Re: [VOTE] Adopt HDSL as a new Hadoop subproject

Glad to see consensus on this proposal. This new subproject will hopefully continue Hadoop's evolution forward (dare I say the biggest one since YARN) and also intends to accomplish this with minimal project overhead. +1 binding. Thanks +Vinod > On Mar 20, 2018, at 11:20 AM, Owen O'Malley

Re: [VOTE] Adopt HDSL as a new Hadoop subproject

+1 for the sub-project idea. Thanks to everyone that contributed! Regards, Rakesh On Tue, Mar 27, 2018 at 4:46 PM, Jack Liu wrote: > +1 (non-binding) > > > On Tue, Mar 27, 2018 at 2:16 AM, Tsuyoshi Ozawa wrote: > > > +1(binding), > > > > - Tsuyoshi > > > >

Re: [VOTE] Adopt HDSL as a new Hadoop subproject

+1 (non-binding) On Tue, Mar 27, 2018 at 2:16 AM, Tsuyoshi Ozawa wrote: > +1(binding), > > - Tsuyoshi > > On Tue, Mar 20, 2018 at 14:21 Owen O'Malley > wrote: > > > All, > > > > Following our discussions on the previous thread (Merging branch >

Re: [VOTE] Adopt HDSL as a new Hadoop subproject

+1 Best, On Mon, Mar 26, 2018 at 10:38 AM, Xiao Chen wrote: > +1 > > Thanks, > -Xiao > > On Sun, Mar 25, 2018 at 9:07 PM, Akira Ajisaka > wrote: > >> +1 >> >> Thanks, >> Akira >> >> >> On 2018/03/24 15:18, Lokesh Jain wrote: >> >>> +1

Re: [VOTE] Adopt HDSL as a new Hadoop subproject

+1 Thanks, Akira On 2018/03/24 15:18, Lokesh Jain wrote: +1 (non-binding) Thanks Lokesh - To unsubscribe, e-mail: hdfs-dev-unsubscr...@hadoop.apache.org For additional commands, e-mail: hdfs-dev-h...@hadoop.apache.org

Re: [VOTE] Adopt HDSL as a new Hadoop subproject

+1 (non-binding) Thanks Lokesh - To unsubscribe, e-mail: hdfs-dev-unsubscr...@hadoop.apache.org For additional commands, e-mail: hdfs-dev-h...@hadoop.apache.org

Re: [VOTE] Adopt HDSL as a new Hadoop subproject

+1 (binding) Happy to see the community converge on a proposal. On Fri, Mar 23, 2018 at 11:18 AM, Andrew Wang wrote: > +1 > > If this VOTE is to gather consensus about establishing a new subproject, > let's definitely proceed with that. > > It sounds like we're

Re: [VOTE] Adopt HDSL as a new Hadoop subproject

+1 If this VOTE is to gather consensus about establishing a new subproject, let's definitely proceed with that. It sounds like we're already discussing changes to the details of how the project will be run, and releasing from the branch vs. maven profile is not a blocker for me. I raised it

Re: [VOTE] Adopt HDSL as a new Hadoop subproject

+1 ( binding) On Tue, Mar 20, 2018 at 11:50 PM, Owen O'Malley wrote: > All, > > Following our discussions on the previous thread (Merging branch HDFS-7240 > to trunk), I'd like to propose the following: > > * HDSL become a subproject of Hadoop. > * HDSL will release

Re: [VOTE] Adopt HDSL as a new Hadoop subproject

+1 (binding) Thanks! On Tue, Mar 20, 2018 at 11:20 AM, Owen O'Malley wrote: > All, > > Following our discussions on the previous thread (Merging branch HDFS-7240 > to trunk), I'd like to propose the following: > > * HDSL become a subproject of Hadoop. > * HDSL will

Re: [VOTE] Adopt HDSL as a new Hadoop subproject

+1 for the subproject of HDSL Instead of maintaining directly as part of main repo itself, may be we can explore 'git submodules' -Vinay On 23 Mar 2018 11:47 am, "Takanobu Asanuma" wrote: +1 (non-binding). Thanks, -Takanobu Asanuma > All, > > Following our

Re: [VOTE] Adopt HDSL as a new Hadoop subproject

+1 (non-binding). Thanks, -Takanobu Asanuma > All, > > Following our discussions on the previous thread (Merging branch HDFS-7240 > to trunk), I'd like to propose the following: > > * HDSL become a subproject of Hadoop. > * HDSL will release separately from Hadoop. Hadoop releases will not >

Re: [VOTE] Adopt HDSL as a new Hadoop subproject

+1 (non-binding) On 3/23/18, 8:23 AM, "dujunp...@gmail.com on behalf of 俊平堵" wrote: I think the proposal here is the right way to get consensus from each part of community. +1 (binding) Thanks Owen for driving this.

