Re: Scalability results for GoldenOrb and comparison with Giraph

2011-12-14 Thread Avery Ching
If you're going to do benchmarking, make sure to include https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/GIRAPH-57 as it should provide a nice messaging boost! Avery On 12/14/11 2:16 PM, Jon Allen wrote: Hi Claudio, It looks like it might be a little tough to squeeze out scalability tests for hama an

Re: Scalability results for GoldenOrb and comparison with Giraph

2011-12-14 Thread Jon Allen
Hi Claudio, It looks like it might be a little tough to squeeze out scalability tests for hama and giraph by the FOSDEM deadline. We can try to put something together if you'd like though (not sure where I'll be able to procure time on a cluster for testing by then, but it won't hurt to try I s

Re: Scalability results for GoldenOrb and comparison with Giraph

2011-12-12 Thread Claudio Martella
This is all very interesting. As I wrote a few weeks ago also on golden orb's ML, i thought about discussing a nice benchmarking toolset at the graph devroom of FOSDEM with hama, goldenorb and giraph devs. Apparently everything got quite anticipated, cool :) I believe the SSSP and PageRank algori

Re: Scalability results for GoldenOrb and comparison with Giraph

2011-12-12 Thread Avery Ching
Thanks for the detail on your experiments. I certainly agree that it would be very useful to make some sort of scalability/performance testing framework to evaluate improvements. Definitely would appreciate your help in putting one together. We have a few benchmarks (PageRankBenchmark and Ra

Re: Scalability results for GoldenOrb and comparison with Giraph

2011-12-11 Thread Jon Allen
Hi Avery, Thanks for the response. I reached out to the graph user mailing list because I am quite interested in helping develop / execute standardized scalability testing for Giraph, so I'm glad to see that there is interest! Here's some follow up to some of the points you raised / questions y

Re: Scalability results for GoldenOrb and comparison with Giraph

2011-12-11 Thread Avery Ching
Hi Jon, -golden...@googlegroups.com (so as to not clog up their mailing list uninvited) First of all, thank you for sharing this comparison. I would like to note a few things. The results I posted in October 2011 were actually a bit old (done in June 2011) and do not have several improveme