Re: IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-31 Thread Scott Brim
On Friday, May 31, 2013, Abdussalam Baryun wrote: So lets be explicit. This is a standards-setting body, which is discussing outreach, inclusiveness, wider participation outcomes, and the cost consequences on attendance where the core motivation is standards setting. Yes, let's be

Re: IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-31 Thread Arturo Servin
On 5/31/13 9:53 AM, Scott Brim wrote: I don't know what the smiley is supposed to connote, but the IETF responds to changes in the community by changing its engineering goals and the problems it works on. I would add that the IETF should change the way we solve those problems as

Re: financial fun with an IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-31 Thread Carlos M. Martinez
Jorge, I seriously believe you're overreacting and overrepresenting the actual view of the people in Argentina. Few, if any, members of the Internet community in Argentina and neighboring countries share this view, and almost all of us can't help laughing at the ironic situation where some people

Re: financial fun with an IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-31 Thread Jorge Amodio
Carlos, I clearly stated that the comment was OT, ie didn't have to much relation with the discussion. I'm not overreacting or misrepresenting anything, it was just an OT comment about a blog article which IMHO I consider really stupid and completely out of lalaland. I didn't say a protest WILL

Re: financial fun with an IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-31 Thread Carlos M. Martinez
Whether OT or not you actively contribute to the mood of the discussion. And to have a fruitful discussion on the topic I believe we MUST accurately represent the facts, again, regardless of being OT or not. ~Carlos On 5/31/13 3:07 PM, Jorge Amodio wrote: Carlos, I clearly stated that the

Re: financial fun with an IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-31 Thread Jorge Amodio
The existence of that article IS a fact -Jorge On May 31, 2013, at 1:15 PM, Carlos M. Martinez carlosm3...@gmail.com wrote: Whether OT or not you actively contribute to the mood of the discussion. And to have a fruitful discussion on the topic I believe we MUST accurately represent the

Re: IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-30 Thread Abdussalam Baryun
On 5/30/13, George Michaelson g...@algebras.org wrote: At risk of alienating my comrades from locations seeking to attract an IETF for local development/inclusiveness and the like reasons, I think John gets to the nub of the matter: the wider community cost, borne by all attendees as a 'silent

Re: IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-29 Thread Yoav Nir
On May 29, 2013, at 5:09 AM, Melinda Shore melinda.sh...@gmail.com wrote: On 5/28/13 3:06 PM, l.w...@surrey.ac.uk wrote: The centres for networking industry in Australia are Melbourne and Sydney, in that order. It's a bit like IETF 51 being held in Grimsby, not London or Cambridge.

Re: IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-29 Thread Patrik Fältström
ICANN 48 is to be held in Buenos Aires, Argentina, 17-21 November 2013, and I am looking forward to it! Patrik On 29 maj 2013, at 04:27, Arturo Servin aser...@lacnic.net wrote: Perhaps not. Buenos Aires is also a big hub of technology in Latin America. In addition as it was

RE: IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-29 Thread S Moonesamy
At 22:18 28-05-2013, GT RAMIREZ, Medel G. wrote: How about in the Philippines? I can show my homeland… I can help facilitate the event, why don’t you give it a try! In the message that was quoted the person mentioned that: I understand that usually the place is chosen based on the most of

Re: IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-29 Thread Abdussalam Baryun
sistopef...@gmail.com wrote: Hello, I agree with the Idea of a IETF meeting in South America. I think it is a way to let the people know about IETF (of course there are other ways, but this is a good one), to give the possibility to students/engineers with very good skills to get into the IETF

Re: More participation from under-represented regions (was: IETF Meeting in South America)

2013-05-29 Thread Abdussalam Baryun
Hi SM my answer to your reply, On 5/27/13, SM s...@resistor.net wrote: Hi Abdussalam, At 16:38 26-05-2013, Abdussalam Baryun wrote: I think they SHOULD have, and all of us should do the same, because IETF will expand and become stronger by increasing participants from ALL Internet community

