[GOAL] Re: Who benefits from for-profit open access publishing? A case study of Hindawi and Egypt

2015-04-21 Thread Dietrich Rordorf / MDPI
Amongst the largest 200 journals in the world (by number of articles published with a doi number assigned), there are about 50 journals that published 10 papers or more per business day in 2014. There are also many large, established journals in chemistry and physics, see: http://sciforum.net/stati

[GOAL] Re: Who benefits from for-profit open access publishing? A case study of Hindawi and Egypt

2015-04-21 Thread Peter Murray-Rust
On Tue, Apr 21, 2015 at 1:53 AM, Dana Roth wrote: > > Some of the Hindawi journals are publishing ~10 papers a day. That could > be over two million dollars a year income (@$600/article) for a single > journal (e.g. Scientific World Journal). > I have no involvement with Hindawi and no comment o

[GOAL] Re: Who benefits from for-profit open access publishing? A case study of Hindawi and Egypt

2015-04-20 Thread Dana Roth
lobal Open Access List (Successor of AmSci); David Solomon Subject: [GOAL] Re: Who benefits from for-profit open access publishing? A case study of Hindawi and Egypt Hi all, The 1500 USD charged by Hindawi for the journal in question is by global standards fairly reasonable, given the impact facto

[GOAL] Re: Who benefits from for-profit open access publishing? A case study of Hindawi and Egypt

2015-04-12 Thread BAUIN Serge
Just to be silly: US$ 6000 for the high end "western" APC is more than the amount of one month salary of a senior scientist here in France. :-( Serge Envoyé d'un téléphone portable, désolé pour le caractère inélégant... > Le 11 avr. 2015 à 19:04, "Bo-Christer Björk" a > écrit : > > Hi all,

[GOAL] Re: Who benefits from for-profit open access publishing? A case study of Hindawi and Egypt

2015-04-11 Thread Bo-Christer Björk
Hi all, The 1500 USD charged by Hindawi for the journal in question is by global standards fairly reasonable, given the impact factor level of the journal. The problem is that uniform APCs for all countries is probably unsustainable in the long run. For this reason many gold OA journals give W

[GOAL] Re: Who benefits from for-profit open access publishing? A case study of Hindawi and Egypt

2015-04-11 Thread Heather Morrison
David, Jan & Peter: thank you for your comments. I agree with some of what you say, would like to point to where we said basically the same things in the original post. and have some comments to add: Agreed - Hindawi has a deserved reputation as a leader in scholarly publishing, and in particul

[GOAL] Re: Who benefits from for-profit open access publishing? A case study of Hindawi and Egypt

2015-04-11 Thread Peter Murray-Rust
I agree completely with what Jan and David have said. If the purpose a journal is to communicate between author and reader without frills and publisher-junk (cf. Tufte's chart-junk) then Hindawi journals come high up my list. Conversely many mainstream publishers' technical offerings are simply ap

[GOAL] Re: Who benefits from for-profit open access publishing? A case study of Hindawi and Egypt

2015-04-11 Thread Jan Velterop
I completely agree with David. Let me add a few comments. Although they are coming at it from different angles, it seems to me that this is where Heather Morrison and Jeffrey Beall converge in what looks like thinly veiled disdain for open access publishers from regions outside N America and Eur

[GOAL] Re: Who benefits from for-profit open access publishing? A case study of Hindawi and Egypt

2015-04-11 Thread David Prosser
I’m rather confused by this blog post. If the argument is that Egypt should invest more in research and build greater safeguards to intellectual and academic freedom then I’m sure that we would all agree wholeheartedly. However, it appears to be trying to make a point about Hindawi and for-prof