[GOAL] Question about portability of peer review

2014-02-25 Thread Beall, Jeffrey
An open-access publisher has this policyhttp://www.medsci.org/ms/author regarding peer review portability: The Editors of the International Journal of Medical Sciences recognize that many manuscripts rejected by top-tier journals are still outstanding. Our journal is willing to review and

[GOAL] Re: Question about portability of peer review

2014-02-25 Thread Charlotte Roh
This is very interesting! I can see how this policy would be helpful to a new journal in providing quick background information for necessary editorial revisions or even ultimate rejection or acceptance. This could also be helpful to authors whose publications are not outstanding due to the

[GOAL] Re: Question about portability of peer review

2014-02-25 Thread Stevan Harnad
The policy of Behavioral and Brain Sciences (BBS, published by Cambridge University Press), of which I was editor in chief for a quarter century was that authors was that authors were strongly encouraged that if their submitted paper had been submitted to and rejected by a journal, the referee