Re: IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-29 Thread Abdussalam Baryun
On 5/29/13, S Moonesamy sm+i...@elandsys.com wrote: I wasn't unable to attend an IETF meeting some time ago due to an administrative issue. The proposal I intended to discuss about (it was discussed during a session) was not adopted. With hindsight I'll say that the proposal would not have

Re: IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-29 Thread Jorge Amodio
ICANN constituencies, mission and participants are way different than IETF and an important number of folks receive financial support to participate. I believe the discussion is not really about if Buenos Aires is the right location or not but if by meeting in a particular region that will drive

Re: IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-29 Thread John C Klensin
--On Wednesday, May 29, 2013 14:50 +1000 George Michaelson g...@algebras.org wrote: I went to Adelaide. it was my first IETF. I am now an IETF regular-irregular, of 10+ years standing. So, proof by example, it increased Australian participation by at least 1. ... I think that increasing

Re: IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-29 Thread John C Klensin
--On Wednesday, May 29, 2013 08:34 +0200 Patrik Fältström p...@frobbit.se wrote: ICANN 48 is to be held in Buenos Aires, Argentina, 17-21 November 2013, and I am looking forward to it! Patrik, ICANN has taken on a formal obligation to meet regularly in Latin America, sees significant

Re: IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-29 Thread Patrik Fältström
On 29 maj 2013, at 13:31, John C Klensin john-i...@jck.com wrote: Given the differences between ICANN and the IETF, this is relevant how? I was not clear enough on my response. I see two things discussed: 1. Whether the organisation should move around and place meetings here and there.

IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-29 Thread Ines Robles
Hello, I agree with the Idea of a IETF meeting in South America. I think it is a way to let the people know about IETF (of course there are other ways, but this is a good one), to give the possibility to students/engineers with very good skills to get into the IETF, thinking that it is going

financial fun with an IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-29 Thread Ines Robles
Hello, I'd also say that I've never heard anyone making that sort of statement. For instance, the argentinan government itself has a program to increase Internet connectivity throughout the country -- That is the web page of the program that Fernando mentions,

Re: IETF Meeting in South America (off-topic)

2013-05-29 Thread S Moonesamy
At 02:19 29-05-2013, Abdussalam Baryun wrote: I don't think I should follow the IETF culture to make my I-D adopted by WG, but I may follow the good/technical reasons the WG provide. We If a working group does not show any interest in working on an I-D it is a good enough reason, in my

Re: IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-29 Thread George Michaelson
yes, I made a facetious posting because I sensed that we were discussing outcomes on a basis of 'nothing happened' when in fact, I think by scale, Australian participation reflects if not exceeds our numerical role in standards development and Internet matters. There is reason to believe we do

Re: IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-28 Thread Dave Crocker
On 5/27/2013 11:38 PM, Christian O'Flaherty wrote: I would like to follow up on this proposal. Having a meeting in South America scheduled two or three years in advance will let us engage local organisations and individuals on a project. We did several activities in the region trying to

Re: IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-28 Thread Eliot Lear
Hi, Actually it's not industry that I hear complaining, but individuals. Eliot On 5/27/13 10:08 AM, Jari Arkko wrote: Melinda wrote: The industry sector bias in IETF participation is possibly compounding the regional bias. Yes. Jari

Re: IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-28 Thread Eric Burger
Riiight. That is why one never has to attend an IETF meeting in person to serve on NOMCOM, one does not need travel support from one's employer to be on the IESG, and why people who never come to IETF meetings are the rule and not the exception with respect to getting documents adopted and

Re: IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-28 Thread Ted Lemon
On May 28, 2013, at 8:46 AM, Eric Burger ebur...@standardstrack.com wrote: Riiight. That is why one never has to attend an IETF meeting in person to serve on NOMCOM, one does not need travel support from one's employer to be on the IESG, and why people who never come to IETF meetings are the

Re: WebRTC and emergency communications (Was: Re: IETF Meeting in South America)

2013-05-28 Thread Janet P Gunn
Date: 05/25/2013 03:10 AM Subject: WebRTC and emergency communications (Was: Re: IETF Meeting in South America) Sent by: ietf-boun...@ietf.org James: did you know that you have a audio/video realtime interactive communications WG churning out proposals and solutions

