Re: [Flightgear-devel] Grr... I am so angry

2008-12-29 Thread LeeE
I'd like to thank the people who have responded to my rant - they have all done so in a considered, thoughtful and positive manner and have not taken anything personally, for which I am extremely relieved. While some people have pointed out that work is already being done to address some of th

Re: [Flightgear-devel] Grr... I am so angry

2008-12-29 Thread Stuart Buchanan
Hi Lee, Thanks for taking the time to write. It's well worth airing these issues, even if I disagree completely with your analysis. :) Others have already addressed a number of points, but my own tuppence is below. LeeE wrote: > Hello dev list, > > If you're in no mood to critically appraise

Re: [Flightgear-devel] Grr... I am so angry

2008-12-29 Thread James Turner
(I essentially agree with everything Tim, but want to add one technical detail) On 29 Dec 2008, at 13:12, Tim Moore wrote: > Putting snark > aside, I'd suggest that FG is not in as bad shape as you think. The > property > system is already a great mechanism for communication among the sub- >

Re: [Flightgear-devel] Grr... I am so angry

2008-12-29 Thread Matthew Tippett
I agree with Tim here. There are many secondary benefits of time-boxed releases. Getting bugfixes and mindshare improves interactions with the user community and attracts users which ultimately attracts new developers. Of course there is a percentage effort cost to ensure broad stability - but u

Re: [Flightgear-devel] Grr... I am so angry

2008-12-29 Thread Tim Moore
LeeE wrote: > Hello dev list, > > If you're in no mood to critically appraise a rant then read no > further. > > For quite a while now, since I stopped actively contributing to FG, > I've been sitting here watching the direction in which FG > development is heading and if ever there was a good

Re: [Flightgear-devel] Grr... I am so angry

2008-12-28 Thread Jon S. Berndt
> What finally broke this camel's back was the thread about release > schedules, but it goes further than that. The idea of release schedules for an open source project struck me as odd, as well. Jon -- ___