Re: [Emc-users] Incorporation & Donation [Was: Re: What's coming in manufacturing]

2009-04-20 Thread Jim Fleig - CNC Services
Steve, The following comment from your email states my sentiments very well. >> >> > I don't think that paid programming prevents volunteer work. What I > don't think I want to see is a corporate entity that thinks it should > direct volunteers to do things they don't want to do, and doesn't acc

Re: [Emc-users] Incorporation & Donation [Was: Re: What's coming in manufacturing]

2009-04-19 Thread Rainer Schmidt
You do not need a bounty system or anything along that line. A commercial venture can be formed and the development of the software can be co-sponsored with services provided. Software enhancements would have to be shared as it is right now. No harm done, and the best beta testing in the world. Win

Re: [Emc-users] Incorporation & Donation [Was: Re: What's coming in manufacturing]

2009-04-19 Thread amtb
Hi I think EMC2 can not be compare to RED HAT software. After price for Red Hat will be too high computer mfg will switch to UBUNTU or next in line Linux distribution. Software EMC2 by them self doesn’t have whole much volume. Use EMC2 to apply to each particular job – retrofit real machine or buil

Re: [Emc-users] Incorporation & Donation [Was: Re: What's coming in manufacturing]

2009-04-19 Thread Rob Jansen
I would not mind saying thank you to the developers or the volunteers at the shows by buying them a beer, lunch or maybe even some hardware to play with. We do have nice beers in the Netherlands ;-) Cheers, Rob On Sun, Apr 19, 2009 at 7:36 PM, Stuart Stevenson wrote: > After I win the lotter

Re: [Emc-users] Incorporation & Donation [Was: Re: What's coming in manufacturing]

2009-04-19 Thread Stuart Stevenson
Gentlemen, I just saw a comment by the 'owner' of Ubuntu. "Ubuntu does not have a positive cash flow." "He doesn't mind supporting it for the next three to five years." Does this mean Ubuntu will not be free in five years? Maybe EMC should develop a kernel of its own? :) (I am not

Re: [Emc-users] Incorporation & Donation [Was: Re: What's coming in manufacturing]

2009-04-19 Thread Stephen Wille Padnos
John Guenther wrote: >For whatever my opinion may or may not be worth, I think well enough >should be left alone. EMC2 seems to be moving along just fine without >the 'commercial' headaches! It seems to me that EMC2 is being developed >by some dedicated hard working people that are more interest

Re: [Emc-users] Incorporation & Donation [Was: Re: What's coming in manufacturing]

2009-04-19 Thread Stephen Wille Padnos
Ian W. Wright wrote: >Ok, lots of fine talk from people who are mostly interested >in using EMC2 for commercial purposes but where would this >'donation' or 'bounty' system leave the amateur who is >struggling to build a system and the knowledge to use it on >a shoestring? > The "average user

Re: [Emc-users] Incorporation & Donation [Was: Re: What's coming in manufacturing]

2009-04-19 Thread John Guenther
For whatever my opinion may or may not be worth, I think well enough should be left alone. EMC2 seems to be moving along just fine without the 'commercial' headaches! It seems to me that EMC2 is being developed by some dedicated hard working people that are more interested in making it right than

Re: [Emc-users] Incorporation & Donation [Was: Re: What's coming in manufacturing]

2009-04-19 Thread Ian W. Wright
Ok, lots of fine talk from people who are mostly interested in using EMC2 for commercial purposes but where would this 'donation' or 'bounty' system leave the amateur who is struggling to build a system and the knowledge to use it on a shoestring? Surely this was one of the main reasons EMC2 w

Re: [Emc-users] Incorporation & Donation [Was: Re: What's coming in manufacturing]

2009-04-19 Thread Erik Christiansen
On Sun, Apr 19, 2009 at 12:08:30PM +0300, Alex Joni wrote: > > One system I've seen on some projects that might be applied on EMC/emc2 is a > "bounty" system. > Basicly a database where donors add their feature request, and the amount of > money they are willing to pay for that feature. > Develo

Re: [Emc-users] Incorporation & Donation [Was: Re: What's coming in manufacturing]

2009-04-19 Thread Alex Joni
Donations to an emc2 entity (whatever form it would have) are basicly hard to manage. Sure the donor can suggest what the money should be used for, but still "someone" has to decide specifically "who" should get the money. I find that as a potential source for tensions. (lots of bad scenarios c

[Emc-users] Incorporation & Donation [Was: Re: What's coming in manufacturing]

2009-04-19 Thread Erik Christiansen
On Sun, Apr 19, 2009 at 12:43:42AM -0400, Stephen Wille Padnos wrote: > If we create a non-profit, there are massive IRS reporting > requirements. The entity would most likely need to hire an accountant. > (I believe there are quarterly reports, similar to 941 tax filings for Must the entity