Re: JESS: Design Problem : Java or not Java ?

2002-12-28 Thread James C. Owen
Ernest: All I can say to this is, "A M E N ! ! !" On one of my projects I had a young Java programmer (six months of Java and two months of Rules) who absolutely insisted that it was OK to change an object outside of the rules, even though manufacture manuals and manufacturer tech support (and Dr

Re: JESS: Design Problem : Java or not Java ?

2002-12-28 Thread Bonnet Emmanuel
[EMAIL PROTECTED] a icrit : > > But using XML would help me to have : > > . a XML black box with predefined entries > > Not sure what this one means. I meant the rule engine would be seen from the outside system as a black-box exchanging data using XML-format. > > . as XML standards (RuleML) a

Re: JESS: Design Problem : Java or not Java ?

2002-12-20 Thread ejfried
I think Bonnet Emmanuel wrote: [Charset iso-8859-1 unsupported, filtering to ASCII...] > > My input and output are Java Objects. > So Java path should be the obvious choice. > > But using XML would help me to have : > . a XML black box with predefined entries Not sure what this one means. > . a

Re: JESS: Design Problem : Java or not Java ?

2002-12-20 Thread Bonnet Emmanuel
Jack Kerkhof a icrit : > Hi Bonnet, > > Your question is pretty wide open and will likely depend as much on the > context of this application as internal representation. If your source inputs > and outputs really are java applications, then the first makes sense. > Otherwise, there undoubtably wil

Re: JESS: Design Problem : Java or not Java ?

2002-12-19 Thread Jay Han
Bonnet Emmanuel wrote: Jay Han a icrit : Is your application standalone or does it work in a network eg client/server fashion? It will be on the server-side of a App Server application. Sounds interesting. Have you decided on what kind of appserver to use? I guess g

Re: JESS: Design Problem : Java or not Java ?

2002-12-19 Thread Bonnet Emmanuel
Jay Han a icrit : > > > Is your application standalone or does it work in a network eg > client/server fashion? It will be on the server-side of a App Server application. Emmanuel To unsubscribe, send the words 'unsubscribe j

Re: JESS: Design Problem : Java or not Java ?

2002-12-19 Thread Jay Han
Bonnet Emmanuel wrote: Hi, I am on the process of trying Jess with a Java application with its own model. I have a design Issue, right now I have 2 choices : 1) use the JavaBean capabilities of Jess -> in : JavaObjects -> middle : rule engine on Java Objects -> out: Java Object

Re: JESS: Design Problem : Java or not Java ?

2002-12-19 Thread Jack Kerkhof
Hi Bonnet, Your question is pretty wide open and will likely depend as much on the context of this application as internal representation. If your source inputs and outputs really are java applications, then the first makes sense. Otherwise, there undoubtably will be some additional context that t

JESS: Design Problem : Java or not Java ?

2002-12-19 Thread Bonnet Emmanuel
Hi, I am on the process of trying Jess with a Java application with its own model. I have a design Issue, right now I have 2 choices : 1) use the JavaBean capabilities of Jess -> in : JavaObjects -> middle : rule engine on Java Objects -> out: Java Objects 2) use Jess as a "XML