Re: [geo] Re: biochar as CDR and related nomenclature issues: CDRS = CDR + S (carbon dioxide removal + storage)

2013-11-20 Thread Keith Henson
On Tue, Nov 19, 2013 at 9:22 PM, Ronal W. Larson rongretlar...@comcast.net wrote: Keith cc list 1. Since this is a thread with a biochar theme, I thought we should compare a hypothetical biochar scenario with your solar power satellite (SPS) scenario. 2. Because char is lighter

Re: [geo] Re: biochar as CDR and related nomenclature issues: CDRS = CDR + S (carbon dioxide removal + storage)

2013-11-20 Thread Ronal W. Larson
Keith etal Thanks for the added material. It seems we understand the differences well, so I will keep this short. 1. Re my #2: You found 1 ppm CO2 as 5.20 Gt CO2. Multiplying by 12/44 would give 1.42 Gt C, whereas I had 2.13 Gt C ( a number I have seen many times - such as at

Re: [geo] Re: biochar as CDR and related nomenclature issues: CDRS = CDR + S (carbon dioxide removal + storage)

2013-11-20 Thread Keith Henson
On Wed, Nov 20, 2013 at 6:33 PM, Ronal W. Larson rongretlar...@comcast.net wrote: Keith etal Thanks for the added material. It seems we understand the differences well, so I will keep this short. 1. Re my #2: You found 1 ppm CO2 as 5.20 Gt CO2. Multiplying by 12/44 would give 1.42 Gt

Re: [geo] Re: biochar as CDR and related nomenclature issues: CDRS = CDR + S (carbon dioxide removal + storage)

2013-11-19 Thread Keith Henson
Some years ago I calculated how much energy it would take to convert 100 ppm of CO2 into synthetic oil which could be stored in old oil fields safely for millions of years. 100 ppm of CO2 would be 470 cubic km of the stuff. It's what humans added to the atmosphere since ~1960. Had to define a

Re: [geo] Re: biochar as CDR and related nomenclature issues: CDRS = CDR + S (carbon dioxide removal + storage)

2013-11-19 Thread Ronal W. Larson
Keith cc list 1. Since this is a thread with a biochar theme, I thought we should compare a hypothetical biochar scenario with your solar power satellite (SPS) scenario. 2. Because char is lighter than oil (I assume relative density of 1/3), I got 1200 km3 of char, assuming 400 Gt of