[Lift] Re: Welcome Jonas Bonér to the Lift committer s

My point was that so far Lift seems to be fine without it. When a problem crops up for which AOP appears to be the best or only solution, then it will be worth considering it. Until then, it is only change for change's sake, IMO, otherwise known as feature creep. I'm a fan of Occam: don't over

[Lift] Re: Welcome Jonas Bonér to the Lift committer s

I'd have to second David on this. If it ain't broke... David Pollak wrote: > > > On Mon, Mar 30, 2009 at 11:26 AM, Lee Mighdoll > wrote: > > Welcome Jonas! > > I'd been thinking that some judicious use of aspectJ might be a nice > fit for lift. Rumo

[Lift] Re: Welcome Jonas Bonér to the Lift committer s

Welcome, Jonas! David Pollak wrote: > Folks, > > Please join me in welcoming Jonas as a Lift committer. I had the > pleasure of meeting Jonas as QCon in London this month. Jonas, Tim, and > I went out a grabbed a few pints and chatted. I think Jonas has a lot > to contribute to Lift. > >

[Lift] Re: Welcome Jonas Bonér to the Lift committer s

On Mar 30, 9:53 pm, David Pollak wrote: > On Mon, Mar 30, 2009 at 11:26 AM, Lee Mighdoll wrote: > > > Welcome Jonas! > > > I'd been thinking that some judicious use of aspectJ might be a nice fit > > for lift.  Rumor has it you know something about aspects... > > AspectJ over my dead body.  :-)

[Lift] Re: Welcome Jonas Bonér to the Lift committer s

On Mon, Mar 30, 2009 at 8:33 PM, Josh Suereth wrote: > I think AspectJ compiler currently pukes on scala classes anyway (or at > least it did when Miles set up aspectj as a workaround the Eclipse JDT). That was certainly the case quite recently ... I filed a bug against AspectJ which as far as I

[Lift] Re: Welcome Jonas Bonér to the Lift committer s

I think AspectJ compiler currently pukes on scala classes anyway (or at least it did when Miles set up aspectj as a workaround the Eclipse JDT). So... no dice for AspectJ + Scala without using a Java "glue" class. On Mon, Mar 30, 2009 at 3:12 PM, Lee Mighdoll wrote: > Certainly, maintaining an a

[Lift] Re: Welcome Jonas Bonér to the Lift committer s

Certainly, maintaining an aspect compiler in the project would be hassle. Probably not worth debating AOP unless there's a case that really calls for it. My guess is that most uses of aspects will eventually get rolled into scala compiler plugins, anyway, but that aspectJ could be an interim strat

[Lift] Re: Welcome Jonas Bonér to the Lift committer s

On Mon, Mar 30, 2009 at 11:26 AM, Lee Mighdoll wrote: > Welcome Jonas! > > I'd been thinking that some judicious use of aspectJ might be a nice fit > for lift. Rumor has it you know something about aspects... > AspectJ over my dead body. :-) I think AOP is a dangerous and generally very bad th

[Lift] Re: Welcome Jonas Bonér to the Lift committer s

Welcome Jonas! I'd been thinking that some judicious use of aspectJ might be a nice fit for lift. Rumor has it you know something about aspects... Lee On Mon, Mar 30, 2009 at 11:15 AM, marius d. wrote: > > Welcome Jonas ! > > On Mar 30, 7:52 pm, David Pollak > wrote: > > Folks, > > > > Plea

[Lift] Re: Welcome Jonas Bonér to the Lift committer s

Welcome Jonas ! On Mar 30, 7:52 pm, David Pollak wrote: > Folks, > > Please join me in welcoming Jonas as a Lift committer.  I had the pleasure > of meeting Jonas as QCon in London this month.  Jonas, Tim, and I went out a > grabbed a few pints and chatted.  I think Jonas has a lot to contribute

[Lift] Re: Welcome Jonas Bonér to the Lift committer s

Welcome Jonas! :) Great to have you aboard! On Mon, Mar 30, 2009 at 6:58 PM, TylerWeir wrote: > > w00p w00p! > > Welcome! > > On Mar 30, 12:52 pm, David Pollak > wrote: > > Folks, > > > > Please join me in welcoming Jonas as a Lift committer. I had the > pleasure > > of meeting Jonas as QCon

[Lift] Re: Welcome Jonas Bonér to the Lift committer s

w00p w00p! Welcome! On Mar 30, 12:52 pm, David Pollak wrote: > Folks, > > Please join me in welcoming Jonas as a Lift committer.  I had the pleasure > of meeting Jonas as QCon in London this month.  Jonas, Tim, and I went out a > grabbed a few pints and chatted.  I think Jonas has a lot to cont