On Fri, Feb 01, 2013 at 12:49:59PM +, William Lewis wrote:
> I couldn't agree more, but I'm really in need of more concrete reasons for
> pushing back against this.
It is very possible that nginx could do the job right for you. That said,
the feedback we get from people who love haproxy for lo
Hi,
The reason is simple: You need a load-balancer.
HAProxy is a load-balancer with advanced features: many weighted
algorithm, many different persistence type (even using application
cookies), advanced reporting, etc...
Nginx isn't, despite very basic features, a load-balancer. That said,
it can
How about going the other way and fully commenting the config, sending it
to them and asking them how they would implement all of the things that you
are using in HAProxy in nginx.
If they pass it back to you as "that's your job", then you can reasonably
ask them that as you have a working solutio
s for same amount of
requests and files.
From: William Lewis [mailto:will...@netproteus.net] On Behalf Of William
Lewis
Sent: vrijdag 1 februari 2013 13:50
To: shouldbe q931
Cc: Steven Acreman; haproxy@formilux.org
Subject: Re: Comparison to nginx
I couldn't agree more, but I'm re
I couldn't agree more, but I'm really in need of more concrete reasons for
pushing back against this.
On Feb 1, 2013, at 12:40 PM, shouldbe q931 wrote:
> On Fri, Feb 1, 2013 at 11:22 AM, William Lewis wrote:
> Hi Steve,
>
> Its not a question of replacing nginx with haproxy.
> The existing so
On Fri, Feb 1, 2013 at 11:22 AM, William Lewis wrote:
> Hi Steve,
>
> Its not a question of replacing nginx with haproxy.
> The existing solution was dns round robin directly to application servers,
> that then proxy on to a different node if they didn't hold the required
> state (which is horrib
Hi Steve,
Its not a question of replacing nginx with haproxy.
The existing solution was dns round robin directly to application servers, that
then proxy on to a different node if they didn't hold the required state (which
is horrible)
I've deployed haproxy in front of this setup but I'm now bei
Hi William,
I'm not sure I'd change anything that wasn't causing me pain. If nginx is
working nicely then there are probably other things that aren't that are
more rewarding of attention.
Are there any pain points that you currently have? Maybe haproxy could
improve some of those.
Thanks,
Steve
Hi
I'm looking for some advice in comparing haproxy to nginx. I've been happily
using haproxy for all my load balancing needs for the past few years and in my
opinion I think its great.
I've recently been working to deploy it my latest role but am coming up against
resistance from supporters o
9 matches
Mail list logo