Re: On the confidentiality of the information and communication within the nomcom context

2008-03-19 Thread Alexey Melnikov
Dave Crocker wrote: Michael StJohns wrote: At 10:46 PM 3/17/2008, Harald Tveit Alvestrand wrote: *The names of people nominated should be made public. *The names of the people who agreed to serve if selected should be kept secret. +1 Open enough to get feedback, but kind to

Re: On the confidentiality of the information and communication within the nomcom context

2008-03-18 Thread Michael StJohns
At 10:46 PM 3/17/2008, Harald Tveit Alvestrand wrote: *The names of people nominated should be made public. *The names of the people who agreed to serve if selected should be kept secret. +1 Open enough to get feedback, but kind to the rejected candidates.

Re: On the confidentiality of the information and communication within the nomcom context

2008-03-18 Thread Dave Crocker
Michael StJohns wrote: At 10:46 PM 3/17/2008, Harald Tveit Alvestrand wrote: *The names of people nominated should be made public. *The names of the people who agreed to serve if selected should be kept secret. +1 Open enough to get feedback, but kind to the rejected candidates. +1

Re: On the confidentiality of the information and communication within the nomcom context

2008-03-18 Thread Brian E Carpenter
On 2008-03-19 15:23, Dave Crocker wrote: Michael StJohns wrote: At 10:46 PM 3/17/2008, Harald Tveit Alvestrand wrote: *The names of people nominated should be made public. *The names of the people who agreed to serve if selected should be kept secret. +1 Open enough to get feedback, but

Re: On the confidentiality of the information and communication within the nomcom context

2008-03-18 Thread Dave Crocker
Brian E Carpenter wrote: On 2008-03-19 15:23, Dave Crocker wrote: Michael StJohns wrote: At 10:46 PM 3/17/2008, Harald Tveit Alvestrand wrote: *The names of people nominated should be made public. *The names of the people who agreed to serve if selected should be kept secret. +1 Open

Re: On the confidentiality of the information and communication within the nomcom context

2008-03-18 Thread Brian E Carpenter
On 2008-03-19 16:40, Dave Crocker wrote: Brian E Carpenter wrote: On 2008-03-19 15:23, Dave Crocker wrote: Michael StJohns wrote: At 10:46 PM 3/17/2008, Harald Tveit Alvestrand wrote: *The names of people nominated should be made public. *The names of the people who agreed to serve if

Re: On the confidentiality of the information and communication within the nomcom context

2008-03-18 Thread Dave Crocker
Brian E Carpenter wrote: At 10:46 PM 3/17/2008, Harald Tveit Alvestrand wrote: *The names of people nominated should be made public. *The names of the people who agreed to serve if selected should be kept secret. ... Brian, many thinks are easy to say without thinking things through. Or

Re: On the confidentiality of the information and communication within the nomcom context

2008-03-17 Thread Lakshminath Dondeti
I have been a bit under the weather and responding to some of the emails. I hope to catch up in the next couple of days. On 3/16/2008 1:56 PM, Brian E Carpenter wrote: Hi Lakshimnath, just a few notes and queries... On 2008-03-16 16:10, Lakshminath Dondeti wrote: ... * Nominee lists

Re: On the confidentiality of the information and communication within the nomcom context

2008-03-17 Thread Harald Tveit Alvestrand
Brian E Carpenter skrev: Hi Lakshimnath, just a few notes and queries... On 2008-03-16 16:10, Lakshminath Dondeti wrote: ... * Nominee lists should be made public. In fact, other selection processes within the IETF make the candidate lists public and so it is time we let go of this

Re: On the confidentiality of the information and communication within the nomcom context

2008-03-16 Thread Brian E Carpenter
Hi Lakshimnath, just a few notes and queries... On 2008-03-16 16:10, Lakshminath Dondeti wrote: ... * Nominee lists should be made public. In fact, other selection processes within the IETF make the candidate lists public and so it is time we let go of this in the nomcom context. The case

Re: On the confidentiality of the information and communication within the nomcom context

2008-03-16 Thread Ole Jacobsen
Inline: On Mon, 17 Mar 2008, Brian E Carpenter wrote: Hi Lakshimnath, just a few notes and queries... On 2008-03-16 16:10, Lakshminath Dondeti wrote: ... * Nominee lists should be made public. In fact, other selection processes within the IETF make the candidate lists public and so

On the confidentiality of the information and communication within the nomcom context

2008-03-15 Thread Lakshminath Dondeti
I understand that there is work underway on the topic of revising 3777 and I have also had several discussions with various folks on this topic. With no intention to undermine the work already underway, I will briefly state some of my thoughts. * Nominee lists should be made public. In fact,

Re: On the confidentiality of the information and communication within the nomcom context

2008-03-15 Thread Danny McPherson
On Mar 15, 2008, at 9:10 PM, Lakshminath Dondeti wrote: I understand that there is work underway on the topic of revising 3777 and I have also had several discussions with various folks on this topic. With no intention to undermine the work already underway, I will briefly state some of