[Isoc-br] IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-28 Thread Rogerio Mariano
Dear IETF Managers, My name is Rogério Mariano and I`m a member of the Internet Society (Global Member # 339380) and a student of Internet Governance Programme (IGCBP) DiploFoundation and Consultant for the definition and operation of the Service Provider direction related to the technical

Re: Re: More participation from under-represented regions (was: IETF Meeting in South America)

2013-05-28 Thread Jiankang Yao
I support to try the new meeting sites such as South America or Africa. Jiankang Yao From: Abdussalam Baryun Date: 2013-05-27 07:38 To: SM CC: ietf; dcrocker Subject: Re: More participation from under-represented regions (was: IETF Meeting in South America) I support to add the new region

Re: IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-28 Thread Christian O'Flaherty
The IETF has a big problem, IMHO, in that effective participation really does currently seem to require meeting attendance. There's a reason that nomcom members have to show up—if they didn't, they wouldn't be part of the actual culture of IETF, because so much IETF culture is bound up

Re: financial fun with an IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-28 Thread Fernando Gont
On 05/27/2013 07:31 AM, Juliao Braga wrote: According to the news published for a long time in Brazilian newspapers and magazines, Buenos Aires (a wonderful place!) would not be recommended. Recommended for what? And on what basis? Cheers, -- Fernando Gont e-mail: ferna...@gont.com.ar ||

Re: financial fun with an IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-28 Thread Fernando Gont
Jorge, On 05/27/2013 08:16 AM, Jorge Amodio wrote: I feel that is totally OT but for example we have supporters of the current government like this one, claiming to be a writer, that if you are able to read in Spanish or helped by a translator to read his article, you will learn that he is

Re: financial fun with an IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-28 Thread Fernando Gont
Hi, Tim, On 05/27/2013 09:19 AM, Tim Chown wrote: The move appears to be related to new, restrictive regulations the Argentine government has imposed on currency exchanges.' According to the Telegraph, 'The new regulations required anyone wanting to change Argentine pesos into another

Re: financial fun with an IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-28 Thread Juliao Braga
Hi Fernando, Please, read my sentence complementary to comment: ...But who should tell us about the true cenary would be our Argentine friends. Regards, Julião Em 28/05/2013 10:36, Fernando Gont escreveu: On 05/27/2013 07:31 AM, Juliao Braga wrote: According to the news published for a long

Re: WebRTC and emergency communications (Was: Re: IETF Meeting in South America)

2013-05-28 Thread Ted Hardie
On Sat, May 25, 2013 at 12:10 AM, Jari Arkko jari.ar...@piuha.net wrote: James: did you know that you have a audio/video realtime interactive communications WG churning out proposals and solutions that is *actively* ignoring emergency communications in its entirety? No? Look at RTCweb,

Re: IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-28 Thread Melinda Shore
On 5/28/13 6:20 AM, Christian O'Flaherty wrote: Probably, this lack of social interaction in our region is one of the main reasons for low participation. Most of latin american IETFers are currently living outside the region and they engaged in the IETF when living in the US or Europe. It's

Re: IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-28 Thread joel jaeggli
On 5/23/13 8:02 PM, David Conrad wrote: On May 23, 2013, at 7:44 PM, Melinda Shore melinda.sh...@gmail.com wrote: So the question is why we aren't seeing more drafts, reviews, and discussions from people in Central and South America, Language? It would seem likely when the participation is

Re: financial fun with an IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-28 Thread Fernando Gont
Julio, I'm worried about people making statements on a random basis. I assume that many people (IAOC and many others) have made a lot of effort before getting to the point of formally proposing/suggesting to have an IETF meeting in Buenos Aires. I bet much of that effort had to do with making an

Re: financial fun with an IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-28 Thread Carlos M. Martinez
The bad things that happen in Argentina financially affect only Argentinians. I'm not saying this is a good thing overall, just saying that this isn't a problem for tourists and certainly won't be a problem for IETFers. Probably these financial 'issues' will even affect positively the

