Re: Harmonics -- WSJ opinion.

2001-02-28 Thread John Woodgate
4203d61676d0ae468aa5cea90a891c13235...@cof110avexu4.global.avaya.com, Wagner, John P johnwag...@avaya.com inimitably wrote: The European harmonics standard IEC 61000-3-2, and I call it European because that is exactly what it is, Indeed, that's because (and it is a matter of record)

RE: Harmonics -- WSJ opinion.

2001-02-28 Thread Wagner, John P
McInturff[SMTP:gary.mcintu...@worldwidepackets.com] Reply To: Gary McInturff Sent: Tuesday, February 27, 2001 8:55 AM To: 'John Juhasz'; 'Rich Nute'; emc-p...@majordomo.ieee.org Subject: RE: Harmonics -- WSJ opinion. Years ago when switch mode power supplies were really first

Re: Harmonics -- WSJ opinion.

2001-02-28 Thread John Woodgate
of318a279e.2188070d-on85256a00.006a3...@somers.hqregion.ibm.com, Edward Jones ejjo...@us.ibm.com inimitably wrote: John, in response to your attached thread you may want to review some of the field surveys that are available from the Low Frequency Emissions Industry Coalition (LFEIC) @

Re: Harmonics -- WSJ opinion.

2001-02-27 Thread John Woodgate
200102271645.iaa00...@epgc196.sdd.hp.com, Rich Nute ri...@sdd.hp.com inimitably wrote: Of course, no one has shown that unacceptable overheating will actually occur. Do you have any more such gems to contribute? What do you think happens to the total current through a capacitor

RE: Harmonics -- WSJ opinion.

2001-02-27 Thread Edward Jones
To: 'Rich Nute' ri...@sdd.hp.com, emc-p...@majordomo.ieee.org cc: Subject: RE: Harmonics -- WSJ opinion. Rich, I would think that you knew that this would generate discussion? One comment of Mr Hunter's that stood out in particular was the very last . . . . . . the only ones who benefit from

Re: Harmonics -- WSJ opinion.

2001-02-27 Thread Rich Nute
Hi John: Of course, no one has shown that unacceptable overheating will actually occur. Do you have any more such gems to contribute? What do you think happens to the total current through a capacitor when the applied voltage contains harmonics? What happens to the I^2R

Re: Harmonics -- WSJ opinion.

2001-02-27 Thread Robert Johnson
[mailto:jjuh...@fiberoptions.com] Sent: Monday, February 26, 2001 10:37 AM To: 'Rich Nute'; emc-p...@majordomo.ieee.org Subject: RE: Harmonics -- WSJ opinion. Rich, I would think that you knew that this would generate discussion? One comment of Mr Hunter's

RE: Harmonics -- WSJ opinion.

2001-02-27 Thread Gary McInturff
Subject: RE: Harmonics -- WSJ opinion. Rich, I would think that you knew that this would generate discussion? One comment of Mr Hunter's that stood out in particular was the very last . . . . . . the only ones who benefit from the harmonic current emission standard are the European electricity

Re: FW: Harmonics -- WSJ opinion.

2001-02-27 Thread John Woodgate
nebbjkpamlaglbmfcdnnceigcdaa.jo...@medson.com, Jon Griver jo...@medson.com wrote: He either pays the manufacturer for increased design and manufacturing costs for compliance with the harmonics standard, or he pays the electric company for increased infrastructure. True, but the

FW: Harmonics -- WSJ opinion.

2001-02-27 Thread Jon Griver
RE: Harmonics -- WSJ opinion.Rich, John It's of no interest to the consumer. He pays in any case. He either pays the manufacturer for increased design and manufacturing costs for compliance with the harmonics standard, or he pays the electric company for increased infrastructure. Best Wishes,

Re: Harmonics -- WSJ opinion.

2001-02-27 Thread John Woodgate
E15CFB09B1FAD311B74700D0B746BDC12CC814@EMAIL, John Juhasz jjuh...@fiberoptions.com wrote: I like to give the benefit of the doubt that the standard was created based on sound technical evidence. It was based on INADEQUATE technical evidence, but not on NO technical evidence. Also

Re: Harmonics -- WSJ opinion.

2001-02-27 Thread John Woodgate
200102262030.maa28...@epgc196.sdd.hp.com, Rich Nute ri...@sdd.hp.com wrote: Of course, no one has shown that unacceptable overheating will actually occur. Do you have any more such gems to contribute? What do you think happens to the total current through a capacitor when the applied voltage

Re: Harmonics -- WSJ opinion.

2001-02-26 Thread Rich Nute
Hi John: I must admit to several motives for posting my message regarding the WSJ-E opinion article. 1. I wanted our subscribers to know that the issue rated comment in the WSJ-E, a high- level, respected newspaper. 2. I wanted our subscribers to know that the technical

Re: Harmonics -- WSJ opinion.

2001-02-26 Thread John Woodgate
200102261711.jaa27...@epgc196.sdd.hp.com, Rich Nute ri...@sdd.hp.com wrote: With thanks to Ed Jones... On Thusday, February 22, The Wall Street Journal Europe published an interesting opinion on the harmonic current emissions standard. The opinion is by Rob Hunter, a lawyer and Chairman of

RE: Harmonics -- WSJ opinion.

2001-02-26 Thread John Juhasz
...@sdd.hp.com mailto:ri...@sdd.hp.com ] Sent: Monday, February 26, 2001 12:11 PM To: emc-p...@majordomo.ieee.org Subject: Harmonics -- WSJ opinion. With thanks to Ed Jones... On Thusday, February 22, The Wall Street Journal Europe published an interesting opinion on the harmonic current

Harmonics -- WSJ opinion.

2001-02-26 Thread Rich Nute
With thanks to Ed Jones... On Thusday, February 22, The Wall Street Journal Europe published an interesting opinion on the harmonic current emissions standard. The opinion is by Rob Hunter, a lawyer and Chairman of the Centre for the New Europe, a Brussels-based think tank. Mr. Hunter is