RE: VIRGIL: Re: Ohio Girls, or: Back to Odysseus?

2004-10-04 Thread Shawn Smith
27;s not clear to me what religious fanaticism has to do with any of this. Are you suggesting that Eclogue 4 really is a prophecy of the birth of Christ? Shawn Smith -Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of fabio paolo barbieri Sent: Monday,

RE: VIRGIL: Re: Ohio Girls, or: Back to Odysseus?

2004-10-04 Thread Shawn Smith
> Yes, Aeneas has to sacrifice much, including personal > happiness; but that is the point, he *has to*, just as > Agamemnon, faced with a choice, *had to* sacrifice his > daughter. It is no use breezing in from another culture, or > even some other point within the same culture, and saying on

RE: VIRGIL: Re: Ohio Girls, or: Back to Odysseus?

2004-10-04 Thread Shawn Smith
en we *should* compare Aeneas to Abraham, Gilgamesh, and Beowulf. And it would be perverse to study medieval or Renaissance literature and ignore Aeneas's function in Christian culture. Shawn Smith > -Original Message- > From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] > [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]