Re: Add original-breaks.ly commands (issue 150670043 by lilyli...@googlemail.com)

2014-10-09 Thread k-ohara5a5a
On 2014/10/09 08:11:29, uliska wrote: On 2014/10/08 05:01:40, Keith wrote: > Why not store the common music in a variable, and show > \score {\music} > \discaredOriginalBreaks > \score {\music} > ? Because it wouldn't work that way. \discardOriginalBreaks would be interpreted when the comma

Re: Add original-breaks.ly commands (issue 150670043 by lilyli...@googlemail.com)

2014-10-09 Thread Federico Bruni
2014-10-09 11:38 GMT+02:00 Urs Liska : > Because one wouldn't want to *finally* produce a version of the score with > the breaks of the original score. If that's my interest (which then would > actually be a "rather specific situation") I can simply use hardcoded > \break commands. > > The whole p

Re: Add original-breaks.ly commands (issue 150670043 by lilyli...@googlemail.com)

2014-10-09 Thread Federico Bruni
2014-10-09 12:41 GMT+02:00 Graham Percival : > On Thu, Oct 09, 2014 at 10:21:45AM +, tdanielsmu...@googlemail.com > wrote: > > I've not followed the corresponding email discussion closely, and maybe > > I've missed something, but how is this better than simply using \obreak > > for an original

Re: Add original-breaks.ly commands (issue 150670043 by lilyli...@googlemail.com)

2014-10-09 Thread dak
On 2014/10/09 10:21:45, Trevor Daniels wrote: It would also be trivial to remove all these editing aids finally with a simple global edits. I think the basic point was to get different aspects of the same document _without_ doing any edits on it. https://codereview.appspot.com/150670043/ _

Re: Add original-breaks.ly commands (issue 150670043 by lilyli...@googlemail.com)

2014-10-09 Thread Graham Percival
On Thu, Oct 09, 2014 at 10:21:45AM +, tdanielsmu...@googlemail.com wrote: > I've not followed the corresponding email discussion closely, and maybe > I've missed something, but how is this better than simply using \obreak > for an original break, and \nbreak for a new, required, break, having >

Re: Add original-breaks.ly commands (issue 150670043 by lilyli...@googlemail.com)

2014-10-09 Thread tdanielsmusic
I've not followed the corresponding email discussion closely, and maybe I've missed something, but how is this better than simply using \obreak for an original break, and \nbreak for a new, required, break, having defined obreak = \break nbreak = <> in order to obtain the original breaks. And t

Re: Add original-breaks.ly commands (issue 150670043 by lilyli...@googlemail.com)

2014-10-09 Thread Urs Liska
Am 09.10.2014 11:27, schrieb David Kastrup: Urs Liska writes: Am 09.10.2014 10:44, schrieb David Kastrup: Urs Liska writes: And I would really love to see that being part of LilyPond itself and not only possible to implement in a library. Firstly because I would like *all* LilyPond users

Re: Add original-breaks.ly commands (issue 150670043 by lilyli...@googlemail.com)

2014-10-09 Thread David Kastrup
Urs Liska writes: > Am 09.10.2014 10:44, schrieb David Kastrup: >> Urs Liska writes: >> >>> And I would really love to see that being part of LilyPond itself and >>> not only possible to implement in a library. >>> Firstly because I would like *all* LilyPond users to have that >>> available and

Re: Add original-breaks.ly commands (issue 150670043 by lilyli...@googlemail.com)

2014-10-09 Thread Urs Liska
Am 09.10.2014 10:44, schrieb David Kastrup: Urs Liska writes: And I would really love to see that being part of LilyPond itself and not only possible to implement in a library. Firstly because I would like *all* LilyPond users to have that available and secondly because I would like to add th

Re: Add original-breaks.ly commands (issue 150670043 by lilyli...@googlemail.com)

2014-10-09 Thread David Kastrup
Urs Liska writes: > And I would really love to see that being part of LilyPond itself and > not only possible to implement in a library. > Firstly because I would like *all* LilyPond users to have that > available and secondly because I would like to add this as a Layout > Control Option to Fresc

Re: Add original-breaks.ly commands (issue 150670043 by lilyli...@googlemail.com)

2014-10-09 Thread Urs Liska
Am 08.10.2014 00:30, schrieb nine.fierce.ball...@gmail.com: On 2014/10/07 08:37:06, uliska wrote: On 2014/10/07 08:37:06, uliska wrote: On 2014/10/07 08:37:06, uliska wrote: On 2014/10/07 08:37:06, uliska wrote: Important: * There should be regression tests. OK. (but only *if* the patch sh

Re: Add original-breaks.ly commands (issue 150670043 by lilyli...@googlemail.com)

2014-10-09 Thread lilyliska
https://codereview.appspot.com/150670043/diff/1/Documentation/notation/spacing.itely File Documentation/notation/spacing.itely (right): https://codereview.appspot.com/150670043/diff/1/Documentation/notation/spacing.itely#newcode1857 Documentation/notation/spacing.itely:1857: @end lilypond On 201

Re: Add original-breaks.ly commands (issue 150670043 by lilyli...@googlemail.com)

2014-10-07 Thread k-ohara5a5a
For this particular task, you should also show the user that he can define at the top of the input, or in a header file if he uses one, originalBreak = \break and insert before music where we are done with the original breaks, originalBreak = {} %\break That is easy enough to understand, and

Re: Add original-breaks.ly commands (issue 150670043 by lilyli...@googlemail.com)

2014-10-07 Thread dak
On 2014/10/07 22:30:53, Dan Eble wrote: * When using original breaks, wouldn't one also want original page size, staff size, etc.? That would not map well to tags. Not without additional facilities, I guess. Still, I think that tags at least address a large enough problem space that making

Re: Add original-breaks.ly commands (issue 150670043 by lilyli...@googlemail.com)

2014-10-07 Thread nine . fierce . ballads
On 2014/10/07 08:37:06, uliska wrote: On 2014/10/07 08:37:06, uliska wrote: On 2014/10/07 08:37:06, uliska wrote: On 2014/10/07 08:37:06, uliska wrote: Important: * There should be regression tests. Musing: * Why not use tags? (Example below.) * Does this implementation make it possible to s

Add original-breaks.ly commands (issue 150670043 by lilyli...@googlemail.com)

2014-10-07 Thread lilyliska
Reviewers: , Description: Add original-breaks.ly commands The commands defined in this patch allow the user to insert breaks (line and page) from the original manuscript that are conditionally respected or discarded. This is very useful for entering and proof-reading music from larger scores. A