Re: Is WAP mobile Internet??

2000-07-11 Thread Doug Royer
TSIGARIDAS PANAGIOTIS wrote: I believe, I found part of the following text in WAP Forum's WEB-pages. However, I think the answer -from business and technology point of view- is simple; Is WAP mobile Internet ? Yes and NO WAP is using existing Internet standards. The WAP architecture

RE: Is WAP mobile Internet??

2000-07-06 Thread arindam . das
EMAIL PROTECTED]'" [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: RE: Is WAP mobile Internet?? Wellas I see it, and belive me I may be wrong 'Its been known' :-) This been the IETF talks about well Internet ... I disagree, WAP, Wireless Application Protocol, Its a way of transmitting data I.E. to and fr

Re: Is WAP mobile Internet??

2000-07-06 Thread Aditya Mohan
will not get a prize "Parkinson, Jonathan" [EMAIL PROTECTED] on 06-07-2000 03:30:32 PM To: 'Jon Crowcroft' [EMAIL PROTECTED] cc: "'[EMAIL PROTECTED]'" [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: RE: Is WAP mobile Internet?? Wellas I see it, and belive me I may be w

Re: Is WAP mobile Internet??

2000-07-06 Thread Keith Moore
Does it need to be if the Web/Wap app can handle this format? web/wap apps handle a very small number of protocols compared to the protocols that are handled by IP and used in practice. Keith

Re: Is WAP mobile Internet??

2000-07-06 Thread Joe Touch
Vernon Schryver wrote: think we mean having unincumbered availability of the common application protocols, email, http, ftp, ssh, ... that's not quite enough; in the UK we're seeing cable-modem ISPs attempt to restrict services to those applications, or to a subset of

Re: Is WAP mobile Internet??

2000-07-06 Thread Vernon Schryver
From: Joe Touch [EMAIL PROTECTED] ... would pacbell filtering all multicast at all CPE equipemt fall into your bucket, where do you draw the line? At IP, as Bob Braden said. SMTP is _over_ IP. Multicast _redefines_ IP (or portions of the address space thereof); it could be argued

RE: Is WAP mobile Internet??

2000-07-06 Thread Brijesh Kumar
Bob Braden writes: -Original Message- Jon Postel would have said: If it speaks IP (UDP/TCP are not necessary), then it's Internet, else not. I will add a bit to this discussion. 1. A WAP phone without an IP address is not an Internet device. And, no one claims so. 2. A WAP device

Re: Is WAP mobile Internet??

2000-07-06 Thread Joe Touch
Vernon Schryver wrote: From: Joe Touch [EMAIL PROTECTED] ... would pacbell filtering all multicast at all CPE equipemt fall into your bucket, where do you draw the line? At IP, as Bob Braden said. SMTP is _over_ IP. Multicast _redefines_ IP (or portions of the

Re: Is WAP mobile Internet??

2000-07-06 Thread Masataka Ohta
Joe; would pacbell filtering all multicast at all CPE equipemt fall into your bucket, where do you draw the line? At IP, as Bob Braden said. SMTP is _over_ IP. Wrong. RFC821 says: SMTP is independent of the particular transmission subsystem and requires only a reliable

RE: Is WAP mobile Internet??

2000-07-05 Thread Taylor, Johnny
Great Catch. It doesn't get any more Mobile on the Internet then that! -Original Message- From: Parkinson, Jonathan [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]] Sent: Friday, June 30, 2000 8:24 AM To: 'Lars-Erik Jonsson'; [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: RE: Is WAP mobile Internet?? Okay WAP at the moment

RE: Is WAP mobile Internet??

2000-07-05 Thread Taylor, Johnny
Good Point I will tap into Japan Wireless infra-structure! -Original Message- From: Renfield Kuroda [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]] Sent: Friday, June 30, 2000 9:07 PM To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: Is WAP mobile Internet?? I don't think WAP Mobile Internet any more than TCP/IP

RE: Is WAP mobile Internet??

2000-07-05 Thread Taylor, Johnny
The Internet allows all protocols to in-operate with her. This is the uniqueness of the web. Therefore WAP falls within this area! -Original Message- From: Lars-Erik Jonsson [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]] Sent: Friday, June 30, 2000 7:54 AM To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Is WAP mobile

RE: Is WAP mobile Internet??

2000-07-05 Thread Ashutosh Agarwal
PROTECTED] Subject: Re: Is WAP mobile Internet?? The Web is NOT the Internet. The Web is one Internet application. /L-E The Internet allows all protocols to in-operate with her. This is the uniqueness of the web. Therefore WAP falls within this area! -Original Message

RE: Is WAP mobile Internet??

