Re: SATA support in Linux kernel's menuconfig

2010-02-08 Thread Andrew Benton
On 08/02/10 05:04, Simon Geard wrote: On Sun, 2010-02-07 at 14:42 +0530, Aditya Bankar wrote: Can The library libata be used during boot time? Can be, and should be. The Support for SATA option is very old, dating to when SATA was a new thing - libata was it's replacement, and should be used

Re: SATA support in Linux kernel's menuconfig

2010-02-08 Thread Aditya Bankar
- Original Message From: Simon Geard delga...@ihug.co.nz To: lfs-support@linuxfromscratch.org Sent: Mon, 8 February, 2010 10:34:23 AM Subject: Re: SATA support in Linux kernel's menuconfig On Sun, 2010-02-07 at 14:42 +0530, Aditya Bankar wrote: Can The library libata be used

Re: SATA support in Linux kernel's menuconfig

2010-02-08 Thread Andrew Benton
On 08/02/10 12:54, Aditya Bankar wrote: In lfs we haven't compiled libdata. Thus, I think, we will have to use Support for SATA. If I compile libdata how do I tell kernel that libdata must be used for SATA support? Do we need to use bootscripts? I'm not familiar with libdata. libata is part

Re: SATA support in Linux kernel's menuconfig

2010-02-08 Thread Ken Moffat
On 8 February 2010 11:09, Andrew Benton b3n...@gmail.com wrote: Well you must know something I don't. I have 3 computers that will not boot if I don't use CONFIG_IDE=y Of course, I use libata on the computers that can use it. But in my experience it's not true that libata supports all IDE

Re: SATA support in Linux kernel's menuconfig

2010-02-08 Thread Andrew Benton
On 08/02/10 15:04, Ken Moffat wrote: Supposedly, only power macs (i.e. 32-bit ppc) are not supported by libata, everything else ought to work (but, perhaps not any i586 or older machines). As with anything in the kernel, the technically correct answer is painful (post on lkml, be prepared

Re: SATA support in Linux kernel's menuconfig

2010-02-08 Thread linux fan
On 2/8/10, Andrew Benton b3n...@gmail.com wrote: On 08/02/10 15:04, Ken Moffat wrote: Indeed. I was wrong. They do work with libata. They were older machines that were working fine so I avoided the headache of altering their kernel configs. My first couple of attempts at getting libata to

SATA support in Linux kernel's menuconfig

2010-02-07 Thread Aditya Bankar
Hi, While doing make menuconfig, in chapter 8 lfs-6.5, I found the following: Support for SATA (deprecated; conflicts with libata SATA driver) I have SATA harddrive. If I don't enable this how would the kernel talk to SATA drive? Can The library libata be used during boot time? Thanks, Aditya

Re: SATA support in Linux kernel's menuconfig

2010-02-07 Thread Andrew Benton
On 07/02/10 09:12, Aditya Bankar wrote: Hi, While doing make menuconfig, in chapter 8 lfs-6.5, I found the following: Support for SATA (deprecated; conflicts with libata SATA driver) I have SATA harddrive. If I don't enable this how would the kernel talk to SATA drive? Use libata, the

Re: SATA support in Linux kernel's menuconfig

2010-02-07 Thread Simon Geard
On Sun, 2010-02-07 at 14:42 +0530, Aditya Bankar wrote: Can The library libata be used during boot time? Can be, and should be. The Support for SATA option is very old, dating to when SATA was a new thing - libata was it's replacement, and should be used for all SATA and IDE hardware these