Re: [j-nsp] EX4200 virtual chassis problem, master going into linecard mode

2018-07-26 Thread Pavel Lunin
--> so then in a 2node VC one node is Master one node is backup > If they split the master will go down but the backup should survive as it > is > still half of the original cluster > > So this means you should make the part you want to survive to be the > backup-RE and not the master-RE > > ---

Re: [j-nsp] EX4200 virtual chassis problem, master going into linecard mode

2018-07-26 Thread Victor Sudakov
Alexander Marhold wrote: > Therefore if you want to put one node out of a 2 node VC you need to put the > Master down not the backup > Sounds strange but this is according to the rules stated below Interesting twist :-) -- Victor Sudakov, VAS4-RIPE, VAS47-RIPN AS43859

Re: [j-nsp] EX4200 virtual chassis problem, master going into linecard mode

2018-07-26 Thread Victor Sudakov
Tobias Heister wrote: > > > > Yes, no-split-detection did help. > > I would like to add to that. My point of view is that you do not > always disable split-detection in a two member VC. You can do so if > you know what that implies. > > The reasoning for the remaining node going into LC mode

Re: [j-nsp] EX4200 virtual chassis problem, master going into linecard mode

2018-07-26 Thread Alexander Marhold
Alexander Marhold Gesendet: Donnerstag, 26. Juli 2018 09:52 An: 'Tobias Heister'; 'Victor Sudakov'; 'Pavel Lunin' Cc: 'juniper-nsp' Betreff: Re: [j-nsp] EX4200 virtual chassis problem, master going into linecard mode Hi According to the documentation there should be the following behavior

Re: [j-nsp] EX4200 virtual chassis problem, master going into linecard mode

2018-07-26 Thread Alexander Marhold
[j-nsp] EX4200 virtual chassis problem, master going into linecard mode Hi, On 26.07.2018 09:06, Victor Sudakov wrote: >>> I don't like to explain what others say but I think yes. It's been known >>> behavior since always: in a two-member VC always disable split-detectio

Re: [j-nsp] EX4200 virtual chassis problem, master going into linecard mode

2018-07-26 Thread Tobias Heister
Hi, On 26.07.2018 09:06, Victor Sudakov wrote: I don't like to explain what others say but I think yes. It's been known behavior since always: in a two-member VC always disable split-detection. You can google for other threads on this in this list. It's always been kind of poorly documented.

Re: [j-nsp] EX4200 virtual chassis problem, master going into linecard mode

2018-07-26 Thread Victor Sudakov
Victor Sudakov wrote: > Pavel Lunin wrote: > > > > in a virtual chassis you could add: > > > > > > > > set virtual-chassis no-split-detection > > > > > > > > This will ensure that if both VC ports go down, the master routing > > > engine carries on working. > > > > > > Are you referring to

Re: [j-nsp] EX4200 virtual chassis problem, master going into linecard mode

2018-07-25 Thread Victor Sudakov
Pavel Lunin wrote: > > > in a virtual chassis you could add: > > > > > > set virtual-chassis no-split-detection > > > > > > This will ensure that if both VC ports go down, the master routing > > engine carries on working. > > > > Are you referring to "Scenario B" in > >

Re: [j-nsp] EX4200 virtual chassis problem, master going into linecard mode

2018-07-25 Thread Pavel Lunin
> > in a virtual chassis you could add: > > > > set virtual-chassis no-split-detection > > > > This will ensure that if both VC ports go down, the master routing > engine carries on working. > > Are you referring to "Scenario B" in > https://kb.juniper.net/InfoCenter/index?page=content=KB13879 ? >

Re: [j-nsp] EX4200 virtual chassis problem, master going into linecard mode

2018-07-25 Thread Victor Sudakov
Catalin Dominte wrote: > > > > > > I've encountered an odd problem with adding EX4200s (running 12.3R6.6) > > to Virtual Chassis with a nonprovisioned configuration file. [dd] > > > > Looks fine, doesn't it? However, if I later poweroff the Backup switch > > (BM0217040019), the current Master

Re: [j-nsp] EX4200 virtual chassis problem, master going into linecard mode

2018-07-25 Thread Catalin Dominte
If you only have 2 members in a virtual chassis you could add: set virtual-chassis no-split-detection This will ensure that if both VC ports go down, the master routing engine carries on working. Catalin Dominte | Senior Network Consultant Nocsult Ltd | 11 Castle Hill | Maidenhead | Berkshire

[j-nsp] EX4200 virtual chassis problem, master going into linecard mode

2018-07-25 Thread Victor Sudakov
Dear Colleagues, I've encountered an odd problem with adding EX4200s (running 12.3R6.6) to Virtual Chassis with a nonprovisioned configuration file. According to documentation, I zeroize the second switch, power it off, connect to the running switch and power it on. Some magic happens, and