Re: WebRTC and emergency communications (Was: Re: IETF Meeting in South America)

2013-05-28 Thread James Polk
At 11:58 AM 5/28/2013, Ted Hardie wrote: On Sat, May 25, 2013 at 12:10 AM, Jari Arkko mailto:jari.ar...@piuha.netjari.ar...@piuha.net wrote: James: did you know that you have a audio/video realtime interactive communications WG churning out proposals and solutions that is *actively*

Re: financial fun with an IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-28 Thread Juliao Braga
Dear Fernando, If I have to decide about a meeting in Buenos Aires based in the information that I read in the Brazilian newspapers and magazines I decide to no. By this reason I need to listen from Argentine people, as you. I believe this is the right way to decide. The choice of Buenos Aires

Re: WebRTC and emergency communications (Was: Re: IETF Meeting in South America)

2013-05-28 Thread Richard Barnes
I would suggest we not try to sort out on this list which sorts of Internet services are subject to American regulations. On Tue, May 28, 2013 at 2:20 PM, James Polk jmp...@cisco.com wrote: At 11:58 AM 5/28/2013, Ted Hardie wrote: On Sat, May 25, 2013 at 12:10 AM, Jari Arkko mailto:

Re: [Isoc-br] IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-28 Thread Scott Brim
Dear Rogério Mariano, You have a great deal of experience. Since the mission of the IETF is to make the Internet better, could you point out specific problems that you would like to work on in the IETF? When you say infrastructure and standardization, that is very general. If there were an

Re: WebRTC and emergency communications (Was: Re: IETF Meeting in South America)

2013-05-28 Thread Paul Hoffman
On May 28, 2013, at 11:25 AM, Richard Barnes r...@ipv.sx wrote: I would suggest we not try to sort out on this list which sorts of Internet services are subject to American regulations. Or those of any other jurisdiction. If jurisdiction Z comes to the IETF and says we have declared protocol

Re: IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-28 Thread Christian O'Flaherty
On Tue, May 28, 2013 at 2:15 PM, Melinda Shore melinda.sh...@gmail.com wrote: On 5/28/13 6:20 AM, Christian O'Flaherty wrote: Probably, this lack of social interaction in our region is one of the main reasons for low participation. Most of latin american IETFers are currently living outside

Re: IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-28 Thread Christian O'Flaherty
It would seem likely when the participation is heaviliy biased towards equipment vendors and software tooling that the participants would be more representative of where the concentration of the development sideo of that work occurs. This is true, but this is also something where active

Re: WebRTC and emergency communications (Was: Re: IETF Meeting in South America)

2013-05-28 Thread Ted Hardie
On Tue, May 28, 2013 at 11:20 AM, James Polk jmp...@cisco.com wrote: Quoting Henning: At least in the US, many of the WebRTC services would be considered interconnected VoIP, so they are indeed subject to 911 obligations. James BTW- yeah, I know I'm picking a fight - but Jari singled this

Re: financial fun with an IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-28 Thread Fernando Gont
Julio, On 05/28/2013 08:20 PM, Juliao Braga wrote: If I have to decide about a meeting in Buenos Aires based in the information that I read in the Brazilian newspapers and magazines I decide to no. Could you please provide pointers to such articles? Additionally, could you please summarize

Re: financial fun with an IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-28 Thread Juliao Braga
Fernando, Please, read the Brazilian newspapers and magazines. I'm not looking for news from Argentina. I see them and / or read just the same way that I see or read others news, always an passant. This type of issue is not exactly my specialty or interest. But you can see a handful of recents

RE: IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-28 Thread l.wood
Any sense of why that didn't happen with Australians after the Adelaide meeting? The centres for networking industry in Australia are Melbourne and Sydney, in that order. It's a bit like IETF 51 being held in Grimsby, not London or Cambridge. Lloyd Wood http://sat-net.com/L.Wood