Re: [VOTE] Adopt HDSL as a new Hadoop subproject

I think the proposal here is the right way to get consensus from each part of community. +1 (binding) Thanks Owen for driving this. Thanks, Junping 2018-03-21 2:20 GMT+08:00 Owen O'Malley : > All, > > Following our discussions on the previous thread (Merging branch

Re: [VOTE] Adopt HDSL as a new Hadoop subproject

+1 (non-binding). Thanks, Chen > On Mar 20, 2018, at 11:20 AM, Owen O'Malley wrote: > > All, > > Following our discussions on the previous thread (Merging branch HDFS-7240 > to trunk), I'd like to propose the following: > > * HDSL become a subproject of Hadoop. > *

Re: [VOTE] Adopt HDSL as a new Hadoop subproject

+1 (Binding) Regards, Suresh On Tue, Mar 20, 2018 at 11:20 AM, Owen O'Malley wrote: > All, > > Following our discussions on the previous thread (Merging branch HDFS-7240 > to trunk), I'd like to propose the following: > > * HDSL become a subproject of Hadoop. > * HDSL

Re: [VOTE] Adopt HDSL as a new Hadoop subproject

+1 (non-binding). Thanks, Hanisha On 3/22/18, 4:06 PM, "Elek, Marton" wrote: > > > We need to do this since the source tarball is our official Apache >release > > artifact, the rest are convenience binaries. So the Maven profile is > > insufficient for this. > >It's a very

Re: [VOTE] Adopt HDSL as a new Hadoop subproject

> We need to do this since the source tarball is our official Apache release > artifact, the rest are convenience binaries. So the Maven profile is > insufficient for this. It's a very good point, but actually it could be handled with maven profile and assembly descriptors. I created

Re: [VOTE] Adopt HDSL as a new Hadoop subproject

Hi Lei/Owen, Based on Daryn’s suggestion, we have made HDSL a loadable module inside data node. It relies on the current loadable module support that is already present in HDFS. This module is loaded by Datanodes only when it is configured. --Anu On 3/22/18, 11:25 AM, "Owen O'Malley"

Re: [VOTE] Adopt HDSL as a new Hadoop subproject

On Thu, Mar 22, 2018 at 11:09 AM, Lei Xu wrote: > > I have one concrete question about how this HDSL subproject being > separated: Ozone / HDSL was designed in the current way to re-use the > existing HDFS code base as much as possible, thus today for this > container service

Re: [VOTE] Adopt HDSL as a new Hadoop subproject

Hi, Owen Thanks a lot for this proposal, as I believe it has addressed most of the concerns of the community. I have one concrete question about how this HDSL subproject being separated: Ozone / HDSL was designed in the current way to re-use the existing HDFS code base as much as possible, thus

Re: [VOTE] Adopt HDSL as a new Hadoop subproject

On Thu, Mar 22, 2018 at 10:23 AM, Andrew Wang wrote: > We want the git hash to match the contents of the tarball and tag, which is > beyond what create release does right now. It doesn't do any git stuff. ...and it can't? Even if this remains a manual step, it's not a

Re: [VOTE] Adopt HDSL as a new Hadoop subproject

We want the git hash to match the contents of the tarball and tag, which is beyond what create release does right now. It doesn't do any git stuff. Also sorry if I missed this, but have we gone through all of Owen and Daryn's earlier comments about merge readiness? Some of Daryn's in particular

Re: [VOTE] Adopt HDSL as a new Hadoop subproject

+1 (binding) This compromise seems to address most of the concerns raised during the discussion. Thanks for proposing and driving this, Owen. On Thu, Mar 22, 2018 at 9:30 AM, Andrew Wang wrote: > In Owen's proposal, it says to delete the module from the release branch.