2000-07-05 Thread Parkinson, Jonathan
To: 'Taylor, Johnny' Cc: '[EMAIL PROTECTED]' Subject: RE: Is WAP mobile Internet?? Hi all, I fully agree with Lars. Even I believe WAP does not fall under the Internet Umbrella Ashutosh Agarwal e-mail : [EMAIL PROTECTED

RE: Is WAP mobile Internet??

2000-07-05 Thread Randy Bush
if i have a device which can only send and receive email, am i "on the internet?" if i have a device that lets me send and receive messages to/from internet users, am i "on the internet" note that sms with a gateway satisfies the last one. my point is not to push sms or whatever. but that by

RE: Is WAP mobile Internet??

2000-07-05 Thread Steven Cotton
On Wed, 5 Jul 2000, Stewart Nolan wrote: The web sits atop the internet, as do the protocols mentioned, as does WAP. Yes - the Internet in my mind is just a collection of protocols, be they what they may. Over what physical medium data travel is irrelevant, but doesn't the term "on the

RE: Is WAP mobile Internet??

2000-07-05 Thread Dawson, Peter D
--Original Message- -From: Jon Crowcroft [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]] -Sent: Wednesday, July 05, 2000 11:19 AM -To: Parkinson, Jonathan -Cc: '[EMAIL PROTECTED]'; [EMAIL PROTECTED] -Subject: Re: Is WAP mobile Internet?? - - - -In message -[EMAIL PROTECTED], -"Parkinson, Jonathan&q

Re: Is WAP mobile Internet??

2000-07-05 Thread Jon Crowcroft
Jon, I wonder how WAP will fit into Multicast apps - even if its single line txt based msg's app ? football scores/(tennis etc) share price (look at stockbroker trading terminal - they have very small amount of realestate for the given instrument) many many things would work v. well -

RE: Is WAP mobile Internet??

2000-07-05 Thread Vernon Schryver
From: Lloyd Wood [EMAIL PROTECTED] ... my point is not to push sms or whatever. but that by "on the internet" i think we mean having unincumbered availability of the common application protocols, email, http, ftp, ssh, ... that's not quite enough; in the UK we're seeing cable-modem

RE: Is WAP mobile Internet??

2000-07-05 Thread Rick H Wesson
Vernon, would pacbell filtering all multicast at all CPE equipemt fall into your bucket, where do you draw the line? -rick On Wed, 5 Jul 2000, Vernon Schryver wrote: From: Lloyd Wood [EMAIL PROTECTED] ... my point is not to push sms or whatever. but that by "on the internet" i

Re: Is WAP mobile Internet??

2000-07-05 Thread Bob Braden
* From [EMAIL PROTECTED] Wed Jul 5 08:58:47 2000 * To: "Parkinson, Jonathan" [EMAIL PROTECTED] * cc: "'[EMAIL PROTECTED]'" [EMAIL PROTECTED], [EMAIL PROTECTED] * Subject: Re: Is WAP mobile Internet?? * In-reply-to: Your message of "Wed, 05 Jul 2000 15:15:1

Re: Is WAP mobile Internet??

2000-07-05 Thread George Michaelson
Jon Postel would have said: If it speaks IP (UDP/TCP are not necessary), then it's Internet, else not. I thought part of the argument was about capitalization of the I. if its lowercase, then its using IP, if its uppercase then you can expect to use global Internet addresses and achieve a

Re: Is WAP mobile Internet??

2000-06-30 Thread Patrik Fältström
At 13.54 +0200 00-06-30, Lars-Erik Jonsson wrote: I would like to hear your opinions about how WAP people often say that WAP is "mobile Internet". Well, Ericsson do in their ads :-) :-) (I say to a person at Ericsson). From my point of view, you can (through a proxy service) access (some)

Re: Is WAP mobile Internet??

2000-06-30 Thread Renfield Kuroda
I don't think WAP Mobile Internet any more than TCP/IP is Internet. The Mobile Internet is data/communication devices you carry around with you. Here in Japan we have 8 million non-WAP mobile internet users, plus another 2 million WAP users, and the numbers are exploding. But, and I know this

Re: Is WAP mobile Internet??

2000-06-30 Thread Masataka Ohta
r e n; I don't think WAP Mobile Internet any more than TCP/IP is Internet. There is no such thing as WAP Mobile Internet. The Mobile Internet is data/communication devices you carry around with you. Here in Japan we have 8 million non-WAP mobile internet users, plus another 2 million WAP