Re: the latest splat

2004-09-10 Thread Michael Turner
You've still got a problem with streamlined water landing: if you use regular ablative shielding techniques, you need a blunt body reentering blunt-face-downward. So you have to either reorient the whole craft to a sharp-point-downward attitude, or separate the payload carrier and do some such ma

Re: The Andromeda Strain (was Re: the latest splat)

2004-09-10 Thread Michael Turner
Larry writes: "[Bell] even got some of the facts wrong about TAS:  The Scoop 7 return capsule was not torn open from an impact.  It actually landed successfully.  The problem began when some of the townsfolk in the little New Mexico community it landed in took the capsule to the local doctor

Re: The Andromeda Strain (was Re: the latest splat)

2004-09-10 Thread Michael Turner
> Michael, Larry, et al., > > I didn't know that Jeff has apparently retired. That's how his articles are signed - he has at least retired from space science in some sense. Isn't he still on the faculty though? > He writes a good > article, but why he thinks there are no Mars meteorites is be

Re: the latest splat

2004-09-10 Thread James McEnanly
Or rather a cone, weighted so that the apex points more or less in the direction of travel. Think of a high diver --- Gary McMurtry <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > The question would be can you design a vehicle to > transition from air > to water at 200+ miles per hour with minimum shock? > >

Fw: Genesis Scientists Bouncing Back From Hard Landing

2004-09-10 Thread LARRY KLAES
  - Original Message - From: NASA Jet Propulsion Laboratory To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Friday, September 10, 2004 3:15 PM Subject: Genesis Scientists Bouncing Back From Hard Landing MEDIA RELATIONS OFFICEJET PROPULSION LABORATORYCALIFORNIA INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGYNATIONAL AERONAUTI

The Andromeda Strain (was Re: the latest splat)

2004-09-10 Thread Gary McMurtry
Michael, Larry, et al., I didn't know that Jeff has apparently retired. He writes a good article, but why he thinks there are no Mars meteorites is beyond me. There are plenty of good, solid scientific reasons to believe so, and I think Jeff is in a tiny minority here. So being, then Zubrin's

Re: the latest splat

2004-09-10 Thread Gary McMurtry
The question would be can you design a vehicle to transition from air to water at 200+ miles per hour with minimum shock? Shape it to dive like a duck, then come back up to float on surface, with finder beacons. That a good idea A system can be designed to use a streamlined capsule that could

Re: the latest splat

2004-09-10 Thread Joe Latrell
That a good idea A system can be designed to use a streamlined capsule that could hit the water at rather high velocity without jarring the payload. Make it bouyant and you get it back when it floats to the surface. If something goes wrong and it cracks when hitting the water, you would at lea

Re: the latest splat

2004-09-10 Thread James McEnanly
In the early manned space program, all of the capsules landed at sea. How well would a water landing work? --- Michael Turner <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > > I'm told they might have used the kind of balloons > they used on the recent > Martian landings, but that would have greatly > increased

The Andromeda Strain (was Re: the latest splat)

2004-09-10 Thread LARRY KLAES
I am rather surprised at Bell's dumping upon of the 1971 SF film The Andromeda Strain, which is one of the very few SF films I have ever seen that strove hard to get the science and technology right (for the early 1970s, of course).  And I thought the scientists in the film acted like scient

Fw: Genesis Mission Status: Conducting Inventory of Canister

2004-09-10 Thread LARRY KLAES
  - Original Message - From: NASA Jet Propulsion Laboratory To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Thursday, September 09, 2004 6:51 PM Subject: Genesis Mission Status: Conducting Inventory of Canister MEDIA RELATIONS OFFICEJET PROPULSION LABORATORYCALIFORNIA INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGYNATIONAL A

Re: the latest splat

2004-09-10 Thread Michael Turner
Jeff Bell is a bit depressed about this whole thing.   http://www.spacedaily.com/news/oped-04z.html   He slightly disparages mid-air helicopter retrieval, even though that seemed to be one of the bits of good news in this story: it can be done.   He also has some rather unkind words for Rob

Re: the latest splat

2004-09-10 Thread Michael Turner
> I'm told they might have used the kind of balloons they used on the recent Martian landings, but that would have greatly increased the weight -- and therefore > the cost -- of what was supposed to be a relatively inexpensive return system. But I bet they're rethinking that now. Maybe the ba