Re: Re:democracy

1999-01-30 Thread Edward Weick
Victor Milne: As I recall, this thread got started with a comment about many of the voters seeming to be neither intelligent nor well-informed. I'm sure from many of his postings that Ed Weick did not mean this in an elitist sense. No, I didn't mean it in an elitist sense. I meant it very

Re: real-life example

1999-01-29 Thread Edward Weick
- Original Message - From: Edward Weick [EMAIL PROTECTED] No thanks! I saw direct democracy in action the other night on a PBS program about Rwanda: eight-hundred-thousand dead in one hundred days. Don't you think your being just a little unfair? That was butchery, not democracy

Re: real-life example

1999-01-28 Thread Edward Weick
From: Edward Weick [EMAIL PROTECTED] How about an explicit definition of the job and explicit qualifications? We do that with every other job, why not politics? God will write them? Theocracies worked for a while, but they too had their problems -- e.g. the classic Mayas screwed up

Re: real-life example

1999-01-28 Thread Edward Weick
No thanks! I saw direct democracy in action the other night on a PBS program about Rwanda: eight-hundred-thousand dead in one hundred days. Jay Jay, Don't you think your being just a little unfair? That was butchery, not democracy. Given its background, it could have happened under any

Re: real-life example

1999-01-27 Thread Edward Weick
Jay: How about an explicit definition of the job and explicit qualifications? We do that with every other job, why not politics? God will write them? Theocracies worked for a while, but they too had their problems -- e.g. the classic Mayas screwed up their environment just as badly as we

Re: real-life example

1999-01-26 Thread Edward Weick
Jay Hanson: First of all you did not know my crew. G Moreover, the reason they have skippers on boats is because they are better trained than crew and passengers. It's a fact of life. Human society is inherently hierarchical for the simple reason that it contributes to "inclusive fitness".

Re: Samuelson's lump-of-labor, 1998

1999-01-26 Thread Edward Weick
Ray E. Harrell: 2. Opera is truly a holistic art form that encompasses music, drama, dance, the graphic arts, film and anything else that can be used by the composer. There is nothing about Neo-Classical Economics that vaguely resembles the whole of human.

Re: real-life example

1999-01-26 Thread Edward Weick
Jay Hanson: Democracy makes no sense. If society is seeking a leader with the best skills, the selection should be based on merit -- testing and xperience -- not popularity. Government by popularity contest is a stupid idea. Somehow I'm not at all surprised that this is your point of view.

Re: The lump-of-opera fallacy

1999-01-26 Thread Edward Weick
Ray: Being a musician is a full time job whether paid or not and angry artists are often quite destructive. Since they control the mirrors they often contain a destruction that is truly genocidal all in the name of their own view of the world winning a

Re: Sustainable work

1999-01-25 Thread Edward Weick
Neva Goodwin: "At some point, we need to ask, why are we using the word, "work"? There are other good words -- "self-actualization" (well, that's not a very euphoneous one, but it has a good meaning), "play" -- I've tended to assume that "work" had to do with an output of some kind that was of

Designer seeds

1999-01-25 Thread Edward Weick
From the Globe and Mail: Designer seeds a growing concern in India Monday, January 25, 1999John Stackhouse Badshahpur, India -- Ever since the cotton-field massacre,

Re: academia, etc.

1999-01-20 Thread Edward Weick
Ray E. Harrell, Welcome to the world of the arts.Out of 5,650 graduates a year in vocal performing arts programs there are about 300 full time jobs. We are told by the economists that making a living at something else means that we should be happy to do the art for free. Welcome to the

Re: Afrika and living beyond our means

1999-01-18 Thread Edward Weick
M. Blackmore: Hence the reality of our position is obscured by market relations. Disrupt those relations and watch the industrial populations die off like flies :-( would be my guess. I suppose it depends on what is meant by "disrupt". Total disruption, if such a thing can be imagined, would

Re: Visions of Heaven or Hell

1999-01-02 Thread Edward Weick
Victor Milne: But what consumers are going to be left? They may opt out--boycott--as suggested above. However, Angell's world seems to leave precious few consumers. Global business is to downsize, outsource, roboticize, and where it retains a few workers, tell them to be damn grateful for the

