[GOAL] Re: GOAL] Re: Don't Conflate OA with Peer-Review Reform

2013-12-12 Thread Graham Triggs
On 11 December 2013 20:13, Bosman, J.M. j.bos...@uu.nl wrote: Let me be clear on this. My suggestion to move the discussion on peer review to another list has nothing to do with agreeing or not agreeing with anyone. It has to do with the degree to which peer review is related to Open Access.

[GOAL] Re: GOAL] Re: Don't Conflate OA with Peer-Review Reform

2013-12-12 Thread Michael Eisen
Open access and peer review reform are not necessarily related in that you can have OA without peer review changes (e.g. PLOS Biology) and have peer review changes without open access. However, in practical terms it makes sense to discuss them both in the same place because they are both inhibited