Burger, Eric wrote:
IMHO, *way* too many I*E*TF work groups get chartered based on an idea.
We then spend tons of resources on figuring out if the idea will work.
We produce lots of half-baked documents with little basis in working
code. Then folks try implementing what's been spec'ed, find it
IMHO, *way* too many I*E*TF work groups get chartered based on an idea.
...
Standardize stuff that already works -- what a concept.
...
I don't care how the technology gets developed.
IRTF, vendors, universities, whatever.
The current model in the IETF appears to be: Your running
IMHO, *way* too many I*E*TF work groups get chartered based on an idea.
...
Standardize stuff that already works -- what a concept.
...
I don't care how the technology gets developed.
IRTF, vendors, universities, whatever.
The current model in the IETF appears to be: Your running
Eric,
--- [SNIP ---
-- IMHO, *way* too many I*E*TF work groups get chartered based on
-- an idea. We then spend tons of resources on figuring out if the
-- idea will work. We produce lots of half-baked documents with
-- little basis in working code. Then folks try implementing
-- what's been
PROTECTED]
Sent: Tuesday, January 10, 2006 12:03 PM
To: Burger, Eric
Cc: ietf@ietf.org
Subject: RE: Working Group chartering
Eric,
--- [SNIP ---
-- IMHO, *way* too many I*E*TF work groups get chartered based on
-- an idea. We then spend tons of resources on figuring out if the
-- idea will work. We
On 1/10/06 12:55 PM, Burger, Eric [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
Normally, I would agree, but in one area in particular where I'm active,
RAI, I've seen it all. There has been a ton of work that was
interesting and nice to have.
I'm going to hazard a guess here and suggest that that area has
more
--On tirsdag, januar 10, 2006 12:26:22 -0600 James M. Polk
[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
At 12:55 PM 1/10/2006 -0500, Burger, Eric wrote:
Also, I am a big proponent of microeconomics, which would have rational
actors only put forth and push stuff clearly needed for products.
HOWEVER, in the
IMHO, *way* too many I*E*TF work groups get chartered based on an idea.
We then spend tons of resources on figuring out if the idea will work.
We produce lots of half-baked documents with little basis in working
code. Then folks try implementing what's been spec'ed, find it doesn't
work, but then