THE THIRD CULTURE - by Kevin Kelly (http://www.edge.org/3rd_culture/kelly/inde

1998-12-27 Thread Edward Weick
Title: EDGE 3rd Culture: THE THIRD CULTURE - by Kevin Kelly The Third Culture Home | Third Culture |

Re: Douthwaite's Version

1998-12-18 Thread Edward Weick
Weick: Growth did not, as Douthwaite appears to imply, stagnate because of a lack of effective demand, but because, in the euphoria of the boom, bad investments were made. And it was not only foreign capital that bailed out. Domestic capital also did so. Davis: The "bad investments" were bad

Re: REGIONAL PLANNING DILUTES AND ULTIMATELY DEFEATS DEMOCRACY

1998-12-17 Thread Edward Weick
excerpt from a paper by Albert Bartlett published in Population Environment, Vol. 20, No. 1, September 1998, Pgs. 77 - 81. REGIONWIDE PLANNING WILL MAKE THE PROBLEMS WORSE REGIONAL PLANNING DILUTES AND ULTIMATELY DEFEATS DEMOCRACY What

Re: technology changes community

1998-12-14 Thread Edward Weick
Victor Milne: Having a single service centre for the whole continent is not necessarily very efficient, because the people answering the calls don't have a clue about the local situation. True. I was having problems with my computer, so I dialed the 1-800 number. I told the gentleman at the

Trends of the times

1998-12-11 Thread Edward Weick
1996 Census: Sources of Income, earnings and total income, and family income, Statistics Canada, May 12, 1998: The nearly 21 million individuals who were income recipients in 1995 had an average total income from all sources of $25,196, down 6% from 1990 after adjustment for

Re: Y2K in SF?

1998-12-08 Thread Edward Weick
I see on the news bulletins that San Francisco is experiencing a massive and mysterious power blackout. Could this be an early symptom? Maybe a systems test that didn't work? Tom Walker The following makes it sound all very mysterious! Ed Weick Massive blackout hits San Francisco, Peninsula

Re: simulating ownership and democracy

1998-12-06 Thread Edward Weick
It's hard to answer anything but "maybe" to these questions, which doesn't really satisfy me. "Ownership" is quite an abstract concept, and for all that Marxists talked about materialism they sure attached a lot of importance to something so abstract. Back to some rudeness. I'm really

Fw: World Bank Economic Forecast

1998-12-06 Thread Edward Weick
-Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [EMAIL PROTECTED] Newsgroups: usa-today.money,alt.politics.economics Date: Thursday, December 03, 1998 6:22 PM Subject: World Bank Economic Forecast December 2, 1998 The World Bank (Wednesday) says the Asian financial and economic crisis is

Re: Re: more on simulation ...

1998-12-05 Thread Edward Weick
"Douglas P. Wilson" [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Since my post containing some tentative requirements analysis the silence has been deafening, with even Jay Hanson being mute on the subject. For my part, I found your post excellent, even inspiring. I marvel at your level of enthusiasm. -Pete

Re: (FW) Data and projects (simulation)

1998-12-05 Thread Edward Weick
Steve Kurtz: (Douglas: I urge you to have a look before attempting to re-invent the wheel.) Then, summarizing a paper: Simulators are descriptions of complex systems representing the interrelationships among the processes that constitute the system; they combine observations of past states of

more on simulations...

1998-12-04 Thread Edward Weick
Douglas P. Wilson: But weather is such a profoundly non-linear system that linearization is either impossible or doesn't help much. We may differ on this point, but I think the world economy is a much simpler system than the world's weather. I don't know any way to prove this other than to

Exxon/Mobil merger

1998-12-02 Thread Edward Weick
Jock McCardell: If this merger is based (as claimed by the respective CEOs) onrationalisation of producers because of declining consumption of oil howdoes this affect the timeline on the 'tank is empty' equation? I believe that its a decline in the price of oil that's at issue, not a