[POLL] pop3d/nntpd and IMAP flags

2005-10-25 Thread Ken Murchison
The short discussion on pop3d not changing \Seen state got me thinking about the overall interaction of pop3d and nntpd with IMAP flags. It would be fairly straightforward to have an option that updated \Seen state whenever a POP3 client issues a RETR command or an NNTP client issues a BODY

Re: [POLL] pop3d/nntpd and IMAP flags

2005-10-25 Thread Igor Brezac
On Tue, 25 Oct 2005, Ken Murchison wrote: The short discussion on pop3d not changing \Seen state got me thinking about the overall interaction of pop3d and nntpd with IMAP flags. It would be fairly straightforward to have an option that updated \Seen state whenever a POP3 client issues a

Re: [POLL] pop3d/nntpd and IMAP flags

2005-10-25 Thread Joseph Brennan
Ken Murchison [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: It would be fairly straightforward to have an option that updated \Seen state whenever a POP3 client issues a RETR command or an NNTP client issues a BODY or ARTICLE command. I'm on the fence whether this makes sense for POP. But we've used U Wash for

Re: [POLL] pop3d/nntpd and IMAP flags

2005-10-25 Thread Henrique de Moraes Holschuh
On Tue, 25 Oct 2005, Ken Murchison wrote: It would be fairly straightforward to have an option that updated \Seen state whenever a POP3 client issues a RETR command or an NNTP client issues a BODY or ARTICLE command. I vote for this change, and if it is optional, I'd vote for it to be the

Re: [POLL] pop3d/nntpd and IMAP flags

2005-10-25 Thread Ken Murchison
Igor Brezac wrote: On Tue, 25 Oct 2005, Ken Murchison wrote: The short discussion on pop3d not changing \Seen state got me thinking about the overall interaction of pop3d and nntpd with IMAP flags. It would be fairly straightforward to have an option that updated \Seen state whenever a

Re: [POLL] pop3d/nntpd and IMAP flags

2005-10-25 Thread Ken Murchison
Henrique de Moraes Holschuh wrote: On Tue, 25 Oct 2005, Ken Murchison wrote: It would be fairly straightforward to have an option that updated \Seen state whenever a POP3 client issues a RETR command or an NNTP client issues a BODY or ARTICLE command. I vote for this change, and if it is

Re: [POLL] pop3d/nntpd and IMAP flags

2005-10-25 Thread Ken Murchison
Joseph Brennan wrote: Ken Murchison [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: It would be fairly straightforward to have an option that updated \Seen state whenever a POP3 client issues a RETR command or an NNTP client issues a BODY or ARTICLE command. I'm on the fence whether this makes sense for POP. But

Re: [POLL] pop3d/nntpd and IMAP flags

2005-10-25 Thread Joseph Brennan
Does UW simply mark the messages as \Seen after a RETR? I don't see any other way to determine if the user has actually read the message. imap first. message 131 is not \Seen. c fetch 131 flags * 131 FETCH (FLAGS (Junk)) c OK FETCH completed z logout * BYE okari.cc.columbia.edu IMAP4rev1