Re: Patching with GIT/SVN (Re: Making MinOptMax Immutable)

2009-11-04 Thread Vincent Hennebert
. More below: Alexander Kiel wrote: Hi Max, you are right. It's always better to have small patches focused on one thing. I don't get my MinOptMax patch focused only on the refactoring of making MinOptMax immutable. In the last half-an-hour I walked myself through all the diffs, file

Re: Patching with GIT/SVN (Re: Making MinOptMax Immutable)

2009-11-04 Thread Max Berger
Hi *, Vincent Hennebert schrieb: Hi, Looks like Max is busy with more urgent things :-) Yes, work keeps me occupied most of the time. I was actually just looking at the patch again, and decided that I am unable to apply it, because I do cannot verify if the renames are correct, as it affects

Re: Patching with GIT/SVN (Re: Making MinOptMax Immutable)

2009-11-04 Thread Alexander Kiel
Hi Max, One more thing I noticed: Alex, you are introducing deprecated methods and then using them. Please either - don't mark the methods as deprecated, if they are valid helper methods or - don't use the deprecated methods, but rather use whatever you inted to replace it with. I marked

Patching with GIT/SVN (Re: Making MinOptMax Immutable)

2009-10-29 Thread Max Berger
Hi Alex, Hi *, if you do not yet have FOP developer access, and you are working on a larger set of problems, please do not submit one large patch - current committers will not have the time to go through every single change. Instead, it is much nicer to have a series of small patches. One option

Re: Patching with GIT/SVN (Re: Making MinOptMax Immutable)

2009-10-29 Thread Alexander Kiel
Hi Max, you are right. It's always better to have small patches focused on one thing. I don't get my MinOptMax patch focused only on the refactoring of making MinOptMax immutable. In the last half-an-hour I walked myself through all the diffs, file-by-file. I must say - except from

Re: Making MinOptMax Immutable

2009-10-27 Thread Alexander Kiel
Hi, a issued a patch for MinOptMax: https://issues.apache.org/bugzilla/show_bug.cgi?id=48071 Please read my first comment there and consider my patch :-) Best Regards Alex On Sun, 2009-10-25 at 23:45 +0100, Alexander Kiel wrote: Hi, the class MinOptMax has some 800 usages in FOP. It holds

Making MinOptMax Immutable

2009-10-25 Thread Alexander Kiel
Hi, the class MinOptMax has some 800 usages in FOP. It holds a triple of values (min, opt, max) of length quantities. It's heavily used during local computations and passing around. It's fields are public (whereas the class comment says they are only package visible). The public fields (and