Re: [Elecraft] Ideas for an FT8 Radio

2019-01-03 Thread Edward R Cole
I've been using JT since its advent in early 2000's (I began with JT44 in 2003 using my HB psk-31 computer interface). I only had 110w on 2m using a MOT repeater PA so lucky to get 80w to antennas. But I was using four 10-element yagis, which was considered minimum for CW eme in 1998 if

Re: [Elecraft] Ideas for an FT8 Radio

2019-01-02 Thread Neil Zampella
Carl, you tell that to Joe Taylor, who himself has said he uses the power it takes to make the contact, especially on EME and Meteor Scatter. It is not a low power mode.  For some people using 500w from California results in a - 19 report from  Israel.    That is a weak signal. You use what

Re: [Elecraft] Ideas for an FT8 Radio

2019-01-02 Thread ed
, 02 January, 2019 15:19 To: elecraft@mailman.qth.net Subject: Re: [Elecraft] Ideas for an FT8 Radio On 1/2/2019 2:56 PM, Carl J. Denbow wrote: > While it's legal to run maximum power on FT8, or any other weak signal > mode, it's certainly not in the spirit of the weak signal mode ethos >

Re: [Elecraft] Ideas for an FT8 Radio

2019-01-02 Thread Bill Frantz
I thought I would look through the high power QSOs in my log for Los Gatos, CA to find what I do, instead of what I think I do. I found that I use high power for: The Elecraft SSB net: I frequently need a relay to reach Chicago. DXpeditions: Minimizing the time for my QSO lets others make

Re: [Elecraft] Ideas for an FT8 Radio

2019-01-02 Thread Jim Brown
On 1/2/2019 2:56 PM, Carl J. Denbow wrote: While it's legal to run maximum power on FT8, or any other weak signal mode, it's certainly not in the spirit of the weak signal mode ethos Most weak-signal mode enthusiasts pride themselves on the worldwide contacts they can make with low wattage.

Re: [Elecraft] Ideas for an FT8 Radio

2019-01-02 Thread Bill Rowlett
Dito Carl, well said. I agree 100% Bill KC4IM > On Jan 2, 2019, at 5:56 PM, Carl J. Denbow wrote: > > While it's legal to run maximum power on FT8, or any other weak signal mode, > it's certainly not in the spirit of the weak signal mode ethos Most > weak-signal mode enthusiasts pride

Re: [Elecraft] Ideas for an FT8 Radio

2019-01-02 Thread Carl J. Denbow
While it's legal to run maximum power on FT8, or any other weak signal mode, it's certainly not in the spirit of the weak signal mode ethos  Most weak-signal mode enthusiasts pride themselves on the worldwide contacts they can make with low wattage.  Many feel that 100 watts is QRO on these

Re: [Elecraft] Ideas for an FT8 Radio

2019-01-02 Thread Carl Yaffey
Rick, Thanks for this. Some people seem to think FT8 is a low power mode. It’s a weak signal mode. 73, K8NU > On Jan 1, 2019, at 11:56 PM, Rick Bates (WA6NHC) wrote: > > You run the amount of power required to make the contact, up to the legal > limit. If you wish to operate QRP, that’s

Re: [Elecraft] Ideas for an FT8 Radio

2019-01-02 Thread Wes Stewart
You were wrong, but it's a common misconception. Wes  N7WS On 1/1/2019 9:42 PM, Ken wrote: Geesh, how much power are people running?  I've always thought 50 watts was excessive for digital modes! __ Elecraft mailing list Home:

Re: [Elecraft] Ideas for an FT8 Radio

2019-01-01 Thread Bill Frantz
The short answer for issues of obsolescence is the same for computers as it is for RF components: modularization. I replaced the synthesizers in my K3 when better ones came out. I would expect to do the same for the computer, whether it is integrated into the radio package or separate. I

Re: [Elecraft] Ideas for an FT8 Radio

2019-01-01 Thread Rick Bates (WA6NHC)
You run the amount of power required to make the contact, up to the legal limit. If you wish to operate QRP, that’s your choice. I remind you that RTTY is also digital and full legal limit is common; FT8 is semi-automated RTTY with complex pattern but improved reception. High power is also

Re: [Elecraft] Ideas for an FT8 Radio

2019-01-01 Thread Ken
Geesh, how much power are people running?  I've always thought 50 watts was excessive for digital modes! As for the concept of a dedicated FT8 radio, what's going to happen when FT9 becomes the latest craze?  How many people operate Olivia (or even JT-65) now? Ken WA8JXM On 12/29/18 5:23

