Re: [GROW] Submission of draft-spaghetti-grow-bcp-ext-comms-00

2024-03-15 Thread Randy Bush
> In this draft, we introduce a recommendation to avoid the use of BGP > Extended Communities at the Route Servers of Internet Exchange points. actually, it says Operators that tag or match on route announcements on the public Internet with Extended Communities for 4-octet ASNs are

Re: [GROW] WGADOPTION - draft-spaghetti-grow-bcp-ext-comms - ENDS 04/08/2024 - Apr 8th 2024

2024-03-15 Thread Stavros Konstantaras
Hi Jeff, Thank you very much for your comment. As Job said, the draft is targeting the Route Server infrastructure of Internet Exchange Points, but do you believe that this is something that needs further clarification in the draft? If by build-in scoping you are referring to the definitions

Re: [GROW] WGADOPTION - draft-spaghetti-grow-bcp-ext-comms - ENDS 04/08/2024 - Apr 8th 2024

2024-03-15 Thread Job Snijders
Hi Jeff, On Thu, Mar 14, 2024 at 10:54:54PM -0400, Jeff Haas wrote: > I’m at least 90%, “Meh, whatever “ for the > proposal as long as it doesn’t become a recommendation to filter > the extended communities by default. For purposes of the adoption poll, > consider this a conditional