Re: financial fun with an IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-28 Thread Arturo Servin
Juliao, I went to all this sites (besides BBC Brazil) and searched for Argentina. There were some news about economy, the lady President, some about the senate, commercial balance but none saying huu, scary Argentina, do not go there. Regards, as On 5/28/13 7:13 PM, Juliao Braga wrote:

Re: IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-28 Thread joel jaeggli
On 5/28/13 11:56 AM, Christian O'Flaherty wrote: It would seem likely when the participation is heaviliy biased towards equipment vendors and software tooling that the participants would be more representative of where the concentration of the development sideo of that work occurs. This is

Re: financial fun with an IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-28 Thread Juliao Braga
Arturo, Who said ...huu, scary Argentina, do not go there? Where? In this list? Em 28/05/2013 20:09, Arturo Servin escreveu: Juliao, I went to all this sites (besides BBC Brazil) and searched for Argentina. There were some news about economy, the lady President, some about the

Re: financial fun with an IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-28 Thread Arturo Servin
not be recommended sounds to me it sounded like huu, scary, do not go there. /as On 5/27/13 2:31 AM, Juliao Braga wrote: According to the news published for a long time in Brazilian newspapers and magazines, Buenos Aires (a wonderful place!) would not be recommended. But who

Re: financial fun with an IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-28 Thread Juliao Braga
Arturo, I'm sorry that you interpret this way. But absolutely, I do not mean to offend. Only expressed a point of view and said that our Argentine friends could clarify. You can not trust the press, totally. Anyway, I apologize if there was offense. Best Regards, Juliao Em 28/05/2013 20:36,

Re: financial fun with an IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-28 Thread Arturo Servin
Not taken. It was estrange to me that it were many news about how bad Argentina is in the Brazilian press. I read frequently BBC-Brazil and other newspapers of latin america and I haven't read such things, that is why. /as On 5/28/13 8:45 PM, Juliao Braga wrote: Arturo, I'm

Re: IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-28 Thread Melinda Shore
On 5/28/13 3:06 PM, l.w...@surrey.ac.uk wrote: The centres for networking industry in Australia are Melbourne and Sydney, in that order. It's a bit like IETF 51 being held in Grimsby, not London or Cambridge. Okay. So, should we be extrapolating from this to what we can expect from

Re: IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-28 Thread Arturo Servin
Perhaps not. Buenos Aires is also a big hub of technology in Latin America. In addition as it was mentioned it relatively close from Sao Paulo, Montevideo and Santiago. Also there are direct flights from other major cities in Peru and Colombia. Going to Buenos Aires, Sao Paulo,

Re: IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-28 Thread Juliao Braga
I think we can expect a lot of Brazilians people in Buenos Aires. Juliao Em 28/05/2013 23:09, Melinda Shore escreveu: Okay. So, should we be extrapolating from this to what we can expect from Brazilians if we meet in Buenos Aires?

Re: IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-28 Thread Melinda Shore
On 5/28/13 6:27 PM, Arturo Servin wrote: Going to Buenos Aires, Sao Paulo, Mexico City or Santiago will always split audiences as these are the major tech hubs in the region (also add Bogota, Lima, San Jose and other cities). So, I think it is not comparable with Australia. I actually

Re: IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-28 Thread Arturo Servin
On 5/28/13 11:47 PM, Melinda Shore wrote: On 5/28/13 6:27 PM, Arturo Servin wrote: Going to Buenos Aires, Sao Paulo, Mexico City or Santiago will always split audiences as these are the major tech hubs in the region (also add Bogota, Lima, San Jose and other cities). So, I think it is

RE: IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-28 Thread l.wood
May 2013 03:47 To: ietf@ietf.org Subject: Re: IETF Meeting in South America On 5/28/13 6:27 PM, Arturo Servin wrote: Going to Buenos Aires, Sao Paulo, Mexico City or Santiago will always split audiences as these are the major tech hubs in the region (also add Bogota, Lima, San Jose and other

IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-28 Thread I rob
Hello, I agree with the Idea of a IETF meeting in South America. I think it is a way to let the people know about IETF (of course there are other ways, but this is a good one), to give the possibility to students/engineers with very good skills to get into the IETF, thinking that it is going

