Re: [galaxy-dev] multiple datatypes input in 16.07

2016-12-14 Thread Aysam Guerler
Hi Chris, I am glad that we figured this out. So I am not sure what the best strategy for datatypes with code dependencies is, we should open a new thread or git issue and see if someone can help with that. Thanks, Sam On Wed, Dec 14, 2016 at 10:59 AM, Cristel Thomas wrote: > Hi again, > ok, r

Re: [galaxy-dev] multiple datatypes input in 16.07

2016-12-14 Thread Cristel Thomas
Hi again, ok, ran some more tests - we switched to a new dev server recently and we were having the issue because of the R/rpy2 thing. With that taken care of though, we still have files in the dropdown that shouldn't be there - no more FCS, but .ypnb still show up. I guess this is because of the

Re: [galaxy-dev] multiple datatypes input in 16.07

2016-12-13 Thread Cristel Thomas
Hey Sam, thanks, I'll check tomorrow at work but I suspect there might be something else - I use rpy2 to call R, so that FCS files can be read. As of 2 months ago there was no efficient way of doing it strictly in python. rpy2 does not load if R isn't installed on the system (and for this specific

Re: [galaxy-dev] multiple datatypes input in 16.07

2016-12-13 Thread Aysam Guerler
Hey Cris, Dannon and I figured out, that the problem is that your datatypes are not loaded properly, due to these two invalid imports: https://github.com/ImmPortDB/immport-galaxy/blob/release_16.07/lib/galaxy/datatypes/flow.py#L13 Removing them fixes the issue. The error for this is shown in the

Re: [galaxy-dev] multiple datatypes input in 16.07

2016-12-05 Thread Aysam Guerler
Ok, let me look a little bit further then. Can you send me the corresponding tool xml file and let me know which datatypes appear in the dropdown list and which of those you would not expect to see? Ideally we can reproduce it with datatypes available to everyone, so I can test it locally.

Re: [galaxy-dev] multiple datatypes input in 16.07

2016-12-05 Thread Cristel Thomas
If it's implicit conversion, why does it pick up the FCS bianry format along with the other text formats? and why does it get triggered on every single tool instead of just the few that have the multiple datatypes? On Mon, Dec 5, 2016 at 12:31 PM, Aysam Guerler wrote: > Ok, so this seems to work

Re: [galaxy-dev] multiple datatypes input in 16.07

2016-12-05 Thread Aysam Guerler
Ok, so this seems to work properly, and implicit conversion is the reason why you see html and text, but not png and pdf files. Currently there is no option to disable implicit conversion but its an enhancement we can suggest to be implemented by creating a github issue. ___

Re: [galaxy-dev] multiple datatypes input in 16.07

2016-12-05 Thread Cristel Thomas
there are 8 datatypes, 7 are tabular / text files, one is binary. The binary format also shows up in the dropdown. I can send you the datatype specification python code if you'd like, Im not sure what you need to see. On Mon, Dec 5, 2016 at 12:01 PM, Aysam Guerler wrote: > Thanks for the quick r

Re: [galaxy-dev] multiple datatypes input in 16.07

2016-12-05 Thread Aysam Guerler
Thanks for the quick response. What is the set of datatypes you are specifying? It is possible that one of the specified datatypes can be implicitly converted to html and text e.g. a fasta file will be listed even if only tabular has been specifed as valid datatype. In other words, Galaxy will impl

Re: [galaxy-dev] multiple datatypes input in 16.07

2016-12-05 Thread Cristel Thomas
Hi Sam, I'm not sure what tools have multiple datatypes as input on usegalaxy.org (and my files are still waiting to be uploaded for some reasons.) I can give you more details though. Those are tools we developed for flow cytometry with new datatypes. I wonder if the issue is with the fact

Re: [galaxy-dev] multiple datatypes input in 16.07

2016-12-05 Thread Aysam Guerler
Hey Cris, Thanks for reporting this. I am looking into it. In the meanwhile, I am wondering if you can reproduce the error on usegalaxy.org? Does it happen for all tools? Thanks, Sam On Mon, Dec 5, 2016 at 8:47 AM, Cristel Thomas wrote: > Hi Galaxy Devs, > > We have a few tools with multiple d