Meantone confusion

2004-09-18 Thread Daniel Shoskes
I am trying to understand the meantone -1/6 tuning system which I do agree makes the lute sound better in most of the Ren repertoire that I play. I am a bit confused about the actual tuning process. I have read http://home.planet.nl/~d.v.ooijen/lgs/meantone.html I have used the fret positions

Re: Meantone confusion

2004-09-18 Thread Ed Durbrow
So my questions are: 1) Have I misunderstood something in the process? Should I be using a different tonic? I prefer to use the 1st/6th courses as a tonic unless I have to play with other instruments, then I use C, which amounts to the same thing except 2 cents flater. 2) What keys work and

Re: Meantone confusion

2004-09-18 Thread lutesmith
I'll go out on a limb here, Daniel, and please forgive me if you get better input elsewhere. Yes, I know it's a little bind moggling. First off, you might try using G or C as your tonic since more of your average lute music is in those scales. A is a little problematic since it often requires