Re: financial fun with an IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-28 Thread I rob
Hello, I'd also say that I've never heard anyone making that sort of statement. For instance, the argentinan government itself has a program to increase Internet connectivity throughout the country -- That is the web page of the program that Fernando mentions,

Re: IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-28 Thread George Michaelson
said? Thanks so much! Lloyd Wood http://sat-net.com/L.Wood/ From: ietf-boun...@ietf.org [ietf-boun...@ietf.org] On Behalf Of Melinda Shore [melinda.sh...@gmail.com] Sent: 29 May 2013 03:47 To: ietf@ietf.org Subject: Re: IETF Meeting in South

RE: IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-28 Thread GT RAMIREZ, Medel G.
Meeting in South America Hello, I agree with the Idea of a IETF meeting in South America. I think it is a way to let the people know about IETF (of course there are other ways, but this is a good one), to give the possibility to students/engineers with very good skills to get into the IETF

Re: IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-28 Thread Jorge Amodio
Just wondering if some folks realize that IETF meetings are not missionary trips, conferences, conventions or industry trade shows ... -Jorge

Re: More participation from under-represented regions (was: IETF Meeting in South America)

2013-05-27 Thread SM
Hi Abdussalam, At 16:38 26-05-2013, Abdussalam Baryun wrote: I think they SHOULD have, and all of us should do the same, because IETF will expand and become stronger by increasing participants from ALL Internet community regions. The answers also based on IETF vesion. The question was about

Re: financial fun with an IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-27 Thread Jorge Amodio
The financial and political current situation is more complex than just the manipulation and restrictions on currency exchange and payment of obligations. I feel that is totally OT but for example we have supporters of the current government like this one, claiming to be a writer, that if you

Re: financial fun with an IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-27 Thread Tim Chown
On 27 May 2013, at 05:15, John Levine jo...@taugh.com wrote: The move appears to be related to new, restrictive regulations the Argentine government has imposed on currency exchanges.' According to the Telegraph, 'The new regulations required anyone wanting to change Argentine pesos into

Re: IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-27 Thread Jari Arkko
I'm not quite sure the currency exchange issues are key for this discussion. FWIW, I think you can still budget in Euros for the Berlin meeting, but I'm only 97% sure :-) Anyway, I wanted to highlight that, as has been pointed out by many, just meeting at some place makes little sense. But the

Re: financial fun with an IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-27 Thread John R Levine
Is this above advice from Tripadvisor correct? I believe so, but when I was there a few years ago for the ICANN meeting, excess cash was not a problem. It wasn't hard to estimate how much cash I'd need, and whatever was left I spent at the airport. The wine they drink in Argentina is often

Re: WebRTC and emergency communications (Was: Re: IETF Meeting in South America)

2013-05-27 Thread Henning Schulzrinne
The most difficult part for any emergency calling system is location delivery. WebRTC probably doesn't have much impact on emergency calls if all the calls traverse a server of some kind and if the caller location can be looked up based on caller IP addresses, but once you have the end system

Re: financial fun with an IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-27 Thread Jorge Amodio
You should double check, regulations about currency markets are changing very often, custom/immigration officials will almost for sure ask you how much currency you are bringing and for what, and as the trip advisor page says don't expect to be able to convert back leftover pesos to foreign

Re: WebRTC and emergency communications (Was: Re: IETF Meeting in South America)

2013-05-27 Thread Richard Barnes
Even for location delivery, there's not that much to say at the standards layer. For *delivery*, the story is the same as with signaling. Either the RTCWeb VoIP service can translate the location information to comply with RFC 6442, or the PSAP can just build a web app that collects it however

Re: WebRTC and emergency communications (Was: Re: IETF Meeting in South America)

2013-05-27 Thread Henning Schulzrinne
Agreed - this is not so much about standards, but developer awareness. If we write any how to or similar informational documents, they should probably contain that type of discussion. There is a browser aspect, however: Right now, users only have a binary choice about location disclosure, even

