Re: [Fis] Re: Continuing Discussion of Social and Cultural Complexity

2007-02-05 Thread Robert Ulanowicz
On Fri, 2 Feb 2007, Pedro Marijuan wrote: > Dear Igor and colleagues, > > Your question is fascinating, perhaps at the time being rather puzzling or > even un-answerable... Pedro, Yes, unanswerable in the absolute sense, but there are some quantitative approximations that yield helpful insights.

Re: [Fis] Re: Continuing Discussion of Social and Cultural Complexity

2007-02-05 Thread Igor Matutinovic
Reply to Steven and Ted By "genetic constraints" I assume you simply mean that we have certain capacities and are not omnipotent. Is not conflict and war an indicator of our individual failure to manage social complexity? Or would you argue that war is social complexity management? I was

Re: [Fis] Re: Continuing Discussion of Social and Cultural Complexity

2007-02-02 Thread Guy A Hoelzer
Greetings All, I have a different take on the limits of complexity, and perhaps the process of complexification, based on the Prigogine paradigm of dissipative systems. >From this point of view, I would argue that the extent of complexification that can be physically supported by a system depends

Re: [Fis] Re: Continuing Discussion of Social and Cultural Complexity

2007-02-02 Thread Steven Ericsson-Zenith
25 3681 [EMAIL PROTECTED] ; http://www.leydesdorff.net/ -Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Pedro Marijuan Sent: Friday, February 02, 2007 2:39 PM To: fis@listas.unizar.es Subject: Re: [Fis] Re: Continuing Discussion of Social and Cultural C

Re: [Fis] Re: Continuing Discussion of Social and Cultural Complexity

2007-02-02 Thread Stanley N. Salthe
Reacting to both Igor's, Pedro's & Ted's communications: The many complexities facing us as society can be parsed as follows, using a specification hierarcy: {physical constraints (material/chemical constraints {biological constraints {sociocultural constraints. Here we an apply Ted's: "My und

RE: [Fis] Re: Continuing Discussion of Social and Cultural Complexity

2007-02-02 Thread Loet Leydesdorff
to:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Pedro Marijuan > Sent: Friday, February 02, 2007 2:39 PM > To: fis@listas.unizar.es > Subject: Re: [Fis] Re: Continuing Discussion of Social and > Cultural Complexity > > Dear Igor and colleagues, > > Your question is fascinating, perhaps at the

Re: [Fis] Re: Continuing Discussion of Social and Cultural Complexity

2007-02-02 Thread Ted Goranson
Steven Ericsson-Zenith wrote on 2/2/07: Or would you argue that war is social complexity management? Interpreting the term as you have, I would probably present that war is merely part of the dynamics of social systems but indicative of the inability of single humans (or small groups) to "man

Re: [Fis] Re: Continuing Discussion of Social and Cultural Complexity

2007-02-02 Thread James N Rose
Point of reference. At the first ICCS conference on Complexity at Nashua NH, USA in 1997, I presented the concept that Complexity is driven and established by communication probabilities between agent systems, with entropy-related re-distribution of information or energy or mass, being the direct

Re: [Fis] Re: Continuing Discussion of Social and Cultural Complexity

2007-02-02 Thread Steven Ericsson-Zenith
On Feb 2, 2007, at 5:07 AM, Igor Matutinovic (by way of Pedro Marijuan <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>) wrote: ... Considering that we necessarily operate under certain genetic constraints, are there (absolute) upper limits to our ability to manage social complexity? ... By "genetic constraints" I

Re: [Fis] Re: Continuing Discussion of Social and Cultural Complexity

2007-02-02 Thread Pedro Marijuan
Dear Igor and colleagues, Your question is fascinating, perhaps at the time being rather puzzling or even un-answerable... What are the complexity limits of societies? Our individual limits are obvious ---the size of "natural bands" depended both on ecosystems and on the number of people wit

Re: [Fis] Re: Continuing Discussion of Social and Cultural Complexity

2007-02-02 Thread Igor Matutinovic
Dear All I agree with Pedro's perspective, it looks very reasonable from the standpoint of social sciences. I would like to put a question to Joe and other colleagues regarding the constraints of managing social complexity (whatever, objective or perceived). Humanity has reached a high histo