Re: howto software raid under FreeBSD?

2004-11-03 Thread Matthias F. Brandstetter
-- quoting Christian Hiris -- If you use the whole disk as provider and your disk has left free 512 bytes after the end of the last slice, gmirror setup works very easy and fast (no need to use dump/restore or dd): - Boot into the live-filesystem. - Do a 'gmirror load' and

Re: howto software raid under FreeBSD?

2004-10-31 Thread Matthias F. Brandstetter
-- quoting Emanuel Strobl -- Why going outside and searching the internet? You have a complete operating system, and it's one of the best documented out there. Just 'man ata', 'man atacontrol' and 'man gmirror'. Remember that FreeBSD isn't just a hacked kernel with lots of

Re: howto software raid under FreeBSD?

2004-10-31 Thread Emanuel Strobl
Am Sonntag, 31. Oktober 2004 19:01 schrieb Matthias F. Brandstetter: -- quoting Emanuel Strobl -- Why going outside and searching the internet? You have a complete operating system, and it's one of the best documented out there. Just 'man ata', 'man atacontrol' and 'man

Re: howto software raid under FreeBSD?

2004-10-31 Thread Matthias F. Brandstetter
-- quoting Emanuel Strobl -- You can use 'atacontrol detach' then powerdown, replace the drive and after booting you can 'atacontrol addspar ar0 ad6' (or what ever drive and array failed) and 'atacontrol rebuild ar0'. Problem is, that man page says atacontrol rebuild is only

Re: howto software raid under FreeBSD?

2004-10-31 Thread Matthias F. Brandstetter
-- quoting Matthias F. Brandstetter -- Problem is, that man page says atacontrol rebuild is only valid on RAID capable ATA controllers. But since I have no such controller, I can't use this command. Ahh, would it be possible to dd data to the new disk? And if yes: Is this the

Re: howto software raid under FreeBSD?

2004-10-31 Thread Emanuel Strobl
Am Sonntag, 31. Oktober 2004 19:42 schrieb Matthias F. Brandstetter: -- quoting Emanuel Strobl -- You can use 'atacontrol detach' then powerdown, replace the drive and after booting you can 'atacontrol addspar ar0 ad6' (or what ever drive and array failed) and 'atacontrol

Re: howto software raid under FreeBSD?

2004-10-31 Thread Matthias F. Brandstetter
-- quoting Emanuel Strobl -- I don't know why this is in the man page, last time I read it (some years ago) it was not in there. You can use the rebuild command also on non-raid controllers, at least it was possible for me when I did some tests about 3 months ago. As I can see

Re: howto software raid under FreeBSD?

2004-10-31 Thread Matthias F. Brandstetter
-- quoting Emanuel Strobl -- Problem is, that man page says atacontrol rebuild is only valid on RAID capable ATA controllers. But since I have no such controller, I can't use this command. I don't know why this is in the man page, last time I read it (some years ago) it

Re: howto software raid under FreeBSD?

2004-10-31 Thread Christian Hiris
On Sunday 31 October 2004 23:33, Matthias F. Brandstetter wrote: Any docs for gmirror except man page out there anywhere? Something like how to use it for root file system, how to convert a non-gmirror system, kernel configuration etc. Short time ago there was a thread on the current list:

Re: howto software raid under FreeBSD?

2004-10-30 Thread Matthias F. Brandstetter
-- quoting Subhro -- Buddy, software RAIDs had always been a pain in the neck. they simply are not worth it as the kernel is busy babysitting the RAID and other applications suffer. Also in case of software RAID failures, it is a nightmare. I do not think so. I never ever had

Re: howto software raid under FreeBSD?

2004-10-30 Thread Matthias F. Brandstetter
-- quoting Emanuel Strobl -- Why not, but you also have gmirror and ataraid, the former only on 5.3. For ataraid you can use 'atacontrol create RAID1 ad4 ad6' for example For gmirror you can use 'gmirror label -v -b split -s 2048 mrr ad4 ad6' And you mentioned vinum and ccd

Re: howto software raid under FreeBSD?

2004-10-30 Thread Subhro
On Sat, 30 Oct 2004 12:17:05 +0200, Matthias F. Brandstetter [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I never ever had any diffuiculties or hatches with software raids on Linux systems. You got me wrongly. The primary reason why I would make a RAID is fault tolerance. In case of hardware RAIDs, rebuilding a

Re: howto software raid under FreeBSD?

2004-10-30 Thread Emanuel Strobl
Am Samstag, 30. Oktober 2004 12:18 schrieb Matthias F. Brandstetter: -- quoting Emanuel Strobl -- Why not, but you also have gmirror and ataraid, the former only on 5.3. For ataraid you can use 'atacontrol create RAID1 ad4 ad6' for example For gmirror you can use 'gmirror

Re: howto software raid under FreeBSD?

2004-10-30 Thread Emanuel Strobl
Am Samstag, 30. Oktober 2004 23:52 schrieb Emanuel Strobl: Am Samstag, 30. Oktober 2004 12:18 schrieb Matthias F. Brandstetter: -- quoting Emanuel Strobl -- Why not, but you also have gmirror and ataraid, the former only on 5.3. For ataraid you can use 'atacontrol create

howto software raid under FreeBSD?

2004-10-29 Thread Matthias F. Brandstetter
Hi all, I want to create a software RAID 1 of two same disks. Coming from Linux I am used to the very simple /etc/raidtab files. Now I looked into vinum docs in FreeBSD handbook, and it seems somewhat difficult to me. So my question is: Is vinum the only way to create a software RAID 1 from

Re: howto software raid under FreeBSD?

2004-10-29 Thread Emanuel Strobl
Am Freitag, 29. Oktober 2004 23:55 schrieb Matthias F. Brandstetter: Hi all, I want to create a software RAID 1 of two same disks. Coming from Linux I am used to the very simple /etc/raidtab files. Now I looked into vinum docs in FreeBSD handbook, and it seems somewhat difficult to me. So

Re: howto software raid under FreeBSD?

2004-10-29 Thread Subhro
On Fri, 29 Oct 2004 23:55:43 +0200, Matthias F. Brandstetter [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Hi all, I want to create a software RAID 1 of two same disks. Buddy, software RAIDs had always been a pain in the neck. they simply are not worth it as the kernel is busy babysitting the RAID and other