Re: WebRTC and emergency communications (Was: Re: IETF Meeting in South America)

2013-05-27 Thread cb.list6
On May 27, 2013 10:56 AM, Henning Schulzrinne h...@cs.columbia.edu wrote: Agreed - this is not so much about standards, but developer awareness. If we write any how to or similar informational documents, they should probably contain that type of discussion. There is a browser aspect, however:

Re: financial fun with an IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-27 Thread Tim Chown
On 27 May 2013, at 16:37, John R Levine jo...@taugh.com wrote: Is this above advice from Tripadvisor correct? I believe so, but when I was there a few years ago for the ICANN meeting, excess cash was not a problem. It wasn't hard to estimate how much cash I'd need, and whatever was left

Re: IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-27 Thread Christian O'Flaherty
Hi, On Mon, May 27, 2013 at 5:08 AM, Jari Arkko jari.ar...@piuha.net wrote: I'm not quite sure the currency exchange issues are key for this discussion. FWIW, I think you can still budget in Euros for the Berlin meeting, but I'm only 97% sure :-) Anyway, I wanted to highlight that, as has

Re: WebRTC and emergency communications (Was: Re: IETF Meeting in South America)

2013-05-27 Thread Richard Barnes
Keep in mind, though, that the binary decision is usually per site. So if the PSAP is web-enabled, the user can provide location to 911.gov, and not anyone else. That seems like a solution that's more likely to deploy than something that requires the browser to distinguish emergency from

Re: IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-26 Thread Dave Crocker
The IAOC has put forward two reasons for having an IETF meeting in South America: Encouraging growing participation will help strengthen the Internet, further encourage participation from those areas that will see the most growth in the coming years, and will help advance the IETF in political

Re: IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-26 Thread Juliao Braga
This is the main question with one pragmatic solution proposal in brief, and well justified! Juliao Em 26/05/2013 13:42, Dave Crocker escreveu: If we are serious about wanting more participation from under-represented regions, then let's attack that issue seriously and substantively, rather

Re: WebRTC and emergency communications (Was: Re: IETF Meeting in South America)

2013-05-26 Thread Richard Barnes
Indeed, there has already been some coordination between the groups, going back about a year: http://tools.ietf.org/agenda/84/slides/slides-84-ecrit-0.pdf http://tools.ietf.org/id/draft-aboba-rtcweb-ecrit-00.txt So my read of the situation is much less dire than James's. As I understand it, the

More participation from under-represented regions (was: IETF Meeting in South America)

2013-05-26 Thread SM
At 09:42 26-05-2013, Dave Crocker wrote: I like visiting South America. But IETF meetings do not have tourism as a goal. So yes, I'm sure those who go will enjoy the city; but again, that's not stated purpose of choosing venues. Over a year ago the IAOC [was] pleased to announce the Return

Re: [Recentattendees] IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-26 Thread John C Klensin
--On Sunday, May 26, 2013 15:46 -0400 Ray Pelletier rpellet...@isoc.org wrote: The venues are in Buenos Aires. They meet our requirements for the meeting space, networking, nearby restaurants and bars, hotel room rates in the mid $200 dollar range, nearby alternate hotels at a broad range

Re: More participation from under-represented regions (was: IETF Meeting in South America)

2013-05-26 Thread Abdussalam Baryun
I support to add the new region, hoping in future Africa gets its chance. IMO, I thought about it from another point of view. After a long time of having IETF meetings mostly in one region (as history of North America region gaining most meetings), the result of that was that IETF participants are

Re: IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-26 Thread Abdussalam Baryun
I support the ietf-meeting in new regions, and reply as below, On 5/26/13, Dave Crocker d...@dcrocker.net wrote: The IAOC has put forward two reasons for having an IETF meeting in South America: Encouraging growing participation will help strengthen the Internet, further encourage

Re: IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-26 Thread Dave Crocker
Just to make the topic a little more interesting... Google Unable To Keep Paying App Developers In Argentina http://developers.slashdot.org/story/13/05/25/132232/google-unable-to-keep-paying-app-developers-in-argentina Google has sent letters to app developers registered in Argentina

