Re: RACF - Any way to find out before hand what the user's access is to a file

2010-05-10 Thread Shmuel Metz (Seymour J.)
In ncbblknfeephcaamofkleebmlhaa.r.han...@rshconsulting.com, on 05/02/2010 at 07:04 AM, Robert S. Hansel (RSH) r.han...@rshconsulting.com said: For datasets, the ICH408I message and associated SMF type 80 record will show the Generic profile that was guarding the resource at the time of the

Re: RACF - Any way to find out before hand what the user's access is to a file

2010-05-10 Thread Chase, John
-Original Message- From: IBM Mainframe Discussion List On Behalf Of Shmuel Metz (Seymour J.) In ncbblknfeephcaamofkleebmlhaa.r.han...@rshconsulting.com, on 05/02/2010 at 07:04 AM, Robert S. Hansel (RSH) r.han...@rshconsulting.com said: For datasets, the ICH408I message and

Re: RACF - Any way to find out before hand what the user's access is to a file

2010-05-03 Thread Tony @ Comcast
Nope. We have other means to make that determination. The unnamed company in Nevada provides a nice report. -Original Message- From: IBM Mainframe Discussion List [mailto:ibm-m...@bama.ua.edu] On Behalf Of Paul Gilmartin Sent: Saturday, May 01, 2010 7:05 PM To:

Re: RACF - Any way to find out before hand what the user's access is to a file

2010-05-02 Thread Robert S. Hansel (RSH)
Gil, For datasets, the ICH408I message and associated SMF type 80 record will show the Generic profile that was guarding the resource at the time of the violation or warning. If they do not specify a profile, it is usually the case that a Discrete profile (one exactly matching the name of the

Re: RACF - Any way to find out before hand what the user's access is to a file

2010-05-02 Thread Robert S. Hansel (RSH)
Ted, In those banking environments, did you protect or monitor the use of the LISTDSD, RLIST, or SEARCH commands and their aliases? As discussed in the October 2009 issue of our RSH RACF Tips newsletter, these commands offer a wealth of information to a would-be hacker, and their use is not

Re: RACF - Any way to find out before hand what the user's access is to a file

2010-05-02 Thread Ted MacNEIL
In those banking environments, did you protect or monitor the use of the LISTDSD, RLIST, or SEARCH commands and their aliases? I wasn't the security admin. I was just aware of the policy and the potential 'exposure'. Considering how obsessive most security personel are, I can assume what was

Re: RACF - Any way to find out before hand what the user's access is to a file

2010-05-01 Thread Joel C. Ewing
On 04/30/2010 07:43 PM, Edward Jaffe wrote: Stocker, Herman wrote: To answer the why needed question: On occasion security has stated that access has been given only later to find out that the incorrect access was granted or not granted at all. Causing jobs to fail and time to be lost,

Re: RACF - Any way to find out before hand what the user's access is to a file

2010-05-01 Thread Ted MacNEIL
wants away to check security. Coming from a Banking background, I believe a user should not have the ability to check beforehand. That's a security exposure, because the user may find something that they normally wouldn't. Also, don't blame it on out-sourcing. I've seen incompetent in-house

Re: RACF - Any way to find out before hand what the user's access is to a file

2010-05-01 Thread Shane Ginnane
Who cares if there is decent logging in place. I also have a banking background (amongst others), and there were situations where I preferred not to have code fail unnecessarily. Particularly exits that were checking using some elses ACEE. ISTR ACF2 made this more do-able than RACF. No news

Re: RACF - Any way to find out before hand what the user's access is to a file

2010-05-01 Thread Paul Gilmartin
On Sat, 1 May 2010 13:01:24 +, Ted MacNEIL wrote: wants away to check security. Coming from a Banking background, I believe a user should not have the ability to check beforehand. That's a security exposure, because the user may find something that they normally wouldn't. I was hoping

Re: RACF - Any way to find out before hand what the user's access is to a file

2010-05-01 Thread Tony @ Comcast
Way back when we converted to RACF from Top Secret we received a number of requests, often from dis-belief that access was still there. What we did to quickly check that USER1 had access to the HLQ1.NODE2.WHATEVER.** (the user was connected to multiple groups that made checking timeconsuming)

