Re: [FRIAM] What's so bad about Scientism?

2018-07-08 Thread Nick Thompson
Hi, Glen, I think you are being a little unfair: I merely laid out the understandings that lead ME to think that one cannot doubt and act at the same time: ie, it is entailed by my definition of belief. >We are a having a definitional problem. To a pragmatist (which I seem >to

Re: [FRIAM] What's so bad about Scientism?

2018-07-08 Thread glen
Very interesting! My neighbor had a similar problem after having his hip replaced. Neither he nor his Dr understand the relationship between getting used to his new hip and breathing anxiety. But he has been a Tae Kwon Do master for decades. So it would make some sense to hypothesize an

Re: [FRIAM] What's so bad about Scientism?

2018-07-08 Thread Frank Wimberly
About 18 months ago I had an experience which is perhaps not relevant but it came to mind as I read what you wrote, Glen. As a result of a dream I was in a state of anxiety which persisted for days. One of the symptoms was an irrational fear that I would stop breathing if I didn't consciously

Re: [FRIAM] What's so bad about Scientism?

2018-07-08 Thread glen
I've answered your question so manu times, it doesn't seem worth it to answer again. But such is life, eh? Doubt is uncertainty. Our bodies (including our minds) deal with uncertainty by maintaining feedback with the environment. Such doubting feedback is present even during actions of which

Re: [FRIAM] What's so bad about Scientism?

2018-07-08 Thread Nick Thompson
Glen, We are a having a definitional problem. To a pragmatist (which I seem to be) there can be no doubt in the presence of action (and no belief in its absence). So when you say, “I doubt everything” that MEANS to me that you do nothing. So, when you put your feet out to the