Re: Update project maturity model to include trademark and branding?

Hi, > Besides, the maturity model is applied for all ASF projects and under the > management of ComDev pmc. > > Shall we cc this thread to dev@community.a.o or start a new thread after we > have a consensus within the Incubator first? I had intended to bring it up on dev@community.a.o for

Re: Update project maturity model to include trademark and branding?

cc @Shane Here is a related thread we ever initialized. I'm trying to find some time to pick it up, but yet to achieve it. Best, tison. tison 于2023年12月29日周五 15:21写道： > Besides, the maturity model is applied for all ASF projects and under the > management of ComDev pmc. > > Shall we cc this

Re: Update project maturity model to include trademark and branding?

Besides, the maturity model is applied for all ASF projects and under the management of ComDev pmc. Shall we cc this thread to dev@community.a.o or start a new thread after we have a consensus within the Incubator first? Best, tison. tison 于2023年12月29日 周五12:58写道： > > This varies from project

Re: Update project maturity model to include trademark and branding?

> This varies from project to project: > 1. Some projects have PMC members working at a company who use their > trademark, and they make sure that things are correctly done. > 2. Some projects have people who actively look out for these types of issues > and report them. > 3. Some projects are

Re: Update project maturity model to include trademark and branding?

HI, >> TB40 The project performs some monitoring of 3rd party use of its >> trademarks, addressing any instances of misuse. > > Do you have some examples of how podlings or TLPs perform this today? This varies from project to project: - Some projects have PMC members working at a company who

Re: Update project maturity model to include trademark and branding?

> TB50 Any existing previous domain names are in control of the PMC. This is hard to follow. If the domain names are under the donating compay's top domain, said if there is a foo.google.com, shall the PMC take control of Google? > TB60 Any existing trademarks have been or are in the process of

Re: Update project maturity model to include trademark and branding?

>> It seems the updated podling report template has not had the impact it was >> hoped to have around issues of branding and trademarks. > For example, a doable mechanism is that, during each quarter's report, > the (P)PMC includes a section on what checks they did and if they > found any

Re: Update project maturity model to include trademark and branding?

HI, I’d also suggest adding: TB50 Any existing previous domain names are in control of the PMC. TB60 Any existing trademarks have been or are in the process of being transferred to the ASF. Kind Regards, Justin - To

Re: Update project maturity model to include trademark and branding?

Thanks for starting this thread. As we actually evaluate the maturity at how the podling complies with trademarks and branding, we'd better provide certain guidelines for podlings to follow. I can understand TB10 TB20 TB30 after the recent discussions, but perhaps it is still helpful if we extend

Update project maturity model to include trademark and branding?

Hi, It seems the updated podling report template has not had the impact it was hoped to have around issues of branding and trademarks. It was pointed out on the trademark list that the current maturity model [1] is missing checks for trademarks and branding. Here is my first attempt at it;