Re: [Goanet] Selma Carvalho's book & some unsavoury comments - (Response on Santosh Helekar's posting by Rose Fernandes)

2014-05-16 Thread Santosh Helekar
Dear Rose, Selma's book is excellent. I just read two more chapters. I would advise you to start reading it, and buy copies for all your best friends. You seem like a person who has many best friends both out of love and jealousy. My best to you. Cheers, Santosh On Friday, May 16, 2014 6:57 A

[Goanet] Selma Carvalho's book & some unsavoury comments - (Response on Santosh Helekar's posting by Rose Fernandes)

2014-05-16 Thread Melvyn Fernandes
Dear Santosh Contrary to how you think, you are now fast becoming my second best friend, the first place was taken a long time ago by someone else who I sincerely have and will always have the greatest fondness for.   Over the last week, every day when I wake up and open Melvyn's orange mail

Re: [Goanet] Selma Carvalho's book & some unsavoury comments - (Response on Santosh Helekar's posting by Rose Fernandes)

2014-05-15 Thread Santosh Helekar
Dear Rose, I don't agree with anything you have written so far. I said someone, not "someone else". That "someone" included me and the historian Christine Nicholls. I already told you why I think Selma's book is well written and well researched. If you disagree then please tell me why. I also w

Re: [Goanet] Selma Carvalho's book & some unsavoury comments - (Response on Santosh Helekar's posting by Rose Fernandes)

2014-05-15 Thread Gabe Menezes
On 15 May 2014 17:20, Santosh Helekar wrote: > Dear Rose, > > > Yes, I am interested (not anxious) in knowing what happened to the > talented community, and I will read the rest of the book in the next couple > of weekends. Can you please tell me why you are so bothered if someone says > that Sel

Re: [Goanet] Selma Carvalho's book & some unsavoury comments - (Response to JC by Rose Fernandes)

2014-05-15 Thread Jose Colaco
Dear Rose, As always, good to hear from you. When we lived in London and when we traveled though that lovely city, Marks and Sparks was almost our 'home'. .including the fresh food section. Yes good quality stuff. My only 'difficult' time was when my Ghorkann (already in Goa ahead of m

[Goanet] Selma Carvalho's book & some unsavoury comments - (Response on Santosh Helekar's posting by Rose Fernandes)

2014-05-15 Thread Melvyn Fernandes
Dear Santosh This is what you wrote (not someone else) in Message 9, Goanet Digest Vol 9, Issue 286 on Monday 12 May 2014: Quote Selma's book is well-researched and well-written. Unquote Just two days later on 14 May 2014, in Message 7, Goanet Digest, Vol 9, Issue 291 you wrote: Quo

Re: [Goanet] Selma Carvalho's book & some unsavoury comments - (Response by Rose Fernandes)

2014-05-15 Thread Santosh Helekar
Bernado here is talking about the fact that I have posted descriptions of what was reported in foreign newspapers during Portuguese times with respect to Alfredchacha's post on Goanet and article in Herald, as well as Roland's implicit challenge to me to defend my contention that the Portuguese

Re: [Goanet] Selma Carvalho's book & some unsavoury comments - (Response on Santosh Helekar's posting by Rose Fernandes)

2014-05-15 Thread Santosh Helekar
Dear Rose, Yes, I am interested (not anxious) in knowing what happened to the talented community, and I will read the rest of the book in the next couple of weekends. Can you please tell me why you are so bothered if someone says that Selma's book is well-researched and well-written? Cheers,

[Goanet] Selma Carvalho's book & some unsavoury comments - (Response by Rose Fernandes)

2014-05-15 Thread Bernado Colaco
Xri Elecar is a slow reader because he spends loads of his time researching anti Portuguese propaganda on the web for which he intends to archive for posterity. BC I am not sure what this cross examination is about, but let me tell you why I said Selma's book was well researched and well writ

[Goanet] Selma Carvalho's book & some unsavoury comments - (Response to JC by Rose Fernandes)

2014-05-15 Thread Melvyn Fernandes
Dear JC If I can cast your mind back to the days when the Marks and Spencer shirt was a "must have" item to take back to Goa, just like Cadbury's chocolates are today. To tell you a story, it was known that if you bought a non-Marks and Spencer shirt to gift to your relative in Goa, you would b

[Goanet] Selma Carvalho's book & some unsavoury comments - (Response on Santosh Helekar's posting by Rose Fernandes)

2014-05-15 Thread Melvyn Fernandes
Dear readers Santosh Helekar wrote to me "I am not sure what this cross examination is about".   My response:  To mark his arrival at Melvyn's cross roads, one sign reading "Goans don't tell the right story" and the other sign a chorus going "Ya, ya, ya, ya anything goes".   The wording of the

Re: [Goanet] Selma Carvalho's book & some unsavoury comments - (Response by Rose Fernandes)

2014-05-14 Thread Jose Colaco
On May 14, 2014, at 9:24 AM, Rose Fernandes wrote: "Goan Chicken". (marks and sparks)... Melvyn's eyes lit up, he thought I cooked him "Chicken Cafreal", the instructions on the packet say microwave for 2 minutes not "tell your husband" so I didn't. Dear Rose, How was it? And while packaged

Re: [Goanet] Selma Carvalho's book & some unsavoury comments - (Response by Rose Fernandes)

2014-05-14 Thread Gabe Menezes
Dear Rose, You are absolutely brilliant, your wit and style of writing surpasses! I am most grateful for your input, I thought I was out on a limb. I really enjoyed your piece and had a hearty laugh, you should contribute more, you bring a breath of fresh air! On 14 May 2014 14:24, Melvyn Fer

Re: [Goanet] Selma Carvalho's book & some unsavoury comments - (Response by Rose Fernandes)

2014-05-14 Thread Santosh Helekar
I am not sure what this cross examination is about, but let me tell you why I said Selma's book was well researched and well written. First, I received the book from Selma almost 2 weeks ago. She has signed the copy on April 22, 2014. So if I had the time to read the book completely, I could hav

[Goanet] Selma Carvalho's book & some unsavoury comments - (Response by Rose Fernandes)

2014-05-14 Thread Melvyn Fernandes
Dear goanet readers Santosh Helekar is the person who deserves high praise, if he says Selma's book is "well-researched and well written", one has to presume that he has read it from cover to cover including all research documents, if I may be so bold to ask him did he attend speed reading clas

Re: [Goanet] Selma Carvalho's book & some unsavoury comments

2014-05-13 Thread Santosh Helekar
Selma's book is well-researched and well-written. She deserves nothing but high praise. I thank her for sending a copy to me. Cheers, Santosh On Monday, May 12, 2014 5:15 AM, Mervyn Maciel wrote: The more I read this book, the more I am convinced that very few of us from >East Africa could

[Goanet] Selma Carvalho's book & some unsavoury comments

2014-05-12 Thread Mervyn Maciel
The more I read this book, the more I am convinced that very few of us from East Africa could have come up with anything as well researched as this historical opus. If some feel we could, then why didn't we all these years? Let us be grateful for a job well done - which outsiders have praised, a