't hearing much difference between the Orion and K3 on transient response. So far, static bursts are sounding pronounced on both radios to my ears. 73, Barry N1EU K4IA wrote: > > In a message dated 2/10/2008 3:17:39 A.M. Eastern Standard Time, > [EMAIL PROTE

Re: [Elecraft] Rob Sherwood's K3 test data -- quick summary

2008-02-10 Thread K4IA
In a message dated 2/10/2008 3:17:39 A.M. Eastern Standard Time, [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: New IF DSP designs [can] seriously exaggerate transient noise on weak signals... Some DSP radios make QRN much worse." I certainly felt that way when listening on the Orion. The AGC was never right.

Re: [Elecraft] Rob Sherwood's K3 test data -- quick summary

2008-02-10 Thread Ian White GM3SEK
Wayne Burdick wrote: Rob Sherwood, NC0B, an independent and well-known receiver performance specialist, has completed his K3 receiver tests. We're pleased with the results, which will place the K3 at the top of his comparison chart. Rob will be updating his web site in a few days. For now, I'l

[Elecraft] Rob Sherwood's K3 test data -- quick summary

2008-02-09 Thread wayne burdick
Rob Sherwood, NC0B, an independent and well-known receiver performance specialist, has completed his K3 receiver tests. We're pleased with the results, which will place the K3 at the top of his comparison chart. Rob will be updating his web site in a few days. For now, I'll just mention a coup