Re: [VOTE] Adopt HDSL as a new Hadoop subproject

Hi Anu, Again apologies in advance for phone typing, flight delays means I'm still writing this from an airport :( In Owen's proposal, it says to delete the module from the release branch. We need to do this since the source tarball is our official Apache release artifact, the rest are

Re: [VOTE] Adopt HDSL as a new Hadoop subproject

+1 (non binding) Thanks, Mukul On 22/03/18, 12:31 PM, "Tsz Wo (Nicholas), Sze" wrote: +1 (binding) Tsz-Wo On Wednesday, March 21, 2018, 10:38:03 PM PDT, Jakob Homan wrote: +1 (binding) On 21 March

Re: [VOTE] Adopt HDSL as a new Hadoop subproject

+1 (binding) Tsz-Wo On Wednesday, March 21, 2018, 10:38:03 PM PDT, Jakob Homan wrote: +1 (binding) On 21 March 2018 at 20:12, Shashikant Banerjee wrote: > +1(non-binding) > > On 3/21/18, 10:13 AM, "Jitendra Pandey"

Re: [VOTE] Adopt HDSL as a new Hadoop subproject

+1 (binding) On 21 March 2018 at 20:12, Shashikant Banerjee wrote: > +1(non-binding) > > On 3/21/18, 10:13 AM, "Jitendra Pandey" wrote: > > +1 (binding) > > On 3/20/18, 8:39 PM, "Weiwei Yang" wrote: > >

Re: [VOTE] Adopt HDSL as a new Hadoop subproject

+1(non-binding) On 3/21/18, 10:13 AM, "Jitendra Pandey" wrote: +1 (binding) On 3/20/18, 8:39 PM, "Weiwei Yang" wrote: +1 (non-binding) I really like this proposal and thanks for all the discussions.

Re: [VOTE] Adopt HDSL as a new Hadoop subproject

Hi Andrew, Thanks for your comment. >” Having to delete it each time means more work for mainline RMs and more room >for error.” The current change that we have done has a maven profile called “–Phdsl," without this flag it will not be compiled and will not be included in source or binary

Re: [VOTE] Adopt HDSL as a new Hadoop subproject

Hi folks, Sorry for not replying earlier, I've been on vacation for the last week and am writing this on my phone from the airport now. Please excuse me if this is terser than my normal emails. I really like the direction of Owen's proposal, thanks Owen for driving this toward a conclusion

Re: [VOTE] Adopt HDSL as a new Hadoop subproject

+1 (non-binding) On 3/20/18, 9:43 PM, "Jitendra Pandey" wrote: +1 (binding) On 3/20/18, 8:39 PM, "Weiwei Yang" wrote: +1 (non-binding) I really like this proposal and thanks for all the discussions.

Re: [VOTE] Adopt HDSL as a new Hadoop subproject

On Tue, Mar 20, 2018 at 8:34 PM, 郑锴(铁杰) wrote: > >>* HDSL become a subproject of Hadoop. > I'm not compfortable with the HDSL name, as Konstantin mentioned. H-DSL > looks like a DSL language at the first glance. > Let's start a separate thread about the name. My

Re: [VOTE] Adopt HDSL as a new Hadoop subproject

+1 (binding) On 3/20/18, 8:39 PM, "Weiwei Yang" wrote: +1 (non-binding) I really like this proposal and thanks for all the discussions. -- Weiwei On 21 Mar 2018, 8:39 AM +0800, Arpit Agarwal , wrote: +1

Re: [VOTE] Adopt HDSL as a new Hadoop subproject

+1 (non-binding) I really like this proposal and thanks for all the discussions. -- Weiwei On 21 Mar 2018, 8:39 AM +0800, Arpit Agarwal , wrote: +1 (binding) Arpit On 3/20/18, 11:21 AM, "Owen O'Malley" wrote: All, Following our discussions

Re: [VOTE] Adopt HDSL as a new Hadoop subproject

+1 (binding) Arpit On 3/20/18, 11:21 AM, "Owen O'Malley" wrote: All, Following our discussions on the previous thread (Merging branch HDFS-7240 to trunk), I'd like to propose the following: * HDSL become a subproject of Hadoop. * HDSL will

Re: [VOTE] Adopt HDSL as a new Hadoop subproject

+1 (binding) sanjay > On Mar 20, 2018, at 11:20 AM, Owen O'Malley wrote: > > All, > > Following our discussions on the previous thread (Merging branch HDFS-7240 > to trunk), I'd like to propose the following: > > * HDSL become a subproject of Hadoop. > * HDSL will

Re: [VOTE] Adopt HDSL as a new Hadoop subproject

+1 (Binding) Xiaoyu On 3/20/18, 11:53 AM, "Anu Engineer" wrote: +1 (Binding) --Anu On 3/20/18, 11:21 AM, "Owen O'Malley" wrote: All, Following our discussions on the previous thread

Re: [VOTE] Adopt HDSL as a new Hadoop subproject

+1 (Binding) --Anu On 3/20/18, 11:21 AM, "Owen O'Malley" wrote: All, Following our discussions on the previous thread (Merging branch HDFS-7240 to trunk), I'd like to propose the following: * HDSL become a subproject of Hadoop. * HDSL will