Re: [Finale] Notating Suspendeds

2005-04-26 Thread Simon Troup
In pop music, Gsus2 (i.e., G A D) is a very common chord, especially for keyboard players. G A C D is used _much_ less frequently, and requires a different chord symbol -- usually Gsus (add2). Sorry to be dense, but where is the suspended resolution in such chord as Gsus2? ?? A to be

[Finale] Notating Suspendeds

2005-04-25 Thread Jacki Barineau
Hi, Everyone... I was wondering what the rule is as far as when to call a chord a suspended chord or an add X chord. For example, a Gsus4 - meaning G in the root, then C, then D... I have seen this same chord sometimes labelled as a GaddC or Gadd4. Is it only referred to as the suspended 4th

Re: [Finale] Notating Suspendeds

2005-04-25 Thread Taris L Flashpaw
To me a sus4 chord and an add4 chord are different. The sus4 has no third, whereas the add4 would probably have one. The difference between a 9 and a sus2/add2 chord is whether or not the 7th is present. An add 2/add9 chord is just a major triad with a second/ninth added. A 9th chord implies a

Re: [Finale] Notating Suspendeds

2005-04-25 Thread Darcy James Argue
Hi Jacki, On 25 Apr 2005, at 11:58 AM, Jacki Barineau wrote: I was wondering what the rule is as far as when to call a chord a suspended chord or an add X chord. For example, a Gsus4 - meaning G in the root, then C, then D... I have seen this same chord sometimes labelled as a GaddC or Gadd4.

Re: [Finale] Notating Suspendeds

2005-04-25 Thread Christopher Smith
On Apr 25, 2005, at 2:32 PM, Darcy James Argue wrote: Chris, Anyone who does much studio work out here reads Gsus2 as G A D. Maybe a jazz player who doesn't play a lot of pop music would make the rookie mistake of adding a C to Gsus2, but all the experienced session players here know there's

Re: [Finale] Notating Suspendeds

2005-04-25 Thread Darcy James Argue
5 Apr 2005, at 2:45 PM, A-NO-NE Music wrote: Darcy James Argue / 05.4.25 / 02:32 PM wrote: In pop music, Gsus2 (i.e., G A D) is a very common chord, especially for keyboard players. G A C D is used _much_ less frequently, and requires a different chord symbol -- usually Gsus (add2). Sorry to be

Re: [Finale] Notating Suspendeds

2005-04-25 Thread Jacki Barineau
on 4/25/05 1:01 PM, Darcy James Argue wrote: * Some guy I knew at NEC wrote a tune called What a Friend We Have in Gsus. Oh how funny!! :) Thanks for the explanations, everyone - I think I get it now! Basically, if a chord has the root, third, and fifth and then an additional note - it's an

Re: [Finale] Notating Suspendeds

2005-04-25 Thread Darcy James Argue
On 25 Apr 2005, at 2:46 PM, Christopher Smith wrote: On Apr 25, 2005, at 2:32 PM, Darcy James Argue wrote: Chris, Anyone who does much studio work out here reads Gsus2 as G A D. Maybe a jazz player who doesn't play a lot of pop music would make the rookie mistake of adding a C to Gsus2, but all

Re: [Finale] Notating Suspendeds

2005-04-25 Thread Darcy James Argue
On 25 Apr 2005, at 3:30 PM, Jacki Barineau wrote: on 4/25/05 1:01 PM, Darcy James Argue wrote: * Some guy I knew at NEC wrote a tune called What a Friend We Have in Gsus. Oh how funny!! :) Thanks for the explanations, everyone - I think I get it now! Basically, if a chord has the root, third,

Re: [Finale] Notating Suspendeds

2005-04-25 Thread Christopher Smith
On Apr 25, 2005, at 3:30 PM, Jacki Barineau wrote: Thanks for the explanations, everyone - I think I get it now! Basically, if a chord has the root, third, and fifth and then an additional note - it's an add X... If it's missing the 3rd and has the 4th - it's a sus or sus4. If it's missing

Re: [Finale] Notating Suspendeds

2005-04-25 Thread Christopher Smith
On Apr 25, 2005, at 3:35 PM, Darcy James Argue wrote: We all have to go with the chord symbols that are going to be understood by the players we're writing for. But there's nothing inherently confusing or ambiguous about Gsus2 -- it's used (correctly) in hundreds of pop music publications And

Re: [Finale] Notating Suspendeds

2005-04-25 Thread A-NO-NE Music
Christopher Smith / 05.4.25 / 04:00 PM wrote: But keep in mind that sus2 is a relatively new addition to chord symbol nomenclature. The original standard symbol for this was omit3 G(add9) which is completely clear, I can buy this, totally. This is what I hear when I hear G - A - D