Re: [Spam] partcombine bug when using quoteDuring?

2018-02-20 Thread Rutger Hofman 

On 02/19/2018 08:09 PM, Nathan Sprangers wrote:
When both voices in \partcombine finish a \quoteDuring at the same time, 
only one voice is rendered for subsequent notes.


\version "2.18.2"

\addQuote "melody" \relative c'' {
   a4 a a a
   d d d d
}

\addQuote "alto" \relative c'{
   f2 f
   g2 g
}

\partcombine
   { \quoteDuring #"melody" s1
     \quoteDuring #"melody" s1 }

   { \quoteDuring #"alto" s1
     % This does not get rendered:
     \quoteDuring #"alto" s1 }


Confirmed for version 2.19.80.

Rutger

If the last line is changed to notes, they are rendered but the 
\quoteDuring for the same measure in the first expression is not. 
Lilypond does not throw any errors or warnings when compiling these 
examples. Using the << \\ >> construct does not cause this issue.


If the quote durations overlap, there is no bug:

\partcombine
   { \quoteDuring #"melody" s1
     \quoteDuring #"melody" s1 }

   { \quoteDuring #"alto" s2
     % No problem:
     \quoteDuring #"alto" s1. }


Thanks,
Nathan



___
lilypond-user mailing list
lilypond-user@gnu.org
https://lists.gnu.org/mailman/listinfo/lilypond-user

partcombine bug when using quoteDuring?

2018-02-19 Thread Nathan Sprangers 
When both voices in \partcombine finish a \quoteDuring at the same time,
only one voice is rendered for subsequent notes.

\version "2.18.2"

\addQuote "melody" \relative c'' {
  a4 a a a
  d d d d
}

\addQuote "alto" \relative c'{
  f2 f
  g2 g
}

\partcombine
  { \quoteDuring #"melody" s1
\quoteDuring #"melody" s1 }

  { \quoteDuring #"alto" s1
% This does not get rendered:
\quoteDuring #"alto" s1 }

If the last line is changed to notes, they are rendered but the
\quoteDuring for the same measure in the first expression is not. Lilypond
does not throw any errors or warnings when compiling these examples. Using
the << \\ >> construct does not cause this issue.

If the quote durations overlap, there is no bug:

\partcombine
  { \quoteDuring #"melody" s1
\quoteDuring #"melody" s1 }

  { \quoteDuring #"alto" s2
% No problem:
\quoteDuring #"alto" s1. }


Thanks,
Nathan
___
lilypond-user mailing list
lilypond-user@gnu.org
https://lists.gnu.org/mailman/listinfo/lilypond-user