Re: [Elecraft] Ideas for an FT8 Radio

2018-12-31 Thread Gwen Patton
They can put it on a separate module. There's space for at least a Raspberry Pi Zero in there, so it could be put on a dedicated board of its own. That way, it wouldn't be software in the main system firmware, it'd be a separate, optional module with its own license. THAT can be GPL. You can sell

Re: [Elecraft] Ideas for an FT8 Radio

2018-12-31 Thread Neil Zampella
As long as the developer is using any part of the WSJT-X code it cannot be added to closed source firmware.    It doesn't matter that it can be done. It would be in violation of the GPL Neil, KN3ILZ On 12/30/2018 8:59 PM, John Harper wrote: Here's the thread - scroll down to message #27527:

Re: [Elecraft] Ideas for an FT8 Radio

2018-12-31 Thread Dennis Moore
That explains the complete and utter failure of the K1 and KX1 to gain any popularity. 73, Dennis NJ6G Happy New Year! On 12/30/2018 17:56, Devin Butterfield wrote: I also agree that a one-mode radio wouldn’t be of interest for very long. — Regards, Devin / K6DRS

Re: [Elecraft] Ideas for an FT8 Radio

2018-12-30 Thread W2xj
Digests are from the early 90s. Totally unnecessary in this day and age. Sent from my iPad > On Dec 30, 2018, at 11:15 PM, Jim Brown wrote: > >> On 12/30/2018 7:36 PM, Wes Stewart wrote: >> For the life of me I don't know what all of the hand-wringing is about with >> OT posts. > > I

Re: [Elecraft] Ideas for an FT8 Radio

2018-12-30 Thread Jim Brown
On 12/30/2018 7:36 PM, Wes Stewart wrote: For the life of me I don't know what all of the hand-wringing is about with OT posts. I suspect that the complaints come from those who choose to read a digest, or who don't use a decent email client. My delete key has always worked quite well. 73,

Re: [Elecraft] Ideas for an FT8 Radio

2018-12-30 Thread Wes Stewart
When a post has "FT8" in the subject line, it's an automatic delete. I only opened this one because Bob wrote it. BTW, I too use Thunderbird, but don't use any filters etc.  I find that I'm perfectly capable of deleting unwanted posts by myself.  For the life of me I don't know what all of

Re: [Elecraft] Ideas for an FT8 Radio

2018-12-30 Thread Bob McGraw K4TAX
My interest is already diminished to zero. 73 Bob, K4TAX On 12/30/2018 7:56 PM, Devin Butterfield wrote: I also agree that a one-mode radio wouldn’t be of interest for very long. __ Elecraft mailing list Home:

Re: [Elecraft] Ideas for an FT8 Radio

2018-12-30 Thread John Harper
Here's the thread - scroll down to message #27527: https://groups.io/g/QRPLabs/topic/no_ft8_in_the_upcoming_qsx/27317246?p=,,,20,0,0,0::recentpostdate%2Fsticky,,,20,2,0,27317246 John AE5X https://ae5x.blogspot.com On Sun, Dec 30, 2018 at 7:56 PM Devin Butterfield <

Re: [Elecraft] Ideas for an FT8 Radio

2018-12-30 Thread Devin Butterfield
One of the potential issues no one has mentioned is that JT and friends released the code for FT8 under the GNU GPL license. This means if you link this into any proprietary closed device or firmware, you would violate the terms of the license. You would have to either: 1. Write a cleanroom

[Elecraft] Ideas for an FT8 Radio

2018-12-30 Thread John Harper
The upcoming QSX kit from G0UPL may have FT8 capability. Hans announced that it will run PSK31, WSPR and RTTY natively, ie on firmware within the rig. Another ham, a Latvian I believe, asked "Why not FT8 too?" Hans offered him a free QSX if he could write the code for FT8 capability to exist

Re: [Elecraft] Ideas for an FT8 Radio

2018-12-30 Thread a******@sbcglobal
That is key. In a little while FT8 will fall out of favor as amateurs move on to the next digital mode, a cycle that has repeated for the entire history of digital modes. An FT8 specific radio wouldn’t interest, but an “infinitely flexible” digital mode platform with integral computer might.

Re: [Elecraft] Ideas for an FT8 Radio

2018-12-30 Thread Lynn W. Taylor, WB6UUT
If the radio was basically a Pi Hat then upgrading the computer would be relatively easy. and using a standard, commonly available computer means that you could run useful modes, and modes that have yet to be invented, not just FT8. 73 -- Lynn On 12/30/2018 1:38 PM, Todd wrote: Have a

Re: [Elecraft] Ideas for an FT8 Radio

2018-12-30 Thread Todd
Have a look at some of OH8STN's you tube videos. He's done a lot of portable FT8 ops and has a lot of neat ideas... Later, Todd KH2TJ Doug Millar via Elecraft wrote: Ok, I am going out on a limb. I have been trying to imagine an FT8 all in one radio.

