Re: Ripping from CD to FLAC, and then transcoding to lossy (was: More on MP3 and open formats)

2007-02-27 Thread Jason Stephenson
Ben Scott wrote: On 2/26/07, Jason Stephenson [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I'm already planing a nice utility for managing all of that, too. I'm starting to wonder if there isn't something out there already. I wrote my own collection of really bad hacks (shell and Perl scripts) to do this; I

Re: More on MP3 and open formats

2007-02-27 Thread Bill McGonigle
On Feb 25, 2007, at 23:53, Nigel Stewart wrote: Anyone come across any other FLAC or Ogg oriented music stores online? You can get just about every Grateful Dead concert ever played in FLAC format. A friend of mine has a vertical file full of CD's and even wrote his own FLAC decoder to

Re: Ripping from CD to FLAC, and then transcoding to lossy (was: More on MP3 and open formats)

2007-02-27 Thread Bill McGonigle
On Feb 27, 2007, at 18:26, Jason Stephenson wrote: * From what I've read, Ogg may not be all that safe to use patent- wise. Is this just FUD, or is there something to it? I've heard the claim that it's patent-free hundreds of times. The FAQ at vorbis.com says: What is Ogg Vorbis?

Re: More on MP3 and open formats

2007-02-27 Thread Ben Scott
On 2/27/07, Bill McGonigle [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I'm still miffed my iPod won't play my .mp2 files ... What about RockBox? (RockBox is third-party FOSS firmware for many music players, including the iPod.) A Google for rockbox mp2 seems to indicate it might work. http://www.rockbox.org/

Re: More on MP3 and open formats

2007-02-27 Thread Jon 'maddog' Hall
I'm still miffed my iPod won't play my .mp2 files ... What about RockBox? (RockBox is third-party FOSS firmware for many music players, including the iPod.) A Google for rockbox mp2 seems to indicate it might work. http://www.rockbox.org/ -- Ben The Free Software Foundation is

Re: More on MP3 and open formats

2007-02-27 Thread Bill McGonigle
On Feb 27, 2007, at 21:46, Ben Scott wrote: hat about RockBox? (RockBox is third-party FOSS firmware for many music players, including the iPod.) A Google for rockbox mp2 seems to indicate it might work. Yeah, no support for the model I have (iPod), unfortunately. -Bill - Bill

Re: More on MP3 and open formats

2007-02-26 Thread Jason Stephenson
In reply to Ben's message about ripping to FLAC and then converting to other formats, I believe that is what I am going to do. I'll rip to FLAC and store the results on one of my PCs or possibly even burn them to DVD+R DL discs. Then, I'll convert the FLACs to Ogg when needed for greater file

Ripping from CD to FLAC, and then transcoding to lossy (was: More on MP3 and open formats)

2007-02-26 Thread Ben Scott
On 2/26/07, Jason Stephenson [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I'm already planing a nice utility for managing all of that, too. I'm starting to wonder if there isn't something out there already. I wrote my own collection of really bad hacks (shell and Perl scripts) to do this; I know others have; now

More on MP3 and open formats

2007-02-25 Thread Ben Scott
As a follow-up to the recent discussion about MP3 and closed formats and patents: MP3's Loss, Open Source's Gain, by Eliot Van Buskirk Wired News, 23 Feb 2007 http://www.wired.com/news/culture/music/0,72785-0.html In short, the author hypothesises that this could be an impetuous towards more

Re: More on MP3 and open formats

2007-02-25 Thread Jason Stephenson
Not that anyone really cares what I'm doing, but until this Alcatel thing, I never thought that I was infringing on someone's patent rights by ripping music to MP3. I did it because it pretty much worked everywhere without hassle, though I knew that Ogg was supposed to be better. Now, I'm

Re: More on MP3 and open formats

2007-02-25 Thread Greg Rundlett
On 2/25/07, Jason Stephenson [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Not that anyone really cares what I'm doing, but until this Alcatel thing, I never thought that I was infringing on someone's patent rights by ripping music to MP3. I did it because it pretty much worked everywhere without hassle, though I

Re: More on MP3 and open formats

2007-02-25 Thread Ben Scott
On 2/25/07, Jason Stephenson [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: So, looks like I'll be spending the next couple of weeks re-ripping the hundreds of CDs in my collection. What I've done[1] is to rip my CD collection to FLAC files. This uses much more space[2], but yields a file which can be decoded to

Re: More on MP3 and open formats

2007-02-25 Thread Nigel Stewart
One FLAC/Ogg/Wav friendly online music site that I know of is http://www.magnatune.com/ I also buy music on emusic.com, but they currently only support MP3. (Well, at least with no DRM!) Anyone come across any other FLAC or Ogg oriented music stores online? Nigel