[Lift] Re: [Lift committers] Re: Welcome Indrajit Raychaudhuri to the Lift Committers

2009-09-24 Thread Jeppe Nejsum Madsen
Indrajit Raychaudhuri indraj...@gmail.com writes: Moved over to main Lift list. Folks, for better handle on the context, please have a quick run through of the original message before coming to David's comments and my responses. Thanks, Indrajit Looks like a bunch of work, but I really

[Lift] Re: [Lift committers] Re: Welcome Indrajit Raychaudhuri to the Lift Committers

2009-09-24 Thread Heiko Seeberger
One comment re the scala versions: I don't know about maven, but for other build systems, I don't think this completely solves the problem. Indrajit was talking about Maven and how to improve the POMs (project description files which amongst many other information contain versioned dependency

[Lift] Re: [Lift committers] Re: Welcome Indrajit Raychaudhuri to the Lift Committers

2009-09-24 Thread David Bernard
Hi, removing scala from the direct dependency of project using lift will ease maintenance for user, I agree. But, IMHO : * It's not a good practice because it's like saying that you don't use scala-library directly, it's a transitive/indirect dependency. * project should list every direct

[Lift] Re: [Lift committers] Re: Welcome Indrajit Raychaudhuri to the Lift Committers

2009-09-24 Thread Kevin Wright
On Thu, Sep 24, 2009 at 11:44 AM, David Bernard david.bernard...@gmail.comwrote: Hi, removing scala from the direct dependency of project using lift will ease maintenance for user, I agree. But, IMHO : * It's not a good practice because it's like saying that you don't use scala-library

[Lift] Re: [Lift committers] Re: Welcome Indrajit Raychaudhuri to the Lift Committers

2009-09-24 Thread Jeppe Nejsum Madsen
Heiko Seeberger heiko.seeber...@googlemail.com writes: One comment re the scala versions: I don't know about maven, but for other build systems, I don't think this completely solves the problem. Indrajit was talking about Maven and how to improve the POMs (project description files which

[Lift] Re: [Lift committers] Re: Welcome Indrajit Raychaudhuri to the Lift Committers

2009-09-24 Thread David Pollak
As long as the changes you're proposing do not require changes to non-maven projects, I say go for it. Thanks for taking the time to answer the community's questions and for having such a well thought out proposal! On Wed, Sep 23, 2009 at 10:05 PM, Indrajit Raychaudhuri indraj...@gmail.com

[Lift] Re: [Lift committers] Re: Welcome Indrajit Raychaudhuri to the Lift Committers

2009-09-24 Thread Indrajit Raychaudhuri
On 24/09/09 2:59 PM, Heiko Seeberger wrote: One comment re the scala versions: I don't know about maven, but for other build systems, I don't think this completely solves the problem. Indrajit was talking about Maven and how to improve the POMs (project description files which

[Lift] Re: [Lift committers] Re: Welcome Indrajit Raychaudhuri to the Lift Committers

2009-09-23 Thread Indrajit Raychaudhuri
Moved over to main Lift list. Folks, for better handle on the context, please have a quick run through of the original message before coming to David's comments and my responses. Thanks, Indrajit On 22/09/09 4:56 AM, David Pollak wrote: Moved to the main Lift list. All in all, I like the