Re: Lyric misalignment solved. Was Re: Lyric misalignment and beaming?

2020-01-14 Thread David Kastrup
Carl Sorensen writes: > On 1/14/20, 6:58 AM, "Arle Lommel" wrote: > > So schrieb David: > > > Either way is acting as it should. > > > > The manual has an index entry "beam, with lyrics" for the chapter > > "Setting automatic beam behavior" but there is no usable refer

Re: Lyric misalignment solved. Was Re: Lyric misalignment and beaming?

2020-01-14 Thread Carl Sorensen
On 1/14/20, 6:58 AM, "Arle Lommel" wrote: So schrieb David: > Either way is acting as it should. > > The manual has an index entry "beam, with lyrics" for the chapter > "Setting automatic beam behavior" but there is no usable reference > whatsoever in that chapter

Re: Lyric misalignment solved. Was Re: Lyric misalignment and beaming?

2020-01-14 Thread David Kastrup
Arle Lommel writes: > So schrieb David: > >> Either way is acting as it should. >> >> The manual has an index entry "beam, with lyrics" for the chapter >> "Setting automatic beam behavior" but there is no usable reference >> whatsoever in that chapter. I actually find rather little elsewhere >>

Re: Lyric misalignment solved. Was Re: Lyric misalignment and beaming?

2020-01-14 Thread Arle Lommel
So schrieb David: > Either way is acting as it should. > > The manual has an index entry "beam, with lyrics" for the chapter > "Setting automatic beam behavior" but there is no usable reference > whatsoever in that chapter. I actually find rather little elsewhere > either, there are mostly just

Re: Lyric misalignment solved. Was Re: Lyric misalignment and beaming?

2020-01-14 Thread David Kastrup
Arle Lommel writes: > Thanks very much to Carl Sorenson for a response that got me to start paring > things > down even more and led me to find the problem in my score where I didn’t > previously look. Took a while > > Basically, if autoBeam is off (somehow I’d turned it off outside a > variable

Re: Lyric misalignment solved. Was Re: Lyric misalignment and beaming?

2020-01-13 Thread Kieren MacMillan
Hi Arle, > Seems this is a bug unless there is a reason why lyrics should follow manual > beaming rather than slurs when autoBeam is off. Can anyone tell me whether I > should log this? Well, that would follow "traditional" (meaning pre-1900) engraving rules for vocal writing, when melismas we

Lyric misalignment solved. Was Re: Lyric misalignment and beaming?

2020-01-13 Thread Arle Lommel
Thanks very much to Carl Sorenson for a response that got me to start paring things down even more and led me to find the problem in my score where I didn’t previously look. Took a while Basically, if autoBeam is off (somehow I’d turned it off outside a variable where I was defining things), th

Re: Lyric misalignment and beaming?

2020-01-13 Thread Aaron Hill
On 2020-01-13 3:45 pm, Arle Lommel wrote: Does anyone have any idea what I should check to resolve this problem? I’ve tried everything I can think of with no luck. According to the docs, manual beaming will create melismata when automatic beaming is disabled. In your larger document, do you u

Re: Lyric misalignment and beaming?

2020-01-13 Thread Carl Sorensen
From: Arle Lommel Date: Monday, January 13, 2020 at 4:45 PM To: Subject: Lyric misalignment and beaming? Got a head scratcher here. Using 2.19.83, I’ve run into a problem where I *cannot* create a minimal example: The minimal example works exactly as it should and it is only in context

Lyric misalignment and beaming?

2020-01-13 Thread Arle Lommel
Got a head scratcher here. Using 2.19.83, I’ve run into a problem where I *cannot* create a minimal example: The minimal example works exactly as it should and it is only in context where things fail, but I have no idea what actually makes them fail, so I have no idea how to make a minimal examp