On 23/07/07, Bosco D'Mello [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
On Sun Jul 22 17:49:21 PDT 2007, Gilbert Lawrence wrote:
Hi Bhandare,
You are making a virtue of insulting people and
then apologizing. Then promising not to do it
again. Yet only to repeat it.
OBSERVATION: As previously stated,
--- Gilbert Lawrence [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
Hi Santosh,
Thanks for reviewing and commenting on the contents
on my review / commentary without reading the
original paper.
Gilbert, I read the original paper entitled
Evidence-based medicine: its effect on treatment
recommendations as
Thanks to Santosh's dilligence we now know that Dr
Gilbert refers to a non peer reviewed letter as a
short paper !
he mhanje naaralala shreephal aani chaadrila
mahavastra mhannya paiki aahe!
( credited to P L dehpande)
Bhandare
Hi Bhandare,
You are making a virtue of insulting people and then apologizing. Then
promising not to do it again. Yet only to repeat it.
Are you saying that Letters-to-the-Editor are not selected for their contents
in peer-reviewed in a journal? Did you read the entire short paper of mine
Hi Fred,
I noted your post with a smile. Most Goanetters do not think their supurlo
Goenkar is a scientist. Twenty five years ago, I had all the relevant papers
and their authors' names on my finger tips. But I have also since seen their
data and conclusions come and go. So now I read the
Hi Selma,
As the post below suggest, you are ribbing AT THE SAME TIME eight male Goans
and holding 8.5 (one-half moi) in your orbit. You may have overtaken the
Goddess Artemis Diana of Ephesus.
Becasue of your post below, at least twenty goanetters are now annoyed with you
for not
Hi Santosh, Aristo and others who have addressed the issue of Dualism
Many thanks for the interesting exchange. I do not know much in this field
but my appetite has been whetted to find out more.
Regards
Cornel
Santosh Helekar wrote:
--- Aristo wrote:
Santosh, any suggestions for
Our home-grown dukracho-vhois, Kevin, is a smart-alec. He has pulled a
Goveia on us!!
Even though he is busy adjusting his Speedo, so as to adjust his tan line,
all week on a Caribbean beach(Psst!!), he successfully managed to keep his
name on every third message on Goanet..grin-grin.
Selma wrote:
We are going through the same argument over and over
again. Just because something is unproveable at the
present time, does not mean it will be unproveable
sometime in the future. It surprises me that a
scientiest should extrapolate into the future with a
limited number of current
Mogal Selma bhai,
Kitlem sobit posts boroita! Tuven boroilolem aum zaitem vaztam.
Thanks to you and Google for researching the research. Are you saying, we are
presenting some one's research on this topic without providing reference?
Are you suggesting: What some claim as configurations of
--- Santosh Helekar [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
Perhaps, the surprise is because of a
misunderstanding. Please explain clearly as to what
you are trying to say? What variables? What have I
extrapolated into the future?
--
Alright Santosh,
Let me try
--- Aristo [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
Santosh, any suggestions for pertinent PS books?
Hi Aristo,
To you and to others who have expressed an interest in
this subject privately, here is a short list of
popular books you might want to read:
Consciousness: An Introduction by Susan Blackmore
I think the Selma and Santosh are describing two sides of the same coin. We
see this often in science. At least those of us who have been in science for a
long time.
Selma claims that the CONCEPTS in Kevin's latest theology is nothing new - Very
True! (both for the concept and for Kevin's
Every once in a while one comes across a scientist like Santosh who,
from his arrogance it seems, does not seem to realize that his
understanding is, at best, limited.
Allwyn,
The thing about scientists is they will freely admit that their
understanding is very limited(if it indeed is, that
--- Gilbert Lawrence [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
I think the Selma and Santosh are describing two
sides of the same coin. We see this often in
science. At least those of us who have been in
science for a long time.
Arrey Gilbert Irmao, sarko excited zainaka re :-)
I'm only
--- Gilbert Lawrence [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
science. At least those of us who have been in
science for a long time.
This is a really serious problem, Doc Gilbert!
Now guys, how do we de-addict him of all this Science (with a capital
S)? Doc Helecar, please don't rush to his rescue;
--- Santosh Helekar [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
Selma's characterization below of my assertions in
this thread is totally wrong.
Response:
There you go again Santosh with those words totally
wrong. Of late, you've even begun calling for the
pastoral exile of people who you find totally wrong.
--- Carvalho [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
Response:
There you go again Santosh with those words totally
wrong. Of late, you've even begun calling for the
pastoral exile of people who you find totally
wrong.
Very disappointing that was coming from you. I had
truly held you in much higher esteem.
--- Santosh Helekar [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
The scientific method has not yet yielded a detailed
complete natural explanation for the conscious mind.
However, we know that the idea that it exists
independently of the brain is inconsistent with an
overwhelming body of objective evidence.
--- Carvalho [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
We are going through the same argument over and over
again.
Which argument? Please state it clearly.
Just because something is unproveable at the present
time, does not mean it will be unproveable sometime
in the future.
What will be provable in
In my opinion, getting rid of the concept of Dualism is the last step
from a 99% Atheist (Agnostic) to a 100% Atheist.
In my attempt to learn more about the sense or self or Consciousness
a long time ago, I picked a copy of Roger Penrose's The Emperors new
Mind but I found it digressing and did
Selma's characterization below of my assertions in
this thread is totally wrong.
What I stated cannot be recast in the antiquated
philosophical dichotomy of monism and dualism. The
current scientific understanding of the brain points
to a much more complicated scenario. Googling for
monism and
http://www.GOANET.org
International Cuisine Conference on Traditional Asian Diet
Panaji, Goa, September 2-5,
http://www.GOANET.org
International Cuisine Conference on Traditional Asian Diet
Panaji, Goa, September 2-5,
http://www.GOANET.org
International Cuisine Conference on Traditional Asian Diet
Panaji, Goa, September 2-5,
25 matches
Mail list logo
