Re: Recommendations for NICs?

2010-01-22 Thread Elliot Finley
In recent testing with 8-Stable, we couldn't get our Intel cards to push more than 450Mbps. We put some Broadcom cards in and we can get 980Mbps. On Thu, Jan 21, 2010 at 10:27 AM, John j...@starfire.mn.org wrote: This used to be a hot topic long ago, but now seems to have become rather

Recommendations for NICs?

2010-01-21 Thread John
This used to be a hot topic long ago, but now seems to have become rather dormant. Does that mean that all NICs are pretty much commodity with all the good features (unaligned scatter/gather, etc), or does it just mean that machine performance has grown to the point where we don't care anymore?

Re: Recommendations for NICs?

2010-01-21 Thread Chuck Swiger
Hi-- On Jan 21, 2010, at 9:27 AM, John wrote: This used to be a hot topic long ago, but now seems to have become rather dormant. Does that mean that all NICs are pretty much commodity with all the good features (unaligned scatter/gather, etc), or does it just mean that machine performance

Re: Recommendations for NICs?

2010-01-21 Thread John
On Thu, Jan 21, 2010 at 10:12:29AM -0800, Chuck Swiger wrote: Hi-- On Jan 21, 2010, at 9:27 AM, John wrote: This used to be a hot topic long ago, but now seems to have become rather dormant. Does that mean that all NICs are pretty much commodity with all the good features (unaligned

Re: Recommendations for NICs?

2010-01-21 Thread Robert Huff
Chuck Swiger writes: This used to be a hot topic long ago, but now seems to have become rather dormant. Intel (fxp, em) and Broadcom (bce, bge) make fine NICs, and the older DEC/Intel 21x4x Tulip series (dc/de) was quite good as well. Let me add my vote for Intel: I have a

Re: Recommendations for NICs?

2010-01-21 Thread Chuck Swiger
On Jan 21, 2010, at 10:20 AM, John wrote: [ ... ] Thanks! That's perfect. I have a chance to buy a few Intel Pro 10/100 (fxp) cards. I guess I'll take it! If you don't need gigabit, the fxp cards are great-- very reliable and some even support interrupt mitigation in firmware (which

Re: Recommendations for NICs?

2010-01-21 Thread David Kelly
On Thu, Jan 21, 2010 at 12:20:34PM -0600, John wrote: On Thu, Jan 21, 2010 at 10:12:29AM -0800, Chuck Swiger wrote: Intel (fxp, em) and Broadcom (bce, bge) make fine NICs, and the older DEC/Intel 21x4x Tulip series (dc/de) was quite good as well. The Marvel Yukon (msk) and nVidia MCP

Re: Recommendations for NICs?

2010-01-21 Thread Nathan Vidican
Personally, I've had the best success with fxp and em cards (Intel), and the worst with broadcom-based on-board nics, but have tried and worked with many different cards over the years on FreeBSD. Hands-down though, I prefer Intel's NIC offerings. IIRC - Intel contributed to the development and

Re: Recommendations for NICs?

2010-01-21 Thread C. C. Tang
Let me add my vote for Intel: I have a dual-port Pro/1000, and the thing is a rock: I am planning to get a Pro/1000 MT dual port card, do you know that will it works well in 32bit PCI slot on FreeBSD? Thanks, C.C. ___

Re: Recommendations for NICs?

2010-01-21 Thread Robert Huff
C. C. Tang writes: Let me add my vote for Intel: I have a dual-port Pro/1000, and the thing is a rock: I am planning to get a Pro/1000 MT dual port card, do you know that will it works well in 32bit PCI slot on FreeBSD? I have one of these: Pro/1000 GT Dual Port