Re: [GO] WSVS E L Haverfield part 2

2004-11-10 Thread Kate Lambert
In message [EMAIL PROTECTED], Beth  Rich 
[EMAIL PROTECTED] writes
Muriels Choice is really good!! and the Discovery of Kate was enjoyable too.
I haven't seen Phyll's original post yet but yes I think Haverfield is 
extremely readable. Kate Tyler says the same in The Book too. I also 
prefer the later ones (there's a list at the end of my paper). You do 
have to suspend a lot of disbelief about misunderstandings over which 
people suffer in silence for terms or even years and bizarre loyalties - 
why can't Kate just tell Magdalene to piss off? - but after reading a 
few that all seems entirely normal.
--
Kate Lambert
--

Girlsown mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
For self-administration and access to archives see
http://home.it.net.au/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/girlsown
For FAQs see http://www.club-web.pwp.blueyonder.co.uk/girlsown/faq-0.htm


[GO] WSVS E L Haverfield part 2

2004-11-09 Thread phyllgriffiths
Cor, I'm stunned, not by a golf ball of course, by all these dreadful
accidents in the Haverfield books [as described by Kate], they make the
doings in the CS look quite feeble!

I've never read any Haverfield, when were her books published?  They sound
quite dreadful plotwise, do they 'read' well?  The one often has nothing at
all to do with the other after all.

Thanks to Kate and all the other contributors of fascinating Papers.

Phyll

-- 

Girlsown mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
For self-administration and access to archives see
 http://home.it.net.au/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/girlsown
For FAQs see http://www.club-web.pwp.blueyonder.co.uk/girlsown/faq-0.htm


[GO] WSVS E L Haverfield part 2

2004-11-08 Thread Kate Lambert
Nursing, flower-arranging and the importance of Bovril
Nursing skills are an important character trait in determining whether a 
girl is a good sort, one of the ways in which Haverfield uses injury as 
a means of bringing two girls together as friends.

In The Discovery of Kate, Dilys StOswald, isolated by the Grammar School 
girls as being stuck up, crashes her bicycle into a herd of cows and 
is taken unconscious to Kate's house nearby, where she stays in Kate's 
bedroom until she has recovered, Kate's mother handily being a trained 
nurse. The accident starts the process of bringing Kate and Dilys 
together although Kate first has to choke off the attentions of the 
unpleasant, dog-beating and distinctly lower-class Magdalene Russell. 
During her stay at Kate's home Dilys realises that Kate cannot be bird 
of a feather with her friend Magdalene and is attracted by her cheery 
face, her care and thoughtfulness to the sick and her flower arranging 
skills.

In The Luck of Lois her nursing expertise also indicates that there is 
more to Ann Craig the headmistress' daughter, than meets the eye. 
Sphinx-like Ann saves Lois from drowning with cramp and then 
reluctantly accompanies Lois back to school when Lois' friend Zoe fails 
to jump at the chance to go with her, as all good friends should when 
one is ill. Ann, who has always held herself aloof from the girls who 
have invaded her home, then tucks Lois up with a rug, takes off her 
shoes and brings her a hot water bottle and a cup of hot Bovril. Zoe's 
ignoring Lois when she faints marks the shift in Zoe's affections as she 
transfers her friendship from Lois to Lois' newly-arrived sister, the 
beautiful and accomplished Vivian. When Lois goes up to bed, her 
room-mates fail to notice that she needs help and again Ann comes to the 
rescue; I thought you had a sister and a friend here to help you or I 
would have come up before. Later she sends up a temptingly set tray 
(Does anyone know what a cup of Benger is?) decorated with a red rose, 
although she is very particular about flowers being removed from 
sick-rooms at night and Lois is not allowed to keep it. Ann's 
solicitousness when Lois is ill is a hint to the reader that the silent 
Ann cares for Lois, something Lois herself fails to realise until the 
final chapter.

