Re: [-empyre-] Game Art as an art subculture?

2011-01-01 Thread Gabriel Menotti
Dear all, In the final moments of the year, the debate was rekindled in such a way that foregrounded the heterogeneity of perspectives over the game/ art distinction. This heterogeneity was expected, given the different backgrounds of the participants, and it should be welcome, in as much as it

Re: [-empyre-] Game Art as an art subculture?

2010-12-30 Thread Rafael Trindade
Hello, folks, Not a few times I've prepared myself to post something and got to stop just because your messages did my job better :) I just regret missing this latest topic, for I was afraid that kind of contention would happen. I find it a pity, and I'll try to show you why: The Picasso

Re: [-empyre-] Game Art as an art subculture?

2010-12-30 Thread davin heckman
In some ways, I think the question of games as art can be enriched by looking back to poiesis and techne. On the one hand, we are trying to describe formal questions of how someone creates a representation of something (a sculpture, a text, a game, a painting, an utterance) which is expressed

Re: [-empyre-] Game Art as an art subculture?

2010-12-30 Thread Julian Oliver
..on Thu, Dec 30, 2010 at 01:14:11PM -0500, davin heckman wrote: In some ways, I think the question of games as art can be enriched by looking back to poiesis and techne. I must admit to finding this entire thread largely redundant. Surely the very attempt at discerning whether or not videogame

Re: [-empyre-] Game Art as an art subculture?

2010-12-24 Thread Gabriel Menotti
Hey! “Games have repeatedly shied away from tying their dominant value to external systems.” [Daniel Cook] Value is a dubious measure for us to use. On the one hand, it is way too relative and personal; on the other, it seems to me that the art system is more and more aiming towards pure value

Re: [-empyre-] Game Art as an art subculture?

2010-12-23 Thread micha cárdenas
2010/12/22 Daniel Cook d...@spryfox.com: strongly driven by economic processes.  What is the economic function of art institutes in the creation of games and do we need them?  Historically, it seems that the modern art world acts as a certification process to ensure quality combined with a

Re: [-empyre-] Game Art as an art subculture?

2010-12-23 Thread Domenico Quaranta
Hi dears, thank you very much for your feedback. It took some time to go through all the emails, but I did it. I know that any discussion on what's art and what's not usually enters a dead end. I also know that the contemporary art world often works in a way that makes many people get

Re: [-empyre-] Game Art as an art subculture?

2010-12-23 Thread Daniel Cook
Hi Daniel, I think this is an astute observation about the commercialization of art, but I think there's a more complex process involved here. Would you agree that both art institutions and artists and game makers all rely on reputation building? Some of the strength of art institutions is

Re: [-empyre-] Game Art as an art subculture?

2010-12-23 Thread Daniel Cook
The following step is social agreement: other people talking the language of art have to accept it as an art work. And the last step is certification and attribution of economic value. Daniel wrote: And this strikes me as a major difference between games and much of what goes as art.

Re: [-empyre-] Game Art as an art subculture?

2010-12-22 Thread Domenico Quaranta
Dear Adam, thank you very much for your reply! I do not know whether the Mattes were aware that they created a collection of fictitious enactments of the media-created dangerous video games fiction. Actually, I didn't know about the angry german kid meme, but I'm pretty sure the Mattes

Re: [-empyre-] Game Art as an art subculture?

2010-12-22 Thread Paolo Ruffino
Hi everyone, sorry for the late reply -Xmas is a really slow time :) there are quite a lot of things to say and comment, and is very difficult to decide where to start from... On 22 December 2010 11:14, Domenico Quaranta qrn...@yahoo.it wrote: Maybe Paolo can add some interesting thoughts here.

[-empyre-] Game Art as an art subculture?

2010-12-21 Thread Domenico Quaranta
Dear Empyrers, I've been a lurker on this list for a long time, always reading interesting discussions. And I'm really happy to have been invited to contribute to one of them. As an art critic, I've always been interested in the impact of new technologies on artistic production and