Re: [Elecraft] Ideas for an FT8 Radio

2018-12-30 Thread Walter Underwood
Two words, “WSJT-X 2.0”. :-) With five year old software, you wouldn’t be running any kind of FT8. I worked on software for test and measurement instruments at HP. Even twenty years ago, software was moving out of the box into general purpose computers. wunder K6WRU Walter Underwood CM87wj

Re: [Elecraft] Ideas for an FT8 Radio

2018-12-30 Thread Jeff Stai
hi Don - Indeed. I had a line in there about being mindful of bluetooth delays but it somehow disappeared. ;) 73 jeff wk6i On Sun, Dec 30, 2018 at 12:55 PM Don Wilhelm wrote: > Jeff, > > Concept is good, but ignores the latency problem with Bluetooth. I > think that would be a "killer" for

Re: [Elecraft] Ideas for an FT8 Radio

2018-12-30 Thread Don Wilhelm
Jeff, Concept is good, but ignores the latency problem with Bluetooth. I think that would be a "killer" for data modes like FT8 which need rather precise timing. To get an idea about the latency of Bluetooth, try monitoring your CW with a Bluetooth headset - unless you are a slow operator,

Re: [Elecraft] Ideas for an FT8 Radio

2018-12-30 Thread Phil Kane
On 12/30/2018 11:20 AM, Walter Underwood wrote: > So after five years, the radio will still be competitive, but the computer > might not even run current software. But then again, why update the software when it's doing the job that it was intended for. A close friend runs his very successful

Re: [Elecraft] Ideas for an FT8 Radio

2018-12-30 Thread W2xj
Unless there is enough demand for someone to make it happen. Sent from my iPad > On Dec 30, 2018, at 2:26 PM, Jeff Stai wrote: > > Hmmm... as long as you use a generic tablet with a KX2, you're going to > have a box and wires. You could go tablet to USB box and then maybe find > wireless

Re: [Elecraft] Ideas for an FT8 Radio

2018-12-30 Thread Jeff Stai
Hmmm... as long as you use a generic tablet with a KX2, you're going to have a box and wires. You could go tablet to USB box and then maybe find wireless solutions from there. I see there are chargeable bluetooth audio receivers, for example. I've never seen a simple USB wireless extension,

Re: [Elecraft] Ideas for an FT8 Radio

2018-12-30 Thread Walter Underwood
One issue with an all-in-one is that computer technology improves much, much faster than radio technology. So after five years, the radio will still be competitive, but the computer might not even run current software. wunder K6WRU Walter Underwood CM87wj http://observer.wunderwood.org/ (my

Re: [Elecraft] Ideas for an FT8 Radio

2018-12-30 Thread Doug Millar via Elecraft
Hi Jeff, Good ideas all around. Of course i was thinking of the KX2 and a tablet. I actually went portable in the with that setup. What I didn't like was all the wires and the USB box. If I could get straight from the KX2 to the tablet with audio and rig control that might do the trick. What do

Re: [Elecraft] Ideas for an FT8 Radio

2018-12-30 Thread Jeff Stai
Well, since we are dreaming about things that probably won't happen...;) An all in one appeals because it is portable, perhaps even trail ready. There are plenty of good mini keyboard/trackpads units already out there, so use one of those. Since you are using an external keyboard, skip the

Re: [Elecraft] Ideas for an FT8 Radio

2018-12-29 Thread Rick Bates (WA6NHC)
50-70 watts out is fine, that will provide adequate drive for most amps to run their full rated power out. If you don’t want that much, turn it down. Rick WA6NHC Smell Czech correction happen > On Dec 29, 2018, at 1:54 PM, Bill Rowlett wrote: > > 25 watts out max. > > KC4IM Bill > > >>

Re: [Elecraft] Ideas for an FT8 Radio

2018-12-29 Thread Bill Rowlett
25 watts out max. KC4IM Bill > On Dec 29, 2018, at 4:16 PM, Doug Millar via Elecraft > wrote: > > Ok, I am going out on a limb. I have been trying to imagine an FT8 all in one > radio. How about this- A radio that is 6 by 10" or so with a screen that lays > flat on top and swivels up for

[Elecraft] Ideas for an FT8 Radio

2018-12-29 Thread Doug Millar via Elecraft
Ok, I am going out on a limb. I have been trying to imagine an FT8 all in one radio. How about this- A radio that is 6 by 10" or so with a screen that lays flat on top and swivels up for use. Mouse but only and an optional keyboard since the programs are primarily mouse driven. The computer