Re: [geo] Re: Monbiot Claims SAI already tested ... with catastrophic results

2011-09-30 Thread Tom Wigley
It's a long time since I did anything in this field, so this is some ad hoc thinking. Soil PCO2 is much higher than in the atmosphere. An old paper on this is ... Drake, J.J. and Wigley, T.M.L., 1975: The effect of climate on the chemistry of carbonate groundwater. Water Resources Research

RE: [geo] Re: Monbiot Claims SAI already tested ... with catastrophic results

2011-09-30 Thread Rau, Greg
Agree that if your only acid is carbonic then CO2 will be consumed, assuming CaCO3 doesn't reprecipitate. If the soil acidity is caused by other acids then you lose CO2 e.g.: H2SO4 + CaCO3 --- CaSO4 + H2O + CO2. All farmers care about is losing acidity when they limestone. In our current

[geo] Re: New report(s) on carbon dioxide removal

2011-09-30 Thread Josh Horton
Duncan, Repeating what others have already said, kudos on your report, which represents a great first step toward a systematic comparison of competing CDR technologies/NETs. One of your main policy conclusions is that NETs should be excluded from carbon markets due to the possible (probable?)

[geo] Project delays

2011-09-30 Thread Andrew Lockley
Sir I write with deep concern at the news of the delay to the SPICE experiment. Please can you provide a fuller statement regarding the delay to this project? It is extremely worrying that these benign and important experiments in climate science are being held up, based on what appears to be

[geo] Re: New report(s) on carbon dioxide removal

2011-09-30 Thread Duncan McLaren
Thanks John Please keep me in the loop on your thoughts on combining biochar and soil mineralisation with rock dust. We need all the sensible ideas we can get. Regarding the potential benefits of biochar, I tried to include potential benefits for any technique where they were suggested or