[GO] WSVS E L Haverfield part 2

2004-11-08 Thread Kate Lambert
 disaster every time they step outside the 
school gates), she collapses, refuses to move and begs Lois to stay 
because she doesn't want to die alone. Her behaviour is contrasted with 
that of Ann, who tells Lois to leave her after she has banged her head 
on a tree, which Lois of course refuses to do.

Indeed, Haverfield's self-sacrificing heroines are often so stoical that 
the only time they can express their true feelings is when they are 
delirious. In Just a Jolly Girl , Dixie Harding, told by her nurse that 
she was ugly, is jealous of her prettier schoolmates and becoming bitter 
and warped. For years she has believed that her adored mother is 
disappointed in her. It is only when she is delirious after being 
knocked down by a car on a school walk that she pours out all her 
bottled-up emotions: I'm not a little dwarf, it isn't true  This is 
the first her mother, sitting by her bedside, knows of her daughter's 
thoughts. Dixie, what kind of a mother do you take me for? Don't you 
think that I love you? And after years of misunderstanding, all is 
resolved.

Similarly, in The Luck of Lois when Ann is unconscious in bed following 
the forest fire, Lois overhears her saying What do you think of your 
precious friend now? Plucky isn't she? Wanting you to die with her! You 
didn't ask me to die with you. Lois, who can be rather dense at times, 
can't make sense of this at all, but the astute reader will realise that 
Ann cares for her. In Our Vow too, Alison's ravings after being burned 
in the fire gain her some sympathy from her aunt, who has previously 
dismissed her as a naughty child. She must have been most miserable for 
months, and we none of us understood her at all or knew of it. In The 
Happy Comrade, two girls are expelled as bullies after one of their 
victims, who has refused to tell her parents why she did not wish to 
return to school, reveals all in delirious ramblings.

--
Kate Lambert
--

Girlsown mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
For self-administration and access to archives see
http://home.it.net.au/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/girlsown
For FAQs see http://www.club-web.pwp.blueyonder.co.uk/girlsown/faq-0.htm


Re: [GO] WSVS E L Haverfield part 2

2004-11-10 Thread Kate Lambert
In message [EMAIL PROTECTED], Beth  Rich 
[EMAIL PROTECTED] writes
Muriels Choice is really good!! and the Discovery of Kate was enjoyable too.
I haven't seen Phyll's original post yet but yes I think Haverfield is 
extremely readable. Kate Tyler says the same in The Book too. I also 
prefer the later ones (there's a list at the end of my paper). You do 
have to suspend a lot of disbelief about misunderstandings over which 
people suffer in silence for terms or even years and bizarre loyalties - 
why can't Kate just tell Magdalene to piss off? - but after reading a 
few that all seems entirely normal.
--
Kate Lambert
--

Girlsown mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
For self-administration and access to archives see
http://home.it.net.au/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/girlsown
For FAQs see http://www.club-web.pwp.blueyonder.co.uk/girlsown/faq-0.htm