Re: RACF - Any way to find out before hand what the user's access is to a file

2010-05-01 Thread Don Leahy
Some shops allow the use of an API to the security system in order to allow applications to determine if a user has access to a resource or not. This can be used to control application behaviour by limiting the data displayed or the actions available. To cite a trivial example, an application

Re: RACF - Any way to find out before hand what the user's access is to a file

2010-05-01 Thread Ted MacNEIL
Some shops allow the use of an API to the security system in order to allow applications to determine if a user has access to a resource or not. This can be used to control application behaviour by limiting the data displayed or the actions available. That is a different situation. That is

Re: RACF - Any way to find out before hand what the user's access is to a file

2010-05-01 Thread Binyamin Dissen
On Sat, 1 May 2010 17:02:39 -0400 Don Leahy don.le...@leacom.ca wrote: :Some shops allow the use of an API to the security system in order to :allow applications to determine if a user has access to a resource or :not. This can be used to control application behaviour by limiting :the data

Re: RACF - Any way to find out before hand what the user's access is to a file

2010-05-01 Thread Paul Gilmartin
On Sat, 1 May 2010 11:12:00 -0500, Tony wrote: 1. rdef a surrogat profile USER1.submit and permit ourselves to it. 2. run a batch job as user=USER1 that would attempt to allocate HLQ1.NODE2.WHATEVER.TESTRACF.FILE. 3. run another job to load a record into said file. 4. run another job to delete

RACF - Any way to find out before hand what the user's access is to a file

2010-04-30 Thread Stocker, Herman
G'day, I have been asked if there is away for the user to find out what access they have to a data set before they attempt to update or read it. Is their any RACF command that a general user could use to find out the type access they have to a data set? Thank you. Regards, Herman Stocker

Re: RACF - Any way to find out before hand what the user's access is to a file

2010-04-30 Thread Elardus Engelbrecht
Stocker, Herman wrote: I have been asked if there is away for the user to find out what access they have to a data set before they attempt to update or read it. Is their any RACF command that a general user could use to find out the type access they have to a data set? Yes, let the general

Re: RACF - Any way to find out before hand what the user's access is to a file

2010-04-30 Thread Rob Scott
Remember that this will *not* take into account any logic in the RACF exits (if any) that can upgrade/downgrade the user's access - plus there might be volser-specific rules in effect as well. Rob Scott Developer Rocket Software 275 Grove Street * Newton, MA 02466-2272 * USA Tel:

Re: RACF - Any way to find out before hand what the user's access is to a file

2010-04-30 Thread Binyamin Dissen
On Fri, 30 Apr 2010 06:42:08 -0600 Stocker, Herman herman.stoc...@avisbudget.com wrote: :I have been asked if there is away for the user to find out what access they have to a data set before they attempt to update or read it. Well, they could ask the security guy. The real issue is why do

Re: RACF - Any way to find out before hand what the user's access is to a file

2010-04-30 Thread Elardus Engelbrecht
Rob Scott wrote: Remember that this will *not* take into account any logic in the RACF exits (if any) that can upgrade/downgrade the user's access - plus there might be volser-specific rules in effect as well. I know. The OP asked for a command. My example also assumes there is a GENERIC

Re: RACF - Any way to find out before hand what the user's access is to a file

2010-04-30 Thread Stocker, Herman
Thank you for you fast response. To answer the why needed question: On occasion security has stated that access has been given only later to find out that the incorrect access was granted or not granted at all. Causing jobs to fail and time to be lost, therefore the user wants away to check

Re: RACF - Any way to find out before hand what the user's access is to a file

2010-04-30 Thread Donald Johnson
IIRC, it is also a way to verify which profile is covering a file, so if the SecAdmin said they changed it and it isn't working, you can confirm that the correct profile was changed. * Don * On Fri, Apr 30, 2010 at 10:26 AM, Stocker, Herman herman.stoc...@avisbudget.com wrote: Thank you for

Re: RACF - Any way to find out before hand what the user's access is to a file

2010-04-30 Thread Edward Jaffe
Stocker, Herman wrote: To answer the why needed question: On occasion security has stated that access has been given only later to find out that the incorrect access was granted or not granted at all. Causing jobs to fail and time to be lost, therefore the user wants away to check security.