Re: [GKD] Acknowledging the Digital Divide

2002-01-30 Thread Udit Chaudhuri
I would like to build on what Vickram Crishna has stated: It is a common concern that any such development makes some people 'more equal' than the others. Unfortunately, in many Indian cases, the current village 'head-man' or one from the local all-powerful family was the only one educated and

Re: [GKD] Acknowledging the Digital Divide

2002-01-17 Thread Mike Powell
Dr. Perry Morrison wrote: Another way to put it is that the developed are quite happy to inform the undeveloped on the practical things they need to do to redress their situation. However the developed are not that keen on being told of the political dimensions/causations of underdevelopment

Re: [GKD] Acknowledging the Digital Divide

2002-01-16 Thread Margaret Grieco
The internet can be used to empower those previously by-passed in decision making processes. The poverty mapping of Chicago is an excellent example. Volunteers in disadvantaged communities can map their experience and regularly update and display it and grow conscious of the overall framework

Re: [GKD] Acknowledging the Digital Divide

2002-01-15 Thread tom poe
On Sunday 13 January 2002 07:42, Dr. Perry Morrison wrote: - - -snip - - - Hi: I was going to snip and comment, but, regardless of which paragraph I landed on, I found myself wanting to add my .02 worth. So, your message in its entirety deserves a singular comment. You, sir, need to read

Re: [GKD] Acknowledging the Digital Divide

2002-01-14 Thread Daniel Taghioff
I feel I must respond to Perry Morrison's Comments. It may be naive to think that ICTs in developing countries will suddenly make it matter when the West has a much greater ability to tune the message out, to corrupt it or just turn up the volume on its own orgy of self interest. Whilst it

Re: [GKD] Acknowledging the Digital Divide

2002-01-11 Thread Dr. Perry Morrison
Tom Poe wrote: Hello: So, you don't have objections to moving computers over to developing countries, setting them on the tables of all the communities, and then discussing politics. Is this a correct perception of your comments? If so, then maybe the time has come to do just that:

Re: [GKD] Acknowledging the Digital Divide

2002-01-11 Thread Daniel Bassill
Dr. Morrison concluded with this comment: I'm not sure that they will have much role in changing the network of human power relationships that have determined and tolerated these and similar circumstances for so long. I feel this is where the real power of the Internet lies. Prior to this

Re: [GKD] Acknowledging the Digital Divide

2002-01-07 Thread John Lawrence
I was going through Grand Central station in New York City just before Christmas, and while buying bagels in the new GC market, I struck up a brief post 9/11 commiseration with the person serving me ( a woman). She assured me confidently that 9/11 was a function of the huge global social divide

Re: [GKD] Acknowledging the Digital Divide

2002-01-07 Thread Sam Lanfranco
Margaret Grieco, of Napier University (Edinburgh) focuses in on the persistant problem of muzzling expert opinion within the international development community and singles out the World Bank for its internal problems. While the World Bank may be an example of this problem it is probably unfair

Re: [GKD] Acknowledging the Digital Divide

2002-01-07 Thread Dr. Perry Morrison
This thread is intriguing and appeals to my long term interest in the absolute vs relative gains provided by ICTs. There are really 3 points that I think are important. 1. Absolute gains in living standards. I agree that these technologies can deliver real gains in access to information,

Re: [GKD] Acknowledging the Digital Divide

2002-01-04 Thread Refcon Standard
I really don't understand the purpose in your response. You talk about hospitals, social development, etc. I only discuss providing the foundation, the tool necessary before activities can commence. Secondly, I am far less keen to impose on different cultures a single or limited conception of

Re: [GKD] Acknowledging the Digital Divide

2001-12-21 Thread Michel J. Menou
A quick reaction to Monday, December 17, 2001, 6:05:20 PM, Alan Levy wrote: My true goal is to achieve universal access to IP communications. It is possible, if sufficient political will is created. This requires voices, nothing more. Fine but this is not the only fundamental issue in