Stian
If a community made predominantly of existing Apache committers (or
containing a strong core of) already exists and this would be a small self
contained module as part of Apache Commons then why does the Incubator
need be involved at all?
Why can this not just be submitted directly to
The discussion on dev@commons about coming-to-Apache Commons-RDF
(https://github.com/commons-rdf/commons-rdf/) seems to be rejecting a
temporary mailing list like rdf@commons as it is seen t be splitting
Apache Commons as a project - the ideal committer on Apache Commons is
caring about all its
I agree that incoming codebase can go through the IP Clearance, and if the
committers are already Commons folks (predominantly), and the only actual
issue is the number of mails on the dev@, then I think that separate
mailing list is fine, perhaps with the exception of not having a name
related to
Agreed
The point that I was trying to make is that if those involved already
understand the Apache Way going through Incubation for the sake of it
seems a pointless exercise especially when the legal/IP aspects of things
can be handled in other fashions. If you are in a position to simply
@incubator.apache.orgmailto:general@incubator.apache.org
Subject: Re: Incubating with Apache Commons as champion?
I agree that incoming codebase can go through the IP Clearance, and if the
committers are already Commons folks (predominantly), and the only actual
issue is the number of mails on the dev@, then I think
On 20/01/15 16:08, Rob Vesse wrote:
On the other hand does Commons-RDF necessarily need to come to the ASF at
all? If it is a small self-contained interface module that will remain
stable what does it gain (other than brand association) by coming to the
ASF?
Well, this question eventually
Just because a lot of Apache committers are involved and could put
things right into another project (or even propose a new TLP directly)
doesn't mean it happens.
https://wiki.apache.org/incubator/BeanShellProposal was voted -1 in
the incubator because it had many Apache folks already and didn't
@incubator.apache.orgmailto:general@incubator.apache.org
Subject: Re: Incubating with Apache Commons as champion?
Stian
If a community made predominantly of existing Apache committers (or
containing a strong core of) already exists and this would be a small self
contained module as part of Apache Commons then why does
On 20/01/15 15:28, Stian Soiland-Reyes wrote:
The suggestion is that Commons-RDF could be a incubator project, but
with a projected path to become part of the Apache Commons instead of
a TLP. (I believe this path has not happened before)
It did happened before:
Stian Soiland-Reyes wrote:
https://wiki.apache.org/incubator/BeanShellProposal was voted -1 in
the incubator because it had many Apache folks already and didn't need
to learn anything. Yet the project didn't move into Apache - perhaps
because it didn't have any pressure or framework to go
10 matches
Mail list logo
