Re: [PHP-DEV] Allow properties to be defined on interface

[Saki Takamachi]

Hi Claude,

> For information, the question of properties on interfaces is covered by the 
> currently discussed RFC “Property hooks”: 
> https://wiki.php.net/rfc/property-hooks

I only half-understand that RFC. Thanks for pointing me out.

Regards.

Saki

[PHP-DEV] Allow properties to be defined on interface

[Saki Takamachi]

Hi Larry,

> This functionality is included in the Property Hooks RFC, which will be going 
> to a vote just as soon as Ilija finishes polishing up the test suite for it.  
> (I think he wants to get it into a "commit as soon as the vote passes" state 
> before we call the vote, even though that's not process-required.)

Oops, I haven't fully figured out that RFC yet and didn't realize my suggestion 
was included. Thanks for pointing that out!

Regards.

Saki

Re: [PHP-DEV] Allow properties to be defined on interface

[Saki Takamachi]

Hi Larry,

> This functionality is included in the Property Hooks RFC, which will be going 
> to a vote just as soon as Ilija finishes polishing up the test suite for it.  
> (I think he wants to get it into a "commit as soon as the vote passes" state 
> before we call the vote, even though that's not process-required.)

Oops, I haven't fully figured out that RFC yet and didn't realize my suggestion 
was included. Thanks for pointing that out!

Regards.

Saki

Re: [PHP-DEV] Allow properties to be defined on interface

[Claude Pache]

> Le 28 mars 2024 à 16:03, Saki Takamachi  a écrit :
> 
> Therefore, I propose to allow public properties to be defined on the 
> interface (It does not matter whether it is read-only or not).
> 


Hi, 

For information, the question of properties on interfaces is covered by the 
currently discussed RFC “Property hooks”: 
https://wiki.php.net/rfc/property-hooks 

—Claude

Re: [PHP-DEV] Allow properties to be defined on interface

[Larry Garfield]

On Thu, Mar 28, 2024, at 3:03 PM, Saki Takamachi wrote:
> Hi internals,
>
> With read-only properties, we no longer need to define getter methods 
> when we can take advantage of them.
>
> However, there is still one problem here from a convenience standpoint. 
> That is if we use an interface, we still need to define a getter method.
>
> This was mentioned by @sakurairo in X
>
>
> Therefore, I propose to allow public properties to be defined on the 
> interface (It does not matter whether it is read-only or not).
>
> I would like to hear your feedback.
> Also, if a similar discussion has taken place before, I would 
> appreciate it if you could let me know.
>
> Regards.
>
> Saki

This functionality is included in the Property Hooks RFC, which will be going 
to a vote just as soon as Ilija finishes polishing up the test suite for it.  
(I think he wants to get it into a "commit as soon as the vote passes" state 
before we call the vote, even though that's not process-required.)

https://wiki.php.net/rfc/property-hooks#interfaces

--Larry Garfield

[PHP-DEV] Allow properties to be defined on interface

[Saki Takamachi]

Hi internals,

With read-only properties, we no longer need to define getter methods when we 
can take advantage of them.

However, there is still one problem here from a convenience standpoint. That is 
if we use an interface, we still need to define a getter method.

This was mentioned by @sakurairo in X


Therefore, I propose to allow public properties to be defined on the interface 
(It does not matter whether it is read-only or not).

I would like to hear your feedback.
Also, if a similar discussion has taken place before, I would appreciate it if 
you could let me know.

Regards.

Saki