In Blind Loyalty, Alison spends a night in the dormitory placing cool 
bandages on Georgie's head and Esm's lack of sympathy for Georgie is 
the first hint that Esm might not be the perfect friend Alison has 
thought her, I was conscious of something other than the confiding love 
I had given to this beautiful girl. In Our Vow, hated Cousin Evelyn 
sits up all night bathing the face of Alison who has covered herself in 
shoe blacking while playing missionaries and heathen (did children do 
this all the time or is this where EBD got the idea from?) and although 
Alison is not yet reconciled to her cousin, the reader realises that 
Alison is wrong.

Stoicism and the power of delirium
Haverfield heroines are brave to the point of insanity when in pain. 
Hilary Walford in The Girl From the Bush, set alight by a Christmas tree 
candle, refuses to be examined until her rescuer Dorothy's hands have 
been bandaged and is told by the doctor that she is pretty plucky. 
All night long she was unable to sleep for the pain where the flames 
had scorched her but she allowed neither groan nor sigh to escape her. 
Dorothy herself lies with her lips closed tight in the endeavour to 
crush back a single murmur, though she was white with the agony she was 
forced to endure.

The Girl from the Bush also introduces 11 year-old Leslie who is having 
the open-air cure sleeping alone in a hut in the woods. Her disease, 
presumably TB, is not stated but the cure specifically involves 
breathing pine air. Her parents were with her until her father caught 
influenza and her mother had to stay with him instead (obviously!). 
Despite being frightened to death at night she says her parents would be 
disappointed if she asked to join them in their cottage. This seems to 
be taking stoicism a little too far.

When faced with pain, sympathetic characters soldier on while 
unsympathetic ones go to pieces. The eponymous heroine of Dauntless 
Patty responds to being hit in the eye by a tennis ball with don't 
mention it, accidents will happen. It will be all right in a moment or 
two, but turns out to have been half-blinded, faints and is sick with 
concussion. Similarly Margaret MacDonald felled to the ground by a 
golf ball in The Girls of St Olave's is determined to continue playing 
with a supreme effort until forced by staff to return home to rest. 
Snobbish Phyllis Staunton-Taylor in Sylvia's Victory, on the other hand, 
makes a fuss groaning and covering her face with her arm when hit on 
the ankle at hockey, while Zoe in The Luck of Lois is proved not worthy 
of Lois' friendship when, caught in a forest fire on a walk (pupils in 
The Luck of Lois encounter 

RE: [GO] WSVS E L Haverfield part 2 (fwd)

2004-11-08 Thread Pat Hanby


(Does anyone know what a cup of Benger is?)

Benger's food was (still available??) invalid food - powder mixed with
hot milk to make what could be described as a thick milky drink or
rather thin porridge. It was very easily digestible - I think it was
given to babies as well as invalids. Don't know if it's still around - I
remember it in the 60's when my grandmother sometimes had it.  

Pat H. 
--

Girlsown mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
For self-administration and access to archives see
 http://home.it.net.au/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/girlsown
For FAQs see http://www.club-web.pwp.blueyonder.co.uk/girlsown/faq-0.htm


Re: [GO] WSVS E L Haverfield part 2 (fwd)

2004-11-08 Thread Wards
I too remember Benger's.  I think the modern equivalent (if it's still 
around!) is Complan.   Neither of the smelt particularly appetising and 
tasted worse!

Christine
- Original Message - 
From: Pat Hanby [EMAIL PROTECTED]
To: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Sent: Monday, November 08, 2004 12:37 PM
Subject: RE: [GO] WSVS E L Haverfield part 2 (fwd)


(Does anyone know what a cup of Benger is?)
Benger's food was (still available??) invalid food - powder mixed with
hot milk to make what could be described as a thick milky drink or
rather thin porridge. It was very easily digestible - I think it was
given to babies as well as invalids. Don't know if it's still around - I
remember it in the 60's when my grandmother sometimes had it.
Pat H.
--

Girlsown mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
For self-administration and access to archives see
http://home.it.net.au/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/girlsown
For FAQs see http://www.club-web.pwp.blueyonder.co.uk/girlsown/faq-0.htm 

--

Girlsown mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
For self-administration and access to archives see
http://home.it.net.au/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/girlsown
For FAQs see http://www.club-web.pwp.blueyonder.co.uk/girlsown/faq-0.htm