RE: Re: Teleportation thought experiment and UD+ASSA

2006-06-23 Thread Stathis Papaioannou
Hal Finney writes: > The problem is that there seems to be no basis for judging the validity > of this kind of analysis. Do we die every instant? Do we survive sleep > but not being frozen? Do we live on in our copies? Does our identity > extend to all conscious entities? There are so many q

RE: Re: Teleportation thought experiment and UD+ASSA

2006-06-22 Thread "Hal Finney"
"Stathis Papaioannou" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: > OK, I think I'm clear on what you're saying now. But suppose I argue > that I will not survive the next hour, because the matter making up my > synapses will have turned over in this time. To an outside observer the > person taking my place would

RE: Re: Teleportation thought experiment and UD+ASSA

2006-06-21 Thread Stathis Papaioannou
Hal Finney writes:   > > Yes, but every theoretical scientist hopes ultimately to be vindicated> > by the experimentalists. I'm now not sure what you mean by the second> > sentence in the above quote. What would you expect to find if (classical,> > destructive) teleportation of a subject in Bruss

RE: Re: Teleportation thought experiment and UD+ASSA

2006-06-21 Thread "Hal Finney"
"Stathis Papaioannou" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: > Hal Finney writes: > > I should first mention that I did not anticipate the conclusion that > > I reached when I did that analysis. I did not expect to conclude that > > teleportation like this would probably not work (speaking figurately). > >

RE: Re: Teleportation thought experiment and UD+ASSA

2006-06-21 Thread Stathis Papaioannou
Hal Finney writes:   > I should first mention that I did not anticipate the conclusion that> I reached when I did that analysis.  I did not expect to conclude that> teleportation like this would probably not work (speaking figurately).> This was not the starting point of the analysis, but the con