Re: financial fun with an IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-26 Thread John Levine
The move appears to be related to new, restrictive regulations the Argentine government has imposed on currency exchanges.' According to the Telegraph, 'The new regulations required anyone wanting to change Argentine pesos into another currency to submit an online request for permission

Re: financial fun with an IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-26 Thread Juliao Braga
According to the news published for a long time in Brazilian newspapers and magazines, Buenos Aires (a wonderful place!) would not be recommended. But who should tell us about the true cenary would be our Argentine friends. Juliao Em 27/05/2013 01:15, John Levine escreveu: These kinds of

WebRTC and emergency communications (Was: Re: IETF Meeting in South America)

2013-05-25 Thread Jari Arkko
James: did you know that you have a audio/video realtime interactive communications WG churning out proposals and solutions that is *actively* ignoring emergency communications in its entirety? No? Look at RTCweb, which will become a dominant form of interactive communications between

Re: WebRTC and emergency communications (Was: Re: IETF Meeting in South America)

2013-05-25 Thread John C Klensin
--On Saturday, May 25, 2013 10:10 +0300 Jari Arkko jari.ar...@piuha.net wrote: ... I didn't know about the details of the emergency communications situation. But it is always difficult to balance getting something out early vs. complete. I know how much pressure there is on the working

Re: WebRTC and emergency communications (Was: Re: IETF Meeting in South America)

2013-05-25 Thread Abdussalam Baryun
I don't think there is any general solution to the early vs. complete tradeoff [1], IMHO, that general answer is; having good organisation or management from all parts participants, discussion chairs and from directors. nor, as long as we keep trying to deal with things as collections of

Re: IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-24 Thread SM
At 20:42 23-05-2013, Jorge Amodio wrote: Taking the IETF meeting to Buenos Aires is not a bad idea, but when the meeting is over the root problem will still be there. Jari Arkko is the Chair of the IETF. He asked the following questions (

Re: IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-24 Thread Jari Arkko
Vinayak, Maybe several co-located meetings or having people from the IETF speak at universities and regional ISOC chapters around the meeting might help. Also showcasing the good work done by their Latin American peers might help as well. Good ideas. Thanks. Jari

Re: IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-24 Thread Arturo Servin
On 5/24/13 3:05 AM, SM wrote: Just meeting in some place does not bring too many new participants, at least not in a lasting manner. But combined with some other actions, this may be possible. Are there specific companies or research teams that we could reach out to, and who

Re: IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-24 Thread Michael Richardson
The == The IAOC bob.hin...@gmail.com writes: The The venues are in Buenos Aires. They meet our requirements for the meeting The space, networking, nearby restaurants and bars, hotel room rates in the mid $200 The dollar range, nearby alternate hotels at a broad range of prices,

Re: IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-24 Thread Arturo Servin
Where are you flying from? There are direct flights from Miami, Dallas, Toronto, Washington and other hubs to Buenos Aires. Regards, as On 5/24/13 11:12 AM, Michael Richardson wrote: The == The IAOC bob.hin...@gmail.com writes: The The venues are in Buenos Aires.

Re: IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-24 Thread Juliao Braga
Also, there are several events in each country that can be used to disseminate the actions of IETF. In Brazil, for example, the events linked to universities and research centers are promoted by the Brazilian Computer Society (a lot of). Other less formal events but with participation of people

Re: IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-24 Thread Alejandro Acosta
Hello, Just a small comment: On 5/23/13, Jari Arkko jari.ar...@piuha.net wrote: For what it is worth, I wanted to provide my perspective on this. I of course believe that it is important that the IETF reaches out to an even {...} Just meeting in some place does not bring too many new

Re: IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-24 Thread SM
Hi Juliao, At 18:34 23-05-2013, Juliao Braga wrote: I stare at the map of where the IETF meetings occurred (http://ws.org.br/index.php/IETF_Meetings) and wondering if the fact of bringing some of the meetings to below the Equator could lead to increase people participation. That's